click to enlarge
-
File: Daria Bishop ©️ Seven Days
-
The exterior of Burlington High School
The parent company of PCB producer Monsanto filed a legal motion on Monday requesting an emergency hearing to halt the demolition of Burlington High School until the company can fully inspect the premises.
The motion in U.S. District Court from Bayer is in response to an
October personal injury lawsuit filed by two former Burlington High School teachers, Tracy Rubman and Kathy Lothian. They claim that workplace exposure to PCBs — a toxic chemical manufactured by Monsanto for commercial use until the late 1970s
— caused them to suffer serious health problems, including reproductive issues and hyperthyroidism.
The Burlington School District filed a separate lawsuit earlier this month alleging that Monsanto encouraged customers to use PCB mixtures in construction materials "despite knowing that this would directly introduce PCBs into surrounding air and other construction materials, and onto nearby interior surfaces."
In November, Burlington voters approved borrowing $165 million to demolish the PCB-laden high school and build a new one, and the school district plans to begin work
next month. But in its motion, Bayer states that the district's timing doesn't give the company's consultants "a reasonable opportunity" to inspect the building and gather information critical to both the employees' and school district's lawsuits.
The high school campus is "a textbook example of unique, one-of-a-kind evidence that must be preserved until Defendants can inspect the school," the motion states. "For example, if the buildings are demolished, Defendants [sic] experts cannot inspect the building's mechanical systems, let alone assess how those mechanical systems operated when Plaintiffs were allegedly exposed to PCBs."
As soon as the company found out that the school district planned to begin demolishing the old high school in January, it reached out to the district with its concerns, issued a subpoena seeking documents it needed to prepare for an inspection, and tried four times via Zoom meetings to work out a reasonable timeline for the production of those documents and the inspection itself, according to its lawyers.
Though the school district has already provided the company with close to 40,000 pages of documents, the motion noted, a preliminary review suggests that "BSD is still nowhere near complying with the Defendants' subpoena."
Bayer suggested a March 15 deadline for exchanging documents and conducting an inspection as a "last ditch effort" to avoid court intervention, but the school district rejected the proposal, compelling the company to go the legal route, court papers state.
"The stakes are simply too high to play a game of chicken with a wrecking ball, especially when the delay being sought is reasonable and necessary," Bayer attorneys wrote in the motion.
On Tuesday, Burlington School District declined to comment on Bayer's counterpunch.