Erin Bartle was hiking on October 10 when she got a text from a former colleague at the Burlington Police Department: Lila Darjee Khadka had been brutally beaten with a flashlight. Her husband, Bal Khadka, had been arrested. 

I knew this was going to happen, Bartle thought. 

Bartle had met Lila while working as an officer investigating domestic violence cases. Bal had been arrested repeatedly for allegedly hurting, threatening or harassing Lila. She had accused him of punching and strangling her and even trying to stab her with a knife.

But Lila felt that she could not testify against her husband. Without her, prosecutors say, they didn’t have enough evidence, and the most serious charges were dropped.

Bartle had been worried about Lila ever since, counting her among a handful of women she feared might be killed by their partners. The day after Lila was attacked in October, she died.

Bal Khadka Credit: File: Glenn Russell

Her killing followed a familiar pattern for people who work on domestic violence cases: a history of abuse, criminal charges that fizzled out and a fatal conclusion. Lila Khadka’s case is also a typical example of why these crimes can be so difficult to prosecute. Because the abuse usually happens behind closed doors, prosecutors often rely on the testimony of victims, who might choose to stay silent, sometimes out of fear. 

Bartle’s job is to make these cases stronger. She’s one of several investigators employed by Vermont prosecutors to focus solely on domestic violence. Since June 2025, she’s worked out of the Chittenden County State’s Attorney’s Office, picking up where responding police officers leave off. She gathers additional evidence and builds trust with victims in order to keep cases on track. 

Neither Bartle nor the prosecutors she works for say stronger criminal cases alone will make every victim safe. But they say her work has allowed prosecutors to bring more serious charges, often keeping defendants in jail while their cases are pending. 

That, they say, can be one step toward the ultimate goal of getting victims out of dangerous situations.

Domestic violence differs from most crimes in that the key witnesses — the victims themselves — are often reluctant to report what happened or testify against the perpetrator. 

Some charges are filed only because a neighbor or relative called 911 on their behalf. Even those who willingly seek help from police might later decide not to engage with prosecutors.  

Erin Bartle builds rapport with victims, giving them someone they feel they can trust.

They may rely on abusers for housing and income. They might worry that involving the legal system could jeopardize their custody of their children. Many have nowhere else to go: Chittenden County has only one domestic violence shelter, and open beds are hard to come by. 

They might also fear retribution when their abuser gets out of jail. And very often, according to Bartle, victims still care deeply about their partner. 

“It’s a completely different relationship than if somebody gets mugged out on the street,” she said.

Bartle’s boss, Chittenden County State’s Attorney Sarah George, understands firsthand why someone might protect a person who is hurting them. 

George herself was in an abusive relationship in high school, she said. She did not face the same practical pressures that weigh on many adult victims, but she told neither friends nor family what was going on because she did not want to get her boyfriend in trouble. 

Without victims’ testimony, prosecutors will try to secure other forms of evidence, such as 911 recordings, medical records and witness accounts. That type of evidence-based prosecution is considered a best practice in domestic violence cases and is generally supported by victims’ advocacy groups. 

“It takes the sole pressure off of the victim to participate or not,” said Sarah Robinson, co-executive director of the Vermont Network, which supports organizations that work with domestic violence survivors. 

But gathering evidence can be difficult. Domestic violence usually occurs when the only witnesses may be young children, and injuries can be hard to detect or easy to explain away. Strangulation, one of the most dangerous forms of abuse, may leave few visible marks.

Another obstacle: Most incidents occur overnight, when police departments are typically busier. Officers often only have about 20 to 30 minutes to spend at the scene of a domestic incident before they need to respond to the next call, according to Bartle. 

Those same officers clock out in the morning, when prosecutors review their affidavits — the statements they submit to summarize their evidence backing up an arrest. 

George, who spent her first four years as a prosecutor pursuing domestic violence cases, said police affidavits often lack the details — such as whether a weapon was used or the person suffered serious injuries — that enable charging an abuser with a felony.  

Sarah George in her office Credit: File: Daria Bishop

In one incident, an officer wrote, without elaborating, that a victim had been “choked.” Prosecutors went back and listened to the woman’s full statement and heard her describe in a hoarse voice how she lost control of her bladder during the attack. Neither detail was in the affidavit, and both are “significant indications of strangulation,” according to George, who upgraded the charge to a felony. 

The more serious charge can have immediate repercussions. Judges can only hold someone without bail for felony-level crimes, George said, while a person facing a misdemeanor will likely get out — and could immediately confront their victim again. That convinced George to recruit a trained investigator for her office.

She asked the Department of State’s Attorneys and Sheriffs, which oversees funding of state prosecutor offices, to take federal funds from the Violence Against Women Act that had previously covered a prosecutor’s salary and instead spend it on an investigator. 

She then offered the new part-time job to Bartle, whom she had heard was planning to step down from her full-time job as a Burlington cop to spend more time with her children.

Bartle now works out of Burlington’s criminal courthouse two days a week. She begins each shift by reviewing recent police affidavits in domestic violence cases for any missing elements. Then she fleshes out the investigations herself. 

It can be slow work. On a typical day, she might listen to a victim’s recorded police statement for any information that didn’t make it into the officer’s affidavit or review recorded jail calls in case an accused abuser urged a victim to recant their statement. 

She will sometimes call forensic nurses at the University of Vermont Medical Center, who are trained to collect evidence while examining victims of domestic violence and sexual assault. She also reaches out to victims directly, either by phone, in the office or, sometimes, out in the community.

George recalled days when Bartle spent more than four hours speaking with a victim in a conference room. 

The interviews can lead to fresh evidence. Responding officers often only get the basic facts of an incident, Bartle said, and victims sometimes need a night of sleep to fully recount what happened. 

Bartle probes for details that might turn up new witnesses or corroborating evidence, such as doorbell-camera footage no one had asked for. She asks about any previous assaults or threats.

I just need to keep you alive.

Erin Bartle

One case earlier this year involved a man accused of hurting his girlfriend. After reading the affidavit, prosecutors felt that they could only charge the man with unlawful mischief — a misdemeanor property crime. 

But Bartle, after learning that the victim wound up in the hospital with serious injuries, convinced police to investigate further. The additional evidence they collected allowed prosecutors to upgrade the charge to aggravated domestic assault, a felony. 

Bartle took a statement from the victim that helped to establish that there had been a string of violent acts — which helped convince a judge to keep the perpetrator locked up without bail. 

Bartle’s interviews build rapport with victims, giving them someone in the system they feel they can trust. She connects them with advocates, asks about their housing and finances, and stays in touch as the case moves through court.  

She also has frank conversations. “I tell them straight up, ‘I am afraid for your safety,’” Bartle said. “‘This is what I know is likely to happen, and I just need to keep you alive.’”

Bartle felt the weight of those words as she sat in a courtroom last month, watching Bal Khadka plead not guilty to murdering his wife. Looking back, she believes she and others did everything they could to help Lila Khadka. 

“But it wasn’t enough,” Bartle said. ➆

If you need help, call the Statewide Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-228-7395 or visit humanservices.vermont.gov/help-and-resources/domestic-violence.

The original print version of this article was headlined “‘Afraid for Your Safety’ | A special investigator takes on domestic violence cases. But as a fatal beating shows, there’s more work to be done.”

Colin Flanders is a staff writer at Seven Days, covering health care, cops and courts. He has won three first-place awards from the Association of Alternative Newsmedia, including Best News Story for “Vermont’s Relapse,” a portrait of the state’s worsening drug crisis. He has also written or cowritten a dozen stories that have earned top honors from the New England Newspaper & Press Association. He graduated from Saint Michael’s College with a degree in journalism and started his career...