The House voted 84-61 Tuesday to give preliminary approval to a bill that would raise Vermont’s legal smoking age from 18 to 21. The change would be phased in over three years, beginning next January.
To make up for the loss in tax revenue from tobacco sales, the bill calls for a 13-cent increase in the tax on cigarettes in each of the next three years. A single 13-cent tax hike would raise about $900,000.
The House spent much of Tuesday on this measure. The first vote, to add the tax to the age-change bill, was close: 75 to 68. Critics argued the bill was another excuse to raise taxes.
“This is not a health bill, but just another tax and anti-business bill,” Rep. Ron Hubert (R-Milton) said, explaining his no vote.
“This is a self-imposed tax,” countered Rep. David Deen (D-Westminster) who voted in favor. “If you don’t want to pay the tax, don’t smoke.”
Rep. Carolyn Branagan (R-Georgia) is vice chair of the House Ways and Means Committee, which recommended the tax to offset the reduced revenues. She argued that the higher legal age and the tax increase would make Vermonters healthier. “Reducing the number of young people who smoke will lower health care spending,” she said.
Before taking the final vote of the day on the bill, the House agreed to Rep. Kurt Wright’s (R-Burlington) proposal to raise the fine for underage people who try to deceive retailers. Wright called the current $25 penalty for this violation “a slap on the wrist.” He said that $200 would be a better deterrent — and the House agreed, 136-9.
Rep. Bob Helm (R-Fair Haven) wanted to create an exception to the age increase for members of the military. If people who are 18 can fight for their country, he argued, then the state should “treat them like adults.”
Rep. Mike Mrowicki (D-Putney) acknowledged that dilemma, but argued that the military doesn’t want to encourage smoking.
Helm’s amendment failed in a 70-72 vote.
The House is expected to give the measure final approval Wednesday. Its fate in the Senate, however, is uncertain. It is arriving there long after the date when House bills were due.
Senate President Pro Tempore John Campbell (D-Windsor) noted that the bill’s tardy arrival gave senate committees little time to schedule testimony. He added: “I have heard quite a few of the senators have concerns about doing it.”
Got something to say?
Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!
It is said that a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds. Well, no one will accuse the Legislature of consistency. The age of adulthood in Vermont is 18, yet adults aged 18-20 are not deemed mature enough to make basic decisions for themselves (but we’re more than happy to have them defend our nation in the armed services). Strap on a rifle, vote in elections, get married and sign contracts, but don’t you dare have a drink or smoke a cigarette.
Yet, our purportedly health-conscious, anti-smoking Legislature is at the same time pursuing the legalization of marijuana. According to one British study, just three cannabis joints a day can cause the same amount of damage to the lungs as an entire packet of 20 cigarettes. Its research suggests young cannabis smokers may also be at greater risk of throat and gullet cancers. Finally, tar from cannabis joints contains 50 per cent more cancer-causing toxins than cigarettes made from tobacco alone.
But think of the revenue …..