Listen Up, Burlington Telecom: Lessons From Other Municipally Owned Networks | News | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice
Pin It

Listen Up, Burlington Telecom: Lessons From Other Municipally Owned Networks 

Ed. note: Seven Days contributor Kevin Kelley penned this week's cover story about Burlington Telecom. We didn't have room for his sidebar about other cities that have experimented with municipally owned telecom systems, so we're posting it here on our blog. Kevin wrote the rest of this post.

A few of the more than 50 publicly-owned telecom systems around the country may offer lessons – either cautionary or encouraging – for Burlington's financially troubled network.

Provo, Utah, for example, was forced two years ago to sell off to private interests what it had billed as the nation's largest municipally-owned fiber-to-the-premises network. That outcome is cited by political opponents of city-run telecom operations as proof that such enterprises can and do fail – and may soak taxpayers for millions of dollars in the process.

Provo, a Rocky Mountain city with a population of about 120,000, financed construction of its system, known as iProvo, by issuing $39.5 million in bonds. Buildout was completed on time and on budget, according to Provo city spokeswoman Helen Anderson. About 12,500 of Provo's 30,000 homes and businesses eventually became customers of iProvo, with many of the rest signing up with Comcast or another private provider.

Marketing iProvo proved difficult, Anderson says, because the Utah legislature prohibited city-owned telecom networks from offering their own Internet, telephone or cable TV service. That and other issues resulted in the city having to provide a total of $8.4 million in subsidies over four years to meet iProvo's operating costs. Political criticism intensified, which further damaged the iProvo brand, Anderson adds.

The network was sold to a fledgling private company in 2008 for $40.5 million – enough to cover payments on the the iProvo construction bond but not enough to pay back taxpayers for the operating subsidies. The private company, known as Broadweave, soon encountered major problems of its own and merged with Veracity Networks, another private telecom firm. The city then had to provide a $1.5 million loan to help Veracity stay in business.

But a different community-owned system in the same state – the Utah Telecommunication Open Infrastructure Agency (UTOPIA) – is so far proving successful.

UTOPIA is a consortium of 16 Utah communities with a combined population of 500,000 that built a fiber-to-the-premises network. It's one of several municipally owned telecom entities in the United States that are demonstrating the opposite of the iProvo experience -- that city-owned systems can function as financially viable alternatives to private networks, says Craig Settles, a California-based telecom consultant.

One of the public systems, Bristol Virginia Utilities, was recently profiled by the Economist magazine. Using $9 million in federal and state grants, BVU expanded beyond its own base in Bristol to bring fiber to eight counties in Virginia's coal belt. And that move helped bring hundreds of new jobs to the region, the Economist reports. The magazine says both Northrop Grumman, a huge military contractor, and CGI, an international information technology consultancy, announced plans in 2007 to hire a total of 700 workers in a community that is part of the BVU fiber network. “Neither would have come without BVU's investment, which Northrop calls absolutely critical,” the Economist wrote.

The magazine quoted BVU boss Wes Rosenbalm as declaring, “Broadband is jobs.” (Rosenbalm declined through a spokeswoman to speak with Seven Days because, she says, he does not want BVU associated with a story about a troubled municipal telecom network. That would be BT.)

Jesse Harris, a Utah blogger ( who writes as an unpaid advocate for UTOPIA, said in an email interview that “one of two things has to happen for muni networks to be successful: they need a high take rate among businesses to be financially self-sustaining OR the municipality needs to treat it as a utility and assume the balance as a necessary cost. If one or both aren't there, you're pretty much hosed in the long-term since any telecom project, public or private, needs 7-10 years to see black ink. Sounds like Burlington hasn't done either.”

Settles, the California telecom consultant specializing in municipal systems, offers the same assessment. “The ability to sustain a municipal network rests with getting large institutions and businesses to sign up for it. Individual residents are never enough to sustain it,” Settles says. “The churn [turnover rate] is simply too high.”

Burlington Mayor Bob Kiss argues that BT should be focusing more on finding business customers. And that could prove crucial, Settles suggests, adding, “If you deliver services that the incumbent [Comcast, in Burlington's case] can't touch, and you structure your business plan around the quality of your services, then you have an inherent advantage over even the biggest competitors,” Settles says. “You can make the model work.”

--Kevin J. Kelley

Click here to read Kevin's cover story this week, "City on Wire: How Did Burlington Telecom Become a High-Stakes Balancing Act?" It includes op-eds by Art Woolf and John Franco.

Did you appreciate this story?

Show us your ❤️ by becoming a Seven Days Super Reader.

Got something to say? Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

Tags: ,

Pin It

More by Cathy Resmer

  • Social Sentinel, Burlington Code Academy and Maureen McElaney Win Awards at 12th Vermont Tech Jam
  • Vermont's Top Innovators Honored at Tech Jam 2018

    Social Sentinel, a Burlington-based company that identifies threatening content on social media, was among the winners of the 2018 Tech Jam awards, presented last Friday at the 12th Vermont Tech Jam. The prizes, given annually by the Vermont Technology Alliance, BTV Ignite and Seven Days, recognize leaders in the state's tech ecosystem. The awards ceremony was the culmination of a busy day at the free career and tech expo organized by Seven Days and presented by Vermont Works. Representatives from more than 50 companies and colleges talked with hundreds of attendees who walked the expo floor. Jeff Couture, executive director of the Vermont Technology Alliance, said he talked with job seekers from across Vermont and outside the state at the event, "including someone, suitcase in hand, who visited from North Carolina."
    • Oct 23, 2018
  • Inspiring Projects to See, Hear and Play With at the Vermont Tech Jam
  • Inspiring Projects to See, Hear and Play With at the Vermont Tech Jam

    • Oct 17, 2018
  • The Tech Issue — 2018
  • The Tech Issue — 2018

    • Oct 17, 2018
  • More »

About The Author

Cathy Resmer

Cathy Resmer

Deputy publisher Cathy Resmer is an organizer of the Vermont Tech Jam, and compiles a weekly tech e-newsletter every Monday. She also oversees HR, helps manage Seven Days' digital staff and oversees its parenting publication, Kids VT. In 2018, she designed and administered a statewide youth civics project, the... more


Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Seven Days moderates comments in order to ensure a civil environment. Please treat the comments section as you would a town meeting, dinner party or classroom discussion. In other words, keep commenting classy! Read our guidelines...

Note: Comments are limited to 300 words.

Keep up with us Seven Days a week!

Sign up for our fun and informative

All content © 2019 Da Capo Publishing, Inc. 255 So. Champlain St. Ste. 5, Burlington, VT 05401
Website powered by Foundation