Pin It
Favorite

From the Top 

Some see fire towers as the Adirondacks’ crowning glory; others say they mar the real view

Through a small break in the trees you can see it, but just barely. You charge ahead toward the gleaming silver tower squarely mounted at the summit of the trail. It’s what you climbed the mountain for. It’s what everyone climbed the mountain for.

At the destination, you crane your neck skyward and take in the 35 feet of steel. Five flights of stairs zigzag upward, encased in metal caging to prevent hikers from teetering on the wooden stairs and tumbling over the slim banisters. Giddiness and anticipation make you dizzy. The stairs beg you to climb them.

With each step, the ground feels exponentially farther away. The wind wails, flapping your pants like a flag in a storm. You know you can’t possibly be pitched from the tower, but you still feel unsteady. The tower’s cab can’t come soon enough.

Finally, its open hatch comes into view. Heeding the handwritten reminder to watch your head, you duck and enter. Immediately the air is calm; the cab’s windows are closed against the wind.

The panorama is breathtaking. You imagine what it must have been like for the tower’s earliest inhabitants — grizzled fire observers trained to spot smoke in the hills — to be surrounded by so much beauty. Sure, the hike up to this point was fun, but this is what you came for.

And so it goes with the 23 Adirondack peaks that claim public fire towers. While the 6-million-acre park offers innumerable hikes up and around its many summits, only a handful of those peaks can claim to be fire-tower mountains.

That number could decrease in the near future, pending the result of a dispute over the towers on two of the peaks — Hurricane Mountain and St. Regis Mountain. Regardless of the outcome, people’s love of Adirondack fire towers — for their mystique, their views and their history — is incontrovertible.

The New York Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) began erecting fire observation stations on the park’s summits after forest fires in 1903 and 1908 destroyed nearly a million acres of Adirondack woods. The first such station was built atop the 2180-foot Poke-O-Moonshine in 1912. Five years later, the state replaced the original station on the peak with a standardized steel tower.

Unlike western forests, which tend to be much drier and more fire prone than their northern cousins, the Adirondacks were historically considered “asbestos forests,” says David Thomas-Train, president of the Friends of Poke-O-Moonshine. But droughts, irresponsible logging practices and sparks from the locomotives that soon cut through the park made its woods more vulnerable. State officials realized that, to preserve and protect the region, they required some sort of warning system. The fire observation program was born.

“The installation of the towers marked the first state effort at land stewardship,” Thomas-Train says.

Over the years, the state built 57 towers within today’s Adirondack Park. Civilian fire observers and forest rangers manned them for six to seven months of the year, living in cabins on their assigned mountains and using jeep roads for vehicle access.

When observers spotted smoke, they would use an Osborne Fire Finder — an alidade-type sighting device attached to a round map table — to find the rough coordinates of the fire. They would then triangulate with two other towers to pinpoint its location.

In addition to spotting fires and serving as unofficial stewards of the mountains, the fire observers had another, more patriotic role. According to the 400-page “Fire Tower Study for the Adirondack Park” released in February by the DEC, New York’s fire towers, including those of the Catskills, were used in “aircraft spotting and detection” during World War II, the Korean War and the early days of the Cold War. The fire observers were considered part of the nation’s warning system and were acknowledged for their “unselfish contribution.”

By 1985, the state determined the fire towers and their unionized staff were too expensive and opted for aerial surveillance. The towers were all decommissioned by 1989.

Today, the use of light aircraft to spot fires has become outmoded, too. The need for aerial surveillance within the Blue Line “has been obviated by hikers with cellphones,” says Thomas-Train.

Steven Engelhart is executive director of Adirondack Architectural Heritage, a nonprofit historic preservation organization. He argues that, when it decommissioned the towers, New York lost a piece of Adirondack history. The fire towers were an emblem of the public’s willingness to care for a natural resource, he says. The humanmade steel structures are part of the regional vernacular.

“Many generations of local people were fire observers, and being up on the towers became part of the lore of the community around here,” Engelhart says. “A lot of local people connect the towers to families who worked there and feel strongly that that’s a part of their community.”

Today, 34 towers exist in the park — 20 in the Forest Preserve and 14 on municipal or private land — but not all are accessible. Some, like the tower atop Hurricane Mountain, have been closed to hikers pending necessary restoration. So far, 11 towers have been restored.

Work on Poke-O-Moonshine, which Engelhart considers one of the park’s “success stories,” began in 1997. With funds raised by volunteers, the wooden steps were replaced, as were the steel crosspieces. The group installed safety fencing and new windows to keep the weather out, and commissioned the building of a new map table and brass alidade. Inside the 7-by-7-foot cab, volunteers placed interpretive panels that detail the viewscape and explain the tower’s role in Adirondack firefighting. The tower was reopened in 2005.

In the early days of Poke-O-Moonshine’s restoration, says Thomas-Train, vandalism was rampant in the tower. The alidade was stolen and the walls were spray painted. The problem has tailed off thanks to SUNY Potsdam students who serve as summertime stewards, as well as an increase in public education.

Today, the fire towers have become one of the more popular hiking destinations in the Adirondacks, says Adirondack Mountain Club (ADK) spokesperson Paul Ertelt. Many of the mountains lack a significant view, and only from the fire towers can hikers get the perspective they’re looking for.

People plan their hikes around fire towers, Ertelt says. One of the club’s chapters sponsors a Fire Tower Challenge wherein hikers must climb and document at least 23 fire tower ascents — 18 of the 23 Adirondack Park summits and all five of those in the Catskill Park.

Though the fire towers are a unique cultural resource — and, according to Engelhart, an architectural asset — they are not without controversy. Two of the fire tower peaks — Hurricane and St. Regis — are located in state lands classified as Primitive and Canoe areas of the park, respectively. According to the park’s Master Plan, first adopted in 1972, such areas — along with those classified as Wilderness — should contain few if any humanmade structures that could mar their “primeval character.” Since the towers are considered “nonconforming,” the recent fire tower study recommends their removal “in conformance with Master Plan guidelines.”

The ADK supports this recommendation, but many other organizations — Engelhart’s and Thomas-Train’s, for example — do not. ADK’s board of directors voted in 2005 to oppose any changes to the Adirondack Park Agency’s Master Plan that would allow the nonconforming towers to remain. “It defeats the purpose of ‘wilderness’ if you see the works of man,” Ertelt says.

However, after a number of local groups voiced opposition to the proposed removal, the park agency began looking at legal ways to preserve those two towers. ADK does not support this reexamination, says Ertelt.

“[The towers on Hurricane and St. Regis] don’t really provide any particular benefit. You can’t use them, and both of those mountains have pretty good views,” Ertelt argues. “The towers don’t add anything. There’s nothing particularly unique about them. They’re not the oldest, newest, tallest, et cetera.”

Ertelt does concede that, if the towers are removed, they should not end up in the scrap pile as many others have. Ideally, he says, they would be relocated like those reassembled at the Adirondack Center, the Adirondack Museum and the Ranger School at Wanakena.

While fire towers might have raised some political hackles, the structures’ impact on the region is undeniable. On some of the more heavily trafficked fire tower mountains, such as Blue, Hadley and Rondaxe (Bald), which get nearly 50,000 visitors a year, hikers have to wait in line for a glimpse from the cab. There is something awe inspiring, even playful, about the towers. The structures and the views they provide instill a pre-digital-age sense of wonderment. Engelhart likens them to lighthouses.

“There are certain kinds of structures that we’re drawn to as people for the setting, the shape or the romance of them,” Engelhart says. “You don’t climb to the top of Poke-O-Moonshine and sit away from the other people. You climb the fire tower and you imagine yourself up there in 1925, looking for a fire.”

Want to climb the fire towers?

Hikers can climb to fire towers on the following Adirondack peaks:

Mount Adams — 3584 feet, Newcomb, Essex County

Mount Arab — 2545 feet, Piercefield, St. Lawrence County

Azure Mountain — 2518 feet, Waverly, Franklin County

Belfry Mountain — 1820 feet, Moriah, Essex County

Black Mountain — 2646 feet, Dresden, Washington County

Blue Mountain — 3759 feet, Indian Lake, Hamilton County

Cathedral Rock — 1700 feet, Wanakena, St. Lawrence County

Goodnow Mountain — 2685 feet, Newcomb, Essex County

Gore Mountain — 3583 feet, Johnsburg, Warren County

Hadley Mountain — 2675 feet, Hadley, Saratoga County

Hurricane Mountain — 3694 feet, Keene, Essex County

Kane Mountain — 2060 feet, Caroga, Fulton County

Lyon Mountain — 3830 feet, Saranac, Clinton County

Owls Head Mountain — 2780 feet, Long Lake, Hamilton County

Pillsbury Mountain — 3597 feet, Arietta, Hamilton County

Poke-O-Moonshine Mountain — 2170 feet, Chesterfield, Essex County

Rondaxe (Bald) Mountain — 2350 feet, Webb, Herkimer County

Snowy Mountain — 3899 feet, Indian Lake, Hamilton County

Spruce Mountain — 2005 feet, Corinth, Saratoga County

St. Regis Mountain — 2874 feet, Santa Clara, Franklin County

Vanderwhacker Mountain — 3386 feet, Minerva, Essex County

Wakely Mountain — 3744 feet, Lake Pleasant, Hamilton County

Woodhull Mountain — 2362 feet, Webb, Herkimer County

While hikers can climb to these fire towers, not all of them are open to climb up.

Got something to say? Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

Pin It
Favorite

More by Lauren Ober

About The Author

Lauren Ober

Lauren Ober

Bio:
Lauren Ober was a Seven Days staff writer from 2009-2011.

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Seven Days moderates comments in order to ensure a civil environment. Please treat the comments section as you would a town meeting, dinner party or classroom discussion. In other words, keep commenting classy! Read our guidelines...

Note: Comments are limited to 300 words.

Recent Comments

Social Club

Like Seven Days contests and events? Join the club!

See an example of this newsletter...

Keep up with us Seven Days a week!

Sign up for our fun and informative
e-newsletters:

All content © 2016 Da Capo Publishing, Inc. 255 So Champlain St Ste 5, Burlington, VT 05401
Website powered by Foundation