Burlington city hall Credit: Aaron Calvin

For many years, Burlington residents could walk into city hall and march right into the mayor’s office on the third floor.

No longer.

Since June, a private security guard has been stationed at the staircase that leads to the third floor, denying entry to all unless they have an appointment with someone in the mayor’s office or the Community and Economic Development Office, also housed there.

The third-floor policy is the most noticeable in a suite of new restrictions at city hall that limit where visitors can go and how long they can stay in the building, also home to the city clerk and other municipal offices. These tightened rules follow a series of disruptive visits by critics of Mayor Emma Mulvaney-Stanak and free speech provocateurs that left her and other city employees feeling unsafe. The restrictions effectively limit all residents’ access to the city’s elected leader in the name of protecting the people who work at city hall.

Under the new rules, drafted this summer by the Mulvaney-Stanak administration without public debate, members of the public are not allowed to remain in city hall for more than 10 minutes without an express purpose. Those who disobey the “reasonable” direction of staff or security guards, seek to record videos in nonpublic areas, or intend to “cause annoyance, disruption, or the obstruction” of city business risk a temporary ban.

Signs at city hall Credit: Aaron Calvin

Mulvaney-Stanak, a Progressive, created the new rules to keep her and other city workers safe. City hall employees have been so distressed by critics and activists who have posted videos of their visits on social media that some complained to human resources.

One such critic, Aryeh “Ari” Moskowitz, so aggressively pursued an audience with the mayor that she believed he posed a threat to her and her family. In June, the mayor had criminal stalking charges brought against Moskowitz and sought a stay-away order in civil court.

City lawyers argue that curtailing public access and the exercise of free speech rights is legally justifiable at city hall — no different, say, from long-standing restrictions at courthouses or schools.

But such restrictions on speech, even in reaction to belligerent behavior, don’t sit well with some First Amendment advocates.

A social media post from Ari Moskowitz showing him and Todd DeLuca outside city hall
Credit: Screensho

“Sometimes it’s annoying to be scrutinized as a member of government, and that’s part of the social contract that we have,” said Alex Morey, a First Amendment specialist with the Freedom Forum, a nonpartisan free speech advocacy group based in Washington, D. C.

Before the COVID-19 pandemic, there were few barriers between the Burlington mayor and constituents, physical or otherwise. Jordan Redell, who was chief of staff under Mulvaney-Stanak’s predecessor, Miro Weinberger, recalls that visitors often walked past a third-floor receptionist straight into the mayor’s office.

But Weinberger was repeatedly targeted by varied threats and aggressive behavior throughout his 12-year stint, and the pattern worsened over time, the former mayor said in an email. So-called “First Amendment auditors,” who film themselves in government buildings and post videos of the encounters on YouTube in what they call an exercise of free speech rights, also began to occasionally appear in city hall.

I’m protecting the constitutional right to be annoying, to be an asshole,to be combative, to do whatever as long as I’m not threatening.

Eric Gravel

The most serious incident during Weinberger’s tenure occurred in 2019, when a frequent agitator named Christopher Hayden made a drunken foray into city hall and yelled antisemitic slurs while the mayor was meeting with high school students. Hayden was charged with criminal threatening and aggravated assault. The charges were dismissed when Hayden was found mentally incompetent and put into the custody of the Vermont Department of Mental Health, according to Chittenden County State’s Attorney Sarah George.

And amid COVID-era renovations to city hall, officials installed a wall of windows around the third-floor reception desk that includes a locked, narrow door due to growing concern for the physical safety of city staff. But until now, the third floor was never fully blocked to those without an appointment, nor was there an official policy outlining the sort of behavior that could get someone banned from city hall.

Mulvaney-Stanak asserts that she faces more serious threats because she’s a woman. She said women in power around the country have faced an increase in menacing behavior in recent years, regardless of their political affiliation.

“My deepest concern is that it will have a deep, chilling effect on people running for office, especially women, and especially women who have small children and families,” Mulvaney-Stanak said in an interview.

But her most aggressive critics say gender plays no part in attacking what they see as the failures of her Progressive administration.

Moskowitz, a Burlington resident, this year launched “truthinvermont,” an Instagram account dedicated to criticizing Mulvaney-Stanak over the increased visibility of homeless people and drug use downtown. He became frustrated when she refused to meet with him or fully investigate a city hall security guard who trolled Moskowitz online over his defense of Israel’s war in Gaza.

The city’s actions against Moskowitz began in May, when he was barred from city hall for six months after confronting a city lawyer near the building on Church Street and posting a video of the interaction to his Instagram account. The following month, he was charged with stalking the mayor after several public run-ins that left her fearing for her safety.

Moskowitz claimed in an interview that he is guilty of being “annoying,” but not threatening, in aggressively petitioning the mayor. But a judge has forbidden Moskowitz from coming within six feet of the mayor for a year after finding that her fear of him was merited. The criminal stalking case is currently on track for a jury trial.

A separate social-media provocateur, Todd DeLuca, who lived in Burlington until recently, has spent the past three years documenting homeless encampments, overdoses and emergency responders on channels he calls “Beautiful Scenic Burlington.” He received a single-day ban from city hall in June for refusing to leave after a security guard asked him to do so.

Moskowitz and DeLuca contend that the new restrictions were put in place to silence them. But city officials say the rules are aimed solely at protecting employees.

DeLuca’s videos attracted the attention of Eric Gravel, a First Amendment auditor from East Calais who documents his attempts to push the limits of free speech on his own YouTube channel, “Question Authority.”

A security guard standing watch in city hall Credit: Aaron Calvin

In visits to city hall last summer, Gravel filmed inside the building, provoking the privately contracted security guards, recording their reactions and posting them to his channel. He then posted edited versions that altered the words and actions of Burlington police to make the officers look clownish and heavy-handed.

He was eventually banned for a year after getting into a confrontation with a security guard during an August visit.

Gravel acknowledged that his conduct was abrasive but said he was seeking to protect free speech in public forums. Like Moskowitz and DeLuca, he accused city lawyers of coming up with the prohibited-behavior policy in reaction to his videos.

“I’m protecting the constitutional right to be annoying, to be an asshole, to be combative, to do whatever as long as I’m not threatening,” Gravel said.

A separate First Amendment auditor, Scott Martin, from the Plattsburgh, N.Y., area, was banned from city hall for a month in August for refusing to leave when asked by a security guard.

While a handful of the mayor’s most vociferous critics and free speech YouTubers decry the new restrictions, officials say they have not received any complaints from the general public. Katherine Schad, who helped craft the rules in her role as the city’s chief administrative officer, said they have restored a sense of safety for employees.

“It’s not what anyone dreams of when they come to work in the morning, being put on YouTube with what they feel like is without their consent,” she said.

Gravel and Martin appealed their bans to the city council’s’s Public Safety Committee, whose members weigh the cases of people who have been barred from city property.

The committee upheld Gravel’s yearlong ban from city hall in September, following multiple hearings during which he berated its members. He has sued Chocolate Thunder, the city’s hired security company, and gone to court to appeal the city ban. The committee also upheld Martin’s ban.

City Councilor Buddy Singh (D-South District), the committee chair, has questioned whether the public safety panel has the capacity to settle such appeals.

It’s not what anyone dreams of when they come to work in the morning, being put on YouTube … without their consent

Katherine Schad

“It certainly could get to a point where it’s beyond the ability of the committee to adjudicate these things,” he said.

City council support for the new restrictions has been bipartisan so far. The council pushed through changes to the city’s trespass ordinance to grant the public safety committee more time to consider appeals.

Council President Ben Traverse (D-Ward 5), a Democrat who announced a bid for mayor earlier this month, said “time will tell” if the new rules strike the right balance between protecting city workers and public access to what he called “the people’s building.”

Morey, the First Amendment specialist, said municipalities elsewhere have answered similar cases by teaching city staff about free speech rights, rather than imposing strict policies on what residents can say or do in city hall.

The line between protected speech and criminal behavior, such as stalking and harassment, can be difficult to discern, Morey said. Free speech rights in public places must apply equally, she said, even if someone is shoving a camera in your face. ➆

The original print version of this article was headlined “Access Denied | New restrictions at Burlington City Hall limit public access in the name of protecting staff”

Burlington news reporter Aaron Calvin previously worked at the Stowe Reporter and News & Citizen newspapers in Lamoille County. The New England Newspaper Association named him its 2024 Reporter of the Year. His story about a historic Chinese restaurant's transition to a quirky pizza joint was acknowledged in Best American Food Writing 2021. An Iowa native and graduate of New York's Hofstra University, Aaron previously covered trending news for the Des Moines Register. He's also reported on politics,...