Testing, Testing | Tech | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice
Pin It

Testing, Testing 

Local Matters

Burlington police spent two weeks tracking Laura Winterbottom's murderer. They found him, ultimately, in a laboratory.

When authorities arrested an Old North End resident last week and accused him of murdering and sexually assaulting 31-year-old Winterbottom, it was DNA evidence that connected him to the crimes. Police said bodily fluids recovered from Winterbottom's car and body matched a sample taken from 33-year-old Gerald Tyrone Montgomery, a previously convicted sex offender. Montgomery has pleaded not guilty to both charges.

As a result of TV crime shows and highly publicized celebrity trials, most people these days have a basic understanding of DNA evidence -- what it is and how it's used in criminal cases. But a visit to Vermont's state forensic lab proves that the DNA testing process is more complicated than it looks on TV.

The state's only forensic crime lab is located behind a metal door on the third floor of the Department of Public Safety building in the Waterbury state offices complex. White walls and a gleaming tile floor give the lab an antiseptic appearance, accentuated by the strip of sticky paper that serves as a welcome mat to the DNA analysis room. Lab director Eric Buel explains that the paper helps to reduce the amount of dust in the tight space.

When police collect a sample from a crime scene, he says, they take it first to the serology department, where technicians determine, for example, if stains on a shirt are blood or chocolate sauce. If the sample contains DNA, it's liquefied and brought to the analysis room. Technicians there use pen-like injectors called pipettes to transfer the DNA-filled fluid to clear plastic tubes half an inch long and an eighth of an inch in diameter.

They run the samples through three machines. The first instrument, a "Real-time PCR," determines if there's enough DNA in the sample to test. The second, a thermocycler, replicates the DNA strands, and embeds fluorescent dyes that will enable the third machine -- the genetic analyzer -- to prepare a profile.

It's a lengthy process. "DNA analysis, unlike on 'CSI,' takes time," says Buel. As he displays the machinery, Joseph Abraham, a forensic chemist, runs a sample through the genetic analyzer. Unlike the genetic analyzer on "CSI," Abraham's machine doesn't have lights that illuminate the samples.

Inside the analyzer, a tube extends into the DNA sample, and sucks up fluid into another tube the width of a human hair. Lasers penetrate the tube to search for fluorescent dyes. Abraham stands in front of a computer linked to the machine, which interprets the data and produces a multicolored graph that is indecipherable to non-experts.

Under the best circumstances, Abraham says, the lab can produce a profile in three days. But Buel says that may extend to a week; he declines to discuss the timetable in the Winterbottom case. Homicides are obviously the first priority, but if the machine is mid-analysis, it has to finish before the next sample can be introduced.

And Buel notes that the genetic analyzer is sometimes temperamental. "If the instrument breaks and we have to call a service rep," he says, "they're out of Boston."

Once the profile emerges from the analyzer, a technician determines whether it contains enough information to deliver an accurate match. A second analyst double-checks the report. Then the profile is checked against the genetic profiles of identified suspects, and against the Vermont's Combined DNA Index database. If a match is found, technicians test the original sample to be sure they got an accurate reading. They'll take another sample once the suspect is in custody, from a cheek swab or a blood draw.

Buel says there are multiple checks built into the system. That's crucial, because the likelihood of a false match is slim. "We give statistics in the billions and trillions," he says. "Statistically, it's terrific evidence."

Did you appreciate this story?

Show us your ❤️ by becoming a Seven Days Super Reader.

Got something to say? Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

Pin It

More by Cathy Resmer

  • Social Sentinel, Burlington Code Academy and Maureen McElaney Win Awards at 12th Vermont Tech Jam
  • Vermont's Top Innovators Honored at Tech Jam 2018

    Social Sentinel, a Burlington-based company that identifies threatening content on social media, was among the winners of the 2018 Tech Jam awards, presented last Friday at the 12th Vermont Tech Jam. The prizes, given annually by the Vermont Technology Alliance, BTV Ignite and Seven Days, recognize leaders in the state's tech ecosystem. The awards ceremony was the culmination of a busy day at the free career and tech expo organized by Seven Days and presented by Vermont Works. Representatives from more than 50 companies and colleges talked with hundreds of attendees who walked the expo floor. Jeff Couture, executive director of the Vermont Technology Alliance, said he talked with job seekers from across Vermont and outside the state at the event, "including someone, suitcase in hand, who visited from North Carolina."
    • Oct 23, 2018
  • Inspiring Projects to See, Hear and Play With at the Vermont Tech Jam
  • Inspiring Projects to See, Hear and Play With at the Vermont Tech Jam

    • Oct 17, 2018
  • The Tech Issue — 2018
  • The Tech Issue — 2018

    • Oct 17, 2018
  • More »

About The Author

Cathy Resmer

Cathy Resmer

Deputy publisher Cathy Resmer is an organizer of the Vermont Tech Jam, and compiles a weekly tech e-newsletter every Monday. She also oversees HR, helps manage Seven Days' digital staff and oversees its parenting publication, Kids VT. In 2018, she designed and administered a statewide youth civics project, the... more


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Seven Days moderates comments in order to ensure a civil environment. Please treat the comments section as you would a town meeting, dinner party or classroom discussion. In other words, keep commenting classy! Read our guidelines...

Note: Comments are limited to 300 words.

Recent Comments

Keep up with us Seven Days a week!

Sign up for our fun and informative

All content © 2019 Da Capo Publishing, Inc. 255 So. Champlain St. Ste. 5, Burlington, VT 05401
Website powered by Foundation