On the Fly: In Improv, the Perfect is the Enemy of the Funny | Performing Arts | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice

Seven Days needs your financial support!

On the Fly: In Improv, the Perfect is the Enemy of the Funny 

Published May 15, 2013 at 9:05 a.m.


You’re standing in a small studio with two people you barely know, preparing to act a scene set on a desert island. One of your companions must speak exclusively in rhymes in this scene; the other must pretend to be a mind reader. Your character is endowed with hooks for hands.

There’s no script to follow. Just be sure that, by the end of the scene, the audience knows exactly what these three characters mean to one another, why they’re on the island and what they want. Make sure to highlight their assigned quirks.

Oh, and make it funny.

When you’re improvising, the last part is usually the one you think about the least. If you follow the rules of the game and throw your inhibitions to the wind, you’re almost guaranteed to make a generous audience laugh.

That’s what I’ve learned over nearly a year of attending the Wednesday-night Improv Drop-In group at Burlington’s Spark Arts. The informal, entry-level class is run by Spark Arts cofounders Nathan Hartswick and Natalie Miller, who also offer higher-level classes in improvisation and a range of instruction in standup comedy, acting and music at their recently expanded Flynn Avenue studio.

Hartswick and Miller have their own Spark Improv Troupe — which will perform during the upcoming 2013 Green Mountain Comedy Festival — and they encourage their students to troupe up and get onstage, too. For many of the regulars at Improv Drop-In, that’s a natural next step. They’re theatrical extroverts whose everyday conversation has the rhythms of a comedy sketch.

Which is why I’ve often asked myself on Wednesday nights, What the hell am I doing here?

People invariably describe me as “shy” or “reserved.” I prefer email to phone communications because I can edit it. “On the fly” or “seat of the pants” has never described my chosen way of doing anything. And decades ago, when I made the mistake of taking a graded class in improv, I earned a C-plus, the worst course mark of my academic career.

I remember how desperately the instructor — a member of the successful improv troupe War Babies and a bit player in movies such as This Is Spinal Tap — tried to get me to loosen up. In one exercise, where group members impersonated linked mechanical parts, he ordered the class to embody a giant “Margot Makes Her Debut” machine. It was a disaster.

When I arrived at the Spark Arts drop-in, I hadn’t done improv since I was 14 — and felt like that awkward middle schooler again. But, as an adult, I sought the rush that comes from stepping way outside your comfort zone.

To my relief, the atmosphere at Spark Arts was relaxed and supportive. Hartswick and Miller take care not to put anyone in the hot seat, and they offer lots of positive reinforcement along with guidance.

Sure, I sucked. I could only marvel at the regulars who slipped seamlessly into new characters and never fumbled for words. But accepting that 90 percent of what comes out of your mouth when you do improv is going to suck — or, if you let it, become beauteous nonsense — may just be part of the deal.

As I returned week after week, I started thinking about why a profoundly unspontaneous person would attempt an art of spontaneity — and reached some preliminary conclusions.

Improv is “let’s pretend” for adults. Be a pirate! Explore an alligator swamp with a demented guide! Leave your lover in the most dramatic way possible! Improv games allow you to do all this and more, provided you follow basic rules, starting with the cardinal principle of “Yes, and…” This means that, if a scene partner informs you that you are a pair of foot-fetishist cannibals, you may not reply, “Um, no.” Your answer should be more along the lines of “Mmm, that dude’s pinky toes look scrumptious.”

To give method to the madness, you must also work to establish the scene’s basic parameters: character, relationship, objective, when and where (handily abbreviated on Spark’s whiteboard as CROWW). The audience needs to know whether those foot-fetishist cannibals are elderly spouses, parent and child, or two weirdos who just met via Craigslist. CROWW teaches you to determine your character’s identity and motivation up front — a good skill for any actor or writer.

Improv is cheap group therapy. No, you don’t have to reveal your intimate secrets (thank God). But, while it lacks the confessional aspect of psychiatry, improv is all about learning to play well with others, establishing the trust and open communication without which you couldn’t possibly impersonate foot-fetishist cannibals together.

The circle exercises that start each session at Spark Arts are designed to get participants to make eye contact and read body language as they mime tossing each other invisible balls or chopping each other with invisible samurai swords. If you’re not alert and responsive to others, you won’t be able to keep up the pace. Sure, you’ll feel like you’re playing a goofy game at summer camp as you chant nonsense words at near-strangers. But you’re also polishing the interpersonal skills that atrophy when you spend long days interacting with people via email.

Improv can’t be perfect. Don’t get me wrong. Not all improv is equal. (See sidebar on Ben Rameaka, who does it professionally.) When I watch Spark Arts Troupe perform, I admire the crackerjack speed with which they transform random prompts from the audience into something resembling a scripted comedy sketch. Some people are stumped by dictates such as “you have hooks for hands”; others instantly see a character in their minds, complete with accent and backstory.

But when you stop trying to think of jokes and let your body feel its way into the character, sometimes that’s when the funny happens. Mathieu Gagne, a veteran of ImprovBoston who teaches at Spark Arts, emphasizes that improv isn’t just about cerebral quick-wittedness — there are strong physical and nonverbal components to it, too.

An art that can’t be perfected — just practiced — is hard for my perfectionist mind to accept. But the more I do improv, the more I notice everything that’s unplanned and improvised in our daily lives. No rehearsal, no script — riding the wave of randomness is a skill we can all use. Sometimes you need to just go with it.

Green Mountain Comedy Festival Opening Night Improv Jamboree. Wednesday, May 22, 9 p.m. at Club Metronome in Burlington. $10. 18+. ImprovBoston & Friends. Saturday, May 25, 7 p.m. at Club Metronome in Burlington. $10. 18+. iSpy All-Star Improv Show. Saturday, May 25, 9 p.m. at the Monkey House in Winooski. $8. 18+. greenmountaincomedy.com; sparkartsvt.com

Good Citizen

Scripted or unscripted, Ben Rameaka is a funny guy. The 34-year-old native Vermonter performs and teaches at New York City’s Upright Citizens Brigade Theatre, a hotbed of improv, sketch and standup founded by a quartet of comedians from Chicago, including now-famous Amy Poehler.

Rameaka has appeared in TV pilots, ads and hilarious web videos. In the “Rejected Pitches” series, he plays a soulless Hollywood exec who tears apart pitches for widely beloved movies such as Pulp Fiction and The Lord of the Rings trilogy. (“You know who wants rings?” his character informs Peter Jackson. “Cheap women and drug addicts with frosted tips.”)

While those sketches begin from a script, Rameaka will focus on straight improv when he appears at the Green Mountain Comedy Festival on May 24. He and half of his UCB improv team, Airwolf, will do a show they call “Let’s Go Back to Your Place.”

It’s an example of “long-form” improv that starts with the troupe interviewing an audience member “about a messed-up living situation they’ve had at some point at their life,” Rameaka says in a phone interview. Based on that story, the team improvises a series of scenes lasting 15 to 30 minutes in total — much longer than the brief improv games featured on “Whose Line Is It Anyway?”

Raised in Shelburne, Rameaka went straight from the University of Vermont to the Actors Studio Drama Program in New York. “People told me I should take improv,” he recalls. “I think they thought I was more funny than dramatic.” Perhaps they were right — Rameaka found a home at UCB, where he’s been for the past six years.

The biggest compliment an improviser can get, Rameaka says, is when an audience member asks, “That was written beforehand, right?” We asked him a few questions about how to perform without a net.

SEVEN DAYS: How is improv different from other forms of comedy?

BEN RAMEAKA: You’re dealing with a lot of people who are very funny and very talented, and it takes a sort of ability to sublimate your will for the good of the group. You want to support people, make everybody else look as good as possible … If I fuck up, there’s seven people who can get my back, make me look good, support me.

SD: When you do scripted work, does improv find its way in?

BR: I will definitely play with the script. Everything is shot on digital. Unless you’re in a time crunch, you have time to play. A lot of directors will respect that.[In auditions for ads,] the casting people are going to see tons of people during the day. If you can bring something a little bit different, or entertain, you’re more likely to get the job. Sometimes advertising copy is really shitty — you can improve it.

SD: Were you ever stumped by a prompt from the audience?

BR: No, I’ve never been stumped. There definitely are suggestions where people think they’re being really clever by giving you dirty stuff. It’s your job as an improviser to elevate those suggestions. One technique we have is “going from A to C.” So if you say something really dirty, like “vagina,” I’ll say, “‘Vagina’ reminds me of a woman, so I’ll play a pregnant woman in the scene.” People [in the audience] love to yell “surfboard,” and they love to yell “pineapple.” I have no idea why that is.

SD: What do you like about improv?

BR: There’s no net. You’re out there with your team, and you’re building this thing together; we have each other’s backs. An audience is there with you; they’re watching you take the risk. They want to see you do well. It’s almost like you’re all participating in an in-joke. It’s a very sort of unique art form, in that no one wants to see the trapeze artist fall — and if they do, they’re probably a psychopath.

Got something to say? Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

More By This Author

  • 'Prey' Becomes Predator in a Refreshingly New Twist on an Old Action Franchise
  • Movie Review: 'Prey'

    • Aug 17, 2022
  • Now Playing in Theaters: August 17-23
  • Now Playing in Theaters: August 17-23

    In addition to Fall, here's what is playing in Northern and Central Vermont movie theaters this week. Listings include new movies, vintage films and a directory of open theaters.
    • Aug 17, 2022
  • Now Playing in Theaters: August 10-16
  • Now Playing in Theaters: August 10-16

    In addition to Bodies Bodies Bodies, here's what is playing in Northern and Central Vermont movie theaters this week. Listings include new movies, vintage films and a directory of open theaters.
    • Aug 10, 2022
  • More »

About The Author

Margot Harrison

Margot Harrison

Margot Harrison is the Associate Editor at Seven Days; she coordinates literary and film coverage. In 2005, she won the John D. Donoghue award for arts criticism from the Vermont Press Association.


Comments are closed.

Since 2014, Seven Days has allowed readers to comment on all stories posted on our website. While we’ve appreciated the suggestions and insights, the time has come to shut them down — at least temporarily.

While we champion free speech, facts are a matter of life and death during the coronavirus pandemic, and right now Seven Days is prioritizing the production of responsible journalism over moderating online debates between readers.

To criticize, correct or praise our reporting, please send us a letter to the editor. Or send us a tip. We’ll check it out and report the results.

Online comments may return when we have better tech tools for managing them. Thanks for reading.

Keep up with us Seven Days a week!

Sign up for our fun and informative

All content © 2022 Da Capo Publishing, Inc. 255 So. Champlain St. Ste. 5, Burlington, VT 05401

Advertising Policy  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us  |  About Us  |  Help
Website powered by Foundation