Bruegger’s Bagels on Church Street in Burlington Credit: SALLY POLLAK

Bruegger’s Bagels closed its Church Street Marketplace restaurant on Sunday after more than a quarter-century in business. The bagel restaurant opened in the Howard Opera House about 27 years ago, said Steven Schonberg, co-owner of the building.

“They’re a very familiar, longtime tenant that I’m sure lots of people will miss,” Schonberg said. “However, as you can see, Church Street continues to prosper. We fully expect to be able to lease it to another high-quality tenant that will bring its own unique benefit to Church Street.”

Bruegger’s was founded 35 years ago by Vermonters Nordahl Brue and Michael  Dressell.  Its ownership changed over the years, including Bruegger’s acquisition earlier this year by JAB Holding Company, a private company whose properties include Keurig Green Mountain, Panera  and Caribou Coffee, according to the company website.

The first Bruegger’s  Bagels opened in Troy, N.Y., in 1983.  The founders “wanted to learn how to operate a restaurant from a distance,” said Ron Redmond, executive director of the Church Street Marketplace.  Bruegger’s grew to be a national chain that includes a location in Shelburne, which remains open.

Its closing in downtown Burlington is “typical of the cycle that happens on Church Street where you have stores coming and going,” Redmond said. “If you think of all the stores that were on Church Street 30 years ago, the scene is much different.”

Schonberg said he hopes to have a new tenant occupy the Bruegger’s space soon, but has no specific business in mind.

“We work hard at trying to get tenants that will add a dimension that may not be here otherwise,” he said. “That will certainly be our goal.”

Seventy-five percent of the businesses on the Marketplace are locally owned, up from 65 percent a year ago, according to Redmond.

Bruegger’s closing was reported Monday in the Burlington Free Press.

Got something to say?

Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!

Sally Pollak was a staff writer at Seven Days from 2017 until she retired in summer 2023. She started as a Food contributor before transitioning to the Arts & Culture team. Her first newspaper job was compiling horse racing results at the Philadelphia...

5 replies on “Bruegger’s Bagels Closes on Church Street”

  1. @Mt.Philo
    “Makes one wonder how a tower full of retail space is actually going to do much for Church Street.”

    You do realize that this is not the only location that closed. They closed 30 locations. Sounds like a company wide problem and not a Church St. problem.

  2. > Its ownership changed over the years, including Brueggers acquisition earlier this year by JAB Holding Company, a private company whose properties include Keurig Green Mountain, Panera and Caribou Coffee, according to the company website

    Texas-based vulture capitalism takes yet another bite out of our local business after their earlier GMCR layoffs

  3. Honestly companies come and go. There are multiple coffee places on Church Street and downtown, and frankly, Bruegger bagels are not that good, in fact there are really no very good bagel places in town, including Pine Street. No tears here, innovate provide top quality, or go away.

  4. Thank heaven well have 14 stories of retail and hundreds of new residents to further crowd the city, shop in rapidly emptying storefronts, and add more human pollutants to the lake. What could possibly go wrong?

Comments are closed.