Chittenden County State's Attorney Sarah George has dismissed charges on the grounds of insanity against three people — two accused of murder and one of attempted murder.
All three defendants were involved in unrelated, high-profile cases including a deadly stabbing on Burlington's Church Street and a fatal meat cleaver attack in the city's Old North End.
George announced Tuesday that she had concluded the defendants were legally insane at the time of the crimes and would not be found guilty of the charges against them at trial. She filed to dismiss the charges last Friday.
"Despite retention of expert forensic psychiatrists" who evaluated the defendants, the state does not have evidence to rebut their insanity defenses, George said in a press release. "Therefore the state cannot meet its burden of proving defendants are guilty beyond a reasonable doubt."
Charges were also dropped against Veronica Lewis, who was charged with attempted first-degree murder in 2015 for shooting her firearms instructor multiple times. He survived.
Lawyers for all three mounted the insanity defense in pretrial filings and hired expert witnesses that concluded the defendants had severe mental illnesses that prevented them from "conforming their behavior" to the law.
All three are in custody of the Vermont Department of Mental Health. It's unclear how long they will remain committed.
click to enlarge
Burlington police
Louis Fortier
George wrote that it is the state's expectation that the three will be treated until they are no longer a risk to themselves or others and the "interests of justice have been served."
She also said the dismissals do not undermine the "heroic" work by the Vermont State Police and Burlington Police Department to respond, arrest and investigate the three defendants.
The dismissals come a few weeks after George successfully prosecuted another accused killer who raised an insanity defense. On May 22, a jury found Steven Bourgoin guilty of five counts of murder for driving the wrong way on Interstate 89 and crashing into a car that carried five teens in October 2016.
George could not be reached for further comment late Tuesday.
Since 2014, Seven Days has allowed readers to comment on all stories posted on our website. While we’ve appreciated the suggestions and insights, the time has come to shut them down — at least temporarily.
While we champion free speech, facts are a matter of life and death during the coronavirus pandemic, and right now Seven Days is prioritizing the production of responsible journalism over moderating online debates between readers.
A man released from a hospital where he'd sought mental health treatment returned to his Old North End home on Thursday, killed his wife with a meat cleaver and attacked his mother-in-law, Burlington police said.
Steven Bourgoin, the suspected wrong-way driver in the car crash that killed five teenagers, remains hospitalized but has been formally arrested and was in the custody of the Department of Corrections, Vermont State Police said.
The man suspected of driving a pickup truck north in the southbound lanes of Interstate 89 on Saturday night and colliding with a car — killing five teens — had sought medical treatment that same day, a prosecutor said Monday.