Book Review: Brain in a Jar: A Daughter's Journey Through Her Father's Memory | Books | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice

Seven Days needs your support!

Give Now

Book Review: Brain in a Jar: A Daughter's Journey Through Her Father's Memory 

Published April 3, 2013 at 10:49 a.m. | Updated April 18, 2017 at 3:07 p.m.


It can be hard to force yourself to read about something as profoundly depressing as Alzheimer’s disease. It’s not even like reading about cancer, which most readers can reasonably assure themselves they don’t have. If you’re over 40 — or younger, in the case of early-onset AD — and you forget something at the grocery store, you don’t have to be a hypochondriac to worry AD might be sneaking up on you.

The best writing about Alzheimer’s doesn’t just describe the universal symptoms that signal its onset. Rather, it chronicles the effects of the disease on the individuals afflicted and everyone around them, and depicts a before and after to show how people deal with this devastating disease. In other words, the best writing on Alzheimer’s tells family stories.

Brain in a Jar: A Daughter’s Journey Through Her Father’s Memory, Nancy Stearns Bercaw’s account of her father’s lifelong efforts to avoid the disease, is not just a good book about Alzheimer’s, and it’s not just a good family history. It’s a good book, period. The Burlington author recounts her father’s battle in concise, unflinching chapters that also provide a riveting backstory — even when you know how it will end.

Brain in a Jar starts with Bercaw’s father, Dr. Beauregard Lee Bercaw, sitting in his Florida home before his mind has slipped away. He makes his visiting daughter promise on the family Bible to kill him if he shows signs of Alzheimer’s. This book is both her response to that request and a lively tale of her father’s impact on her life. Beau, who lost his own irascible father to the same disease, was obsessed with preventing it throughout his adult life and his career as a neurologist. He kept his father’s atrophied brain in a jar on his desk as a symbol of that fight.

Though the man people knew as “Dr. Beau” came to see suffering and death as ubiquitous and inevitable, he believed diseases that took the brain were much more to be feared than ones that took the body. He passed that obsession to his daughter, beginning when she was too young to understand.

Nancy Stearns Bercaw describes herself as resembling her father more than anyone else in her family; as a result, by the time she was 6 years old, she knew all about Alzheimer’s. She’d also started to develop her own morbid fascination with brain-wasting diseases. This fear became so ingrained in the author by early adulthood that, when she was stricken with hallucinations brought on by altitude sickness and dysentery while traveling in Asia, her first thought was that AD had begun to destroy her mind.

Brain is full of stories that will resonate with any reader, though a few might cause some head scratching. One standout concerns the time Beau nearly wrecked the family boat, rendering it inoperable. Rather than admitting his mistake and calling the Coast Guard, he made his daughter — a competitive swimmer — pull the boat to safety.

Beau is a compelling, layered character with great strengths as well as flaws, and his daughter chronicles all of them with love and care. She details her father’s difficulty with expressing emotions — he could tell her he loved her only in a roundabout way — and recalls her shock when his slip into Alzheimer’s allowed him to say “I love you” for the first time. Until his senility, Bercaw consoled herself with the presumption that Beau must care about her; after all, this quixotic, unconventional father made sure she knew how to save a loved one by performing an emergency tracheotomy. She was 9 at the time.

Many of Dr. Beau’s friends and former patients didn’t know about his illness until Bercaw (an occasional contributor to this paper), wrote about it in the New York Times. Now she has documented his life in a compulsively readable book that shows what really made him tick. Readers whose families are contending with Alzheimer’s may find salve in Bercaw’s insights. And for anyone who is not, Brain in a Jar is worth reading simply because it’s a great story, well told.

"Brain in a Jar: A Daughter’s Journey Through Her Father’s Memory" by Nancy Stearns Bercaw, Broadstone Books, 208 pages. $24.95.

Nancy Stearns Bercaw reads from and signs "Brain in a Jar" on Saturday, April 6, 6:30 p.m., at Phoenix Books Burlington. Info, 448-3350.

From Brain in a Jar

After retiring from his neurology practice in Naples, Florida, my father spent hours a day doing math in his head. Even when I was visiting, he would sit silently on his leather recliner with his calculator, verifying the accuracy of his mental arithmetic and his memory of the results. He was trying to stave off what had killed his father. He rarely uttered the name of this disease to me — reserving the phrase “Alzheimer’s disease” for clinical use only.

What are you saving your mind for, Dad? I often wondered to myself. I’m here now, waiting to talk with you.

On one of those occasions, he suddenly looked up from his Sudoku game and stared at me intensely. I knew it meant that an extreme statement was forthcoming.

“Promise me something, Gal,” he said.

“Anything,” I answered.

“Swear that you will put a gun to my head if I wind up like my father.”

He was dead serious. He collected guns and kept them under lock and key. He knew I could shoot them because he had taught me how.

Before I could speak, he leapt up from his chair.

“Wait. Let me get the family Bible.”

My brain was unable to reconcile this request. It wasn’t fair or logical to ask a child to kill her own parent. But I knew fair meant nothing to my father.

In three decades as a neurologist, Dr. Beauregard Lee Bercaw had seen young people die of meningitis faster than their parents could get them to a hospital. He had scooped up uncurled gray matter off the emergency room floor hoping to stuff it back in the heads of accident victims. He’d pulled shrapnel out of the skulls of servicemen at Clark Air Base in the Philippines during the Vietnam War.

He came back into the room with the leather-bound King James Bible, which bears the names Nannie Dunlap and Nancy Scott in gold lettering.

“Swear to me,” he repeated.

I crossed the fingers on my left hand, just as I had done a hundred times as a kid to protect me from the wrath of lying to my Dad or God. Then, I put my right hand on the Bible.

“I swear,” I said, but privately vowed to one day tell the story of the man I couldn’t live without.

Got something to say? Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

About The Author

Kim MacQueen


Comments are closed.

From 2014-2020, Seven Days allowed readers to comment on all stories posted on our website. While we've appreciated the suggestions and insights, right now Seven Days is prioritizing our core mission — producing high-quality, responsible local journalism — over moderating online debates between readers.

To criticize, correct or praise our reporting, please send us a letter to the editor or send us a tip. We’ll check it out and report the results.

Online comments may return when we have better tech tools for managing them. Thanks for reading.

Keep up with us Seven Days a week!

Sign up for our fun and informative

All content © 2023 Da Capo Publishing, Inc. 255 So. Champlain St. Ste. 5, Burlington, VT 05401

Advertising Policy  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us  |  About Us  |  Help
Website powered by Foundation