Vietnam Flashback? | Inside Track | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice

Seven Days needs your support!

Give Now

Vietnam Flashback? 

Inside Track

Bernie Sanders

Published July 18, 2007 at 4:00 a.m.


The press conference had all the ingredients — the senator, the National Guard general, the chaplain and the psychiatrist. But, unlike in the 1960s, within hours the conference was online for any and all to see on Independent U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders’ very snappy website touting the Senator’s first-in-the-nation, $1 million annual grant for the Vermont Guard to identify Iraq war vets suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

It’s just what the doctor ordered, and Congress should appropriate $30 million more and take it national!

Fine. Sounded like apple pie and motherhood to this journalist, but things got a bit testy when the questions turned to policy.

Adjutant General Mike Dubie (brother of GOP Lt. Gov. Brian Dubie) insisted the military now speaks openly to the troops about PTSD before they leave Iraq to come home. Dubie told the press the military was determined not to stigmatize the affliction. But even though medical diagnoses are issued, Gen. Dubie adamantly refused to say how many Vermont Guard troops have been diagnosed with PTSD.

“You’re hung up on the numbers,” Dubie told Ch. 3’s Brian Joyce. “If Sen. Sanders gets a million dollars and we save one person’s life, it’s worth a million dollars. If you think we should justify how many people per dollar,” said Vermont’s Adjutant General, “I really don’t care about the numbers.”


Here we have a U.S. senator holding a press conference in the largest city in his state involving the hottest topic of the day — the Iraq war — and nobody wants to talk numbers?

It appears the prep-meeting before the press conference emphasized not giving out one fact in particular: the number of Vermont soldiers coming home from Iraq diagnosed with PTSD.

If one has that number, you see, one can calculate the cost per victim, and that was a dollar figure it appears Sen. Sanders was determined not to provide.

Forty years ago, Democratic President Lyndon Johnson was just as determined not to provide the facts to the public about what was really going on in South Vietnam. It was a truth so powerful, it caused LBJ’s decision not to seek re-election in 1968. But we’ve learned the lessons of Vietnam, right?

So we considered it a fair question to ask General Dubie his understanding of the justification for the latest shipment of Vermont Air Guard troops to the Iraq war zone. What exactly are they fighting for?

Not a question our adjutant general enjoyed.

“First off, we’re leaving the scope of what the conversation was supposed to be about today,” replied Gen. Dubie. “So I’m not going to discuss policy. What I will tell you is, we follow the orders that we are lawfully given, and we are on a deployment schedule and we are maintaining that deployment schedule.”

But in terms of “purpose,” we asked, “you’re following orders. Leave it at that?”

“I’ll say two things,” replied Gen. Dubie. “You make the allegation that the majority of the Vermont population is against the war. OK. That may or may not be true, but I will tell you this,” said Gen. Dubie. “It hasn’t minimized the fact that we have never, ever in the Vermont National Guard history seen such support for the men and women in uniform. They may be against the war,” conceded the Guard’s commanding officer, “but we have never been appreciated as much around the state.”

A lesson of Vietnam, right? That one could hate the war but not the warrior.

As for why Vermont troops are going to Iraq?

“We’re going because we’re on the rotation schedule,” said Dubie. “In the military at our level, we don’t make policy, we execute policy.”

Good soldiers. Just like in Vietnam, eh?

“And the policy is, we are involved in Operation Iraqi Freedom, Operation Enduring Freedom and a number of other operations around the world. And we are supporting our federal role in the U.S. military. That’s what we’re doing.”

And with that, Gen. Dubie and the other Veterans Administration officials rose and departed, leaving Vermont’s freshman senator to handle the “policy” questions from the Fourth Estate.

Sanders noted there will be a debate in the Senate this week on a timeline for bringing our troops home from Iraq.

“I believe this war is a war we should never have been in in the first place,” said Ol’ Bernardo. “We were misled. And I will do everything I can to bring our troops home as soon as we possibly can and will support the strongest legislation.”

Sanders said he agrees with Republican Sen. John Warner of Virginia who now says the original congressional resolution giving the Bush-Cheney White House the green light to invade Iraq has expired. A new one is needed.

The original congressional Iraq war resolution gave the White House authority to take out Saddam Hussein and his weapons of mass destruction.

Saddam Hussein has been executed. His WMDs, we learned, were nonexistent.

“A good point,” noted Sanders. “But actually, the most important point is, how do we bring our troops home as soon as we possibly can? And I will do everything that I can to see that that happens.”

When will GOP defection increase?

“We have a very split Senate on these bills,” said Brooklyn’s gift to the Green Mountains. “It doesn’t take 51 votes to pass. It takes 60 votes to stop debate, to have cloture. We’re not there yet, unless I’m very mistaken.”

But the leading socialist in the U.S. Congress — OK, the only socialist in the U.S. Congress — predicted mounting Republican defections from the dishonest Bush war train.

“In my view, Republican support for this war is weakening significantly,” said Sen. Sanders. “I think that in the not terribly distant future, you will see a group of Republicans from the House and Senate walking into the White House and saying, ‘Mr. President, we go home to our states and our districts, and the people no longer support this war. We are not with you. Bring the troops home!’

“There is momentum within the Republican Party,” said Vermont’s junior senator, “to understand that this war is not serving the best interests of our country.”

Maybe so, Senator, but it is painful to watch.

Yes, indeed.

“And the tragedy is,” said Sanders, “Iraq, in terms of suicide bombers, in terms of the use of IEDs, of tactics that weren’t used in the past, I think there is a lot of evidence to suggest that Iraq has become a university, if you like, in training for terrorists.”

Stop the presses!

Iraq is going to need a new name when the current civil war is over one day, right?

Looks like President George “WMD” Bush will have a lasting, inescapable legacy after all. One many will call “Terrorism University.”

Thanks, George. The C-student at Yale became an “education” president, after all, eh?

Bush Invite — President Bush’s speech at the Naval War College in Newport, Rhode Island, in late June leaves Vermont on its own as the only state in the Union he has not set foot in. It leaked out under questioning from “Inside Track” that Ol’ Bernardo has, in fact, personally invited Dubya to end the shut-out.

“Do I think it is a coincidence that this is the last state, the only state that the president has not visited?” asked Bernie with a grin. “No, I don’t think that it’s a coincidence. I think he understands that he is not enormously popular in this state.”

Sanders said he extended the invitation to Mr. Bush at a White House function a couple months ago.

“He is the president of the 50 states, and I hope he has the decency and the courage to come to the state of Vermont,” said Sen. Sanders. “That’s his job as the President of the United States and, furthermore, I hope he will do what he very rarely does. That is, in a respectful meeting, answer the questions that people have.”

Ah! Our junior senator watches C-Span! The President of the United States deserves to be treated with respect, said Sanders, but he should appear before the American people, not just sanitized, partisan audiences.

“One of the issues that has concerned me with regard to this president for many years,” said Sanders, “is, he keeps giving speeches into audiences which are not quite open to people who have different points of view.”

In his Vermont presidential visit, should there be one, Sen. Sanders said he hopes the president “would allow us to ask him questions.”

Fat chance, eh?


The Douglas Angle? — One reason President Bush should come to Vermont is that our governor is also a Republican!

And last week, Jim Douglas reminded everyone he is a skilled Republican indeed, as majority Democrats under the Golden Dome failed to override not one but two line-in-the-sand gubernatorial vetoes of bills dear to the hearts of Statehouse Democrats: climate change and campaign finance reform.

The Democrats, along with their pals at VPIRG and VNRC and other tree-hugger/leftist outfits, sustained what certainly appeared to be an embarrassing defeat. Gov. Douglas was able to publicly highlight the Dem-ocrats’ “two big losses.”

At Saturday’s Democratic Party State Committee Meeting, House Whip Floyd Nease took some heat from members of his party’s center core.

Can’t legislative Democrats count? If they knew they didn’t have the votes, why the hell did they convene the override session?

Floyd the House Whip admitted he knew the count. It’s his job to know. But leadership decided to proceed anyway.

“I think it was an opportunity to hold Gov. Douglas accountable,” said Nease, “even if we lost the votes.” The Whip pointed to the editorial supporting the Democrats and criticizing Douglas that ran in the following day’s Rutland Herald.

True enough, El Floydo, but fewer people read daily newspapers than used to. And the Rutland Herald isn’t even delivered to Big Bad Burlington anymore.

State Committee Member Bill Sander of Jeffersonville informed Nease and the others that last week’s two veto victories for Gov. Douglas provided little in the way of new information about him.

“The guy’s a fascist with a smile,” Sander told the state committee. The classic-car collector from Lamoille County told fellow Democrats that Gov. Douglas “comes out looking like an effective leader with a plausible explanation if you don’t look at it too carefully. And most folks don’t,” he said.

Nease the Whip also played the “part-time” legislature card at Saturday’s party meeting. On the Democratic Party’s failure to override on global warming legislation, Nease claimed, “There was an unprecedented effort by Entergy. The three largest, most powerful lobbying firms in Vermont were employed in this effort.”

Not so, and the Whip ate some crow over it this week during a phone interview with “Inside Track.” In fact, Entergy Inc., owners of the Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Plant in Vernon, only had one professional Statehouse lobbying outfit on their hired-gun dance card. It was the Burlington-based firm of Morris DeMag & McCarty.

Nice work, eh?

“Up in St. Albans,” continued Nease the Whip, before fellow Dems at the state committee gathering, “the publisher [Emerson Lynn] moderated a forum where it was really difficult for people who had a view other than his and other than Entergy’s to get their views heard. That’s the kind of work that went into this,” whined the Whip. “IBM worked very hard against this bill,” he told questioning Democrats.

Our impression was, the Majority Whip’s whining didn’t fly with the rank and file. The fact that Vermont Democrats just lost on global warming and campaign finance reform is an “inconvenient truth” that suggests Jim Douglas may be governor for quite some time. And the party’s Statehouse leadership may be feeling some heat from within.

Got something to say? Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

More By This Author

About The Author

Peter Freyne

Peter Freyne

Peter Freyne, 1949-2009, wrote the weekly political column "Inside Track," which originated in the Vanguard Press in the mid 1980s; he brought it to Seven Days in 1995. He retired it shortly before his death in January, 2009. We all miss him.


Comments are closed.

From 2014-2020, Seven Days allowed readers to comment on all stories posted on our website. While we've appreciated the suggestions and insights, right now Seven Days is prioritizing our core mission — producing high-quality, responsible local journalism — over moderating online debates between readers.

To criticize, correct or praise our reporting, please send us a letter to the editor or send us a tip. We’ll check it out and report the results.

Online comments may return when we have better tech tools for managing them. Thanks for reading.

Latest in Inside Track

Keep up with us Seven Days a week!

Sign up for our fun and informative

All content © 2023 Da Capo Publishing, Inc. 255 So. Champlain St. Ste. 5, Burlington, VT 05401

Advertising Policy  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us  |  About Us  |  Help
Website powered by Foundation