The #MeToo movement had already named and shamed Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein, comedian Louis C.K., U.S. senator Al Franken and celebrity chef Mario Batali when Elizabeth Dunn decided she had something to say about her classmates at Middlebury College.
On December 12, the senior went on Facebook to post a short list of “men to avoid” at Vermont’s most prestigious college and solicited input from others. She added the crowdsourced names to her list until she had called out 36 male students and recent graduates for sexual misbehavior, ranging from serial rape to harassment.
Not all of the accusers were female. A few cases involved males or nonbinary students identifying men responsible for sexual misdeeds, according to Dunn.
Facebook removed the post within 48 hours, but screenshots of the list continue to circulate on campus. The incident gained national traction after it was covered on Babe.net, the same online outlet that published the much-debated anonymous account of a woman’s “worst night of my life” date with comedian Aziz Ansari. In its Middlebury story, the website that proudly claims to be “for girls who don’t give a fuck” blacked out the names on Dunn’s list.
Like Ansari’s defenders, some say Dunn, 21, went too far: What began as overdue acknowledgment of a vast sexual harassment problem has devolved into unfair and unsupported charges against men. Middlebury may expel Dunn, and she is worried that sanctions by the college could derail her plans to graduate in May and attend law school in the fall.
But other observers see Dunn’s list as an act of bravery and, perhaps, desperation.
“There is an epidemic of sexual assault and everything else you can think of — violence, belittlement, discrimination, stalking, coercion — which happens on college and university campuses every day,” said Felicia Kornbluh, a feminist and associate professor of history at the University of Vermont.
Women have issued warnings about men for a long time, and Dunn’s list is a modern way to frame the message, Kornbluh said. It’s “like what we used to do with writing names on the bathroom wall,” she said. “It’s sort of the weapon of the weak.”
The list is a reminder that many victims don’t feel they can trust in police or campus judicial systems to seek redress, Kornbluh said: “It’s a sign of our utter failure institutionally.”
Numerous students have shared stories with her of being victimized, she added. “It’s pretty ubiquitous, and I hear no stories in which people used the university or other judicial procedures and got relief. That basically never happens,” Kornbluh said. “So here we are. If I was an undergraduate, I might be writing on Facebook, too.”
Culture Shock
Dunn said yes to Middlebury four years ago without ever having seen the place. The Atlanta, Ga., resident picked the college in part because it is known for its foreign languages and offered Arabic, which she’d studied in the rigorous International Baccalaureate program at her public high school.
Middlebury also offered financial aid to cover most of the cost of her four-year education. The teen was too busy with exams at the time to take advantage of an invitation to fly up and visit. Dunn, whom her friends call Liz, turned down similar offers from Brandeis University, American University, and the College of William and Mary to come to Vermont.
Dunn was eager to get out of the South and experience a new culture, a new place. But the transition for the African American daughter of a single hotel housekeeper mom was “jarring,” as Dunn described it on a couch inside Middlebury’s on-campus radio station, WRMC 91.1 FM, on the second floor of Proctor Hall. (She hosts a weekly program, “Cannabis Feminist,” that explores “the intersections of marijuana, feminism, race, class and the prison industrial complex.”) The mostly white, mostly wealthy and very sports-oriented school culture at Middlebury was indeed unfamiliar.
And, like many new college students, Dunn found herself navigating social situations for which she was unprepared. One night during her first year, she attended a party, met a guy and went to his room. According to Dunn, the student, a senior, plied her with alcohol to the point where she was “very drunk.” They had a sexual encounter even though Dunn now says she “didn’t really know what was happening” and “didn’t really consent to a lot of what was happening.”
Dunn tearfully explained that, the next day, she knew something terrible had occurred but didn’t want to fully admit it to herself. She never reported the incident to police or campus judicial officers because she did not want to face humiliating questions that “chip away at you” and blame the victim, she said.
But she came to view the encounter as a sexual assault. And late last year, inspired by the #MeToo movement — and the “Shitty Media Men” list circulating online with claims about professionals in that industry — Dunn accused the student in her December 12 Facebook post that quickly grew into a list of 36 men. She revealed only his first name and encouraged other students to direct message, aka “DM,” her on Facebook with the names of their abusers. She promised to add them to her list.
“The messages just started pouring in,” Dunn recalled, adding that she was surprised by how many students wanted to share their experiences of being victimized by harassment and sexual assault. “There’s just a lot of collective pain and trauma that people have experienced here,” Dunn said of Middlebury College.
Before Facebook took it down due to complaints, the post listed the offenders — almost all by both first and last names — along with various accusations after each one, from “serial rapist” to “emotionally abusive” to “treats women, especially black women, like shit.”
Dunn’s post ended with these words: “here’s to not being complicit in 2018 and feel free to dm me more names to add to this status because I could really give a fuck about protecting the privacy of abusers.”
All of this happened as students were preparing to leave campus for the holiday break. Before she headed home to Atlanta, Dunn got a call from a campus judicial officer asking to meet. Initially, the purpose seemed to be to offer her comfort and support as a victim of sexual assault, Dunn said. But then the officer, whom she won’t name, asked her to identify and provide contact information for those students who gave her the names of the men on the list.
Dunn said she refused to cooperate because she had promised to protect the privacy of the victims; she has since deleted all of their messages. Then, last week, Dunn said she was summoned again to meet with Middlebury judicial officers. On January 17, they told her she was officially facing college discipline for violating the privacy of other students — that is, those individuals she outed on the list.
“I could be facing suspension or expulsion. Middlebury judicial affairs has refused to take anything off the table right now,” said Dunn, who is majoring in gender, sexuality and feminism studies. The possibility that she might not be able to finish at Middlebury is sobering, she said, but she still feels she did the right thing.
“This harm is being done by, like, specific people and by specific individuals, and if we want to move toward a conversation about, like, healing and accountability and growth, there needs to be some acknowledgment that harm was done,” Dunn said. “So I think that the list was collectively generated not only by me, but by a pretty large group of survivors. It was like taking a moment to say, ‘This is our experience. This is what happened to us.'”
Men About Campus
Students weren’t eager to speak to this reporter about Dunn or her list on a snowy afternoon last Thursday. More than half a dozen males declined to comment on the record about the controversy, but each was aware of it. The roster continues to circulate, they said, because so many people took screenshots of the post before Facebook pulled it down.
“For someone to just post a name, post an allegation and not have anything to back it up, it’s hard to respect that,” said a male first-year student on campus who did not want his name used. Others said the post “freaked” students out but triggered necessary conversations.
Samantha Valone, a Middlebury sophomore from the Boston area, said it was a good thing to call attention to sexual violence. But, she added, “I just kind of feel bad for some of the people who were maybe accused and are innocent, because their lives are pretty rough right now.”
The range of misdeeds, alleged or real, also varied widely, she noted, from emotional abuse to the much more serious “serial rape,” and “they maybe shouldn’t have been put on the same list,” Valone said.
After Facebook took down the list, some students decried the decision online and even accused the social media giant of being complicit in sexual assault, observed Nathaniel Wiener, a Middlebury College senior and a reporter for the student newspaper, the Middlebury Campus, which published a December 23 story on Dunn.
But other students immediately felt the list was unfair and still do, Wiener said last week. The controversy comes on the heels of another Middlebury mess that went national last March, when student protesters shut down a talk by The Bell Curve coauthor Charles Murray and injured a professor in the process.
Dunn helped organize that public demonstration, too, calling Murray’s race-based theories about intelligence deeply offensive. On November 13, she took part in a “performance activism” piece in front of Proctor called “Laurie’s Big Apology.” Students in cheerleading getups waved metallic pom-poms as they lampooned Middlebury president Laurie Patton’s effort to respond to continuing protests around the Murray event during a town-hall-style meeting she had convened a few days earlier.
To see the college headed back into the headlines over a new scandal upset a number of alumni, according to Wiener. Some reached out to him to ask about Dunn’s motivations with the list. “My answer was, ‘I don’t know,'” said Wiener.
It didn’t help that immediately after the social media blast, the college issued emails to the student body that appeared to take one side, and then the other. The first urged victims to report harassment or assault to the college judicial office. The second urged people falsely accused to report that, too, to the same office. The messages just added to the confusion around the list, Wiener said.
“It was like you get into a fight in the schoolyard, and your parents say, ‘Well, I don’t really know what happened, but make sure you don’t do it again,'” Wiener said.
The federal law known as Title IX prohibits Middlebury and other educational institutions from discriminating on the basis of gender. Although it is well known for improving women’s access and participation in athletics, the statute also provides guidance on campus judicial reviews of sexual assaults.
College officials would not confirm that Dunn is facing possible sanctions, nor would they say if any of the individuals on the list might be. A request to interview Patton was denied. But college spokeswoman Sarah Ray offered this statement on her behalf: “Middlebury takes all allegations regarding sexual assault and discrimination extremely seriously. Our policies encourage reporting of assaults and ensure that allegations are investigated thoroughly, fairly and confidentially. The public posting of allegations raises many issues for our community and has no role in a fair and balanced process.
“An investigation into all aspects of this incident is under way,” the statement continued, “and we will work to ensure that Middlebury carefully follows its policies regarding sexual assault, harassment and other Title IX allegations, as well as its policies regarding respect for persons.”
Justice or Witch Hunt?
This is not the first time social media has been used in a campus sexual assault allegation. Alec Rose is a Santa Monica, Calif., attorney with a national practice that specializes in college assault cases. He’s not representing anyone in connection with the Middlebury incident.
One of his clients was recently cleared in a campus judicial review process, and the alleged victim chose not to appeal but later tweeted the young man’s name with the accusation that he was a “rapist loose on campus” and that the college was whitewashing that fact, Rose said. “It was very devastating for the young man,” and he withdrew from the school, according to Rose, who declined to release more specific details.
Meanwhile, the accuser could have channeled her anger into an appeal, he added. Using social media as it was in that case, and in others, can be deeply unfair, Rose said: “I think it’s a dangerous way for somebody to seek redress, both to them and the people they are accusing.”
He had a similar reaction after reading the story about Dunn’s list on Babe.
“Without knowing that she had substance to back up her accusations against these 30 young men, I don’t know how this could be deemed responsible,” Rose said, adding: “It’s certainly very humiliating to the people she reported on … It may be a situation where some of them may not be able to recover their reputation.”
Dunn said she considered the risk that someone would sue her for defamation of character when she posted the list, but she doesn’t believe it will happen — in part because legal action would generate unwanted publicity. She hasn’t heard from lawyers for any of the accused young men.
Another factor is the veracity of the claim. “In a campus situation, or in any situation where someone has alleged defamation by [an allegation of] sexual assault, one defense to that would be truth, that it actually happened,” said Burlington attorney Ben Luna, who has no direct connection to the Middlebury situation but has represented students facing various charges and tried many sexual assault cases in his former career as a prosecutor.
“There’s a whole host of issues at play here, legal and otherwise,” Luna said.
Meanwhile, some female public figures, including French actress Catherine Deneuve, are warning that the #MeToo movement is turning into a witch hunt.
Is Middlebury an example of overreach on campuses?
“My immediate reaction to that is no,” Luna said. Historically speaking, sexual assault has “been a grossly underreported crime,” and victims have not felt able to go to the courts for many reasons, Luna said.
“There’s a whole laundry list of reasons why an individual will not report, will not disclose,” Luna said. “Some of those examples are the fear that no one will believe them, embarrassment. A lot of sex assault victims blame themselves.” Luna said one teenage victim he worked with wasn’t fully aware she had been violated. “She didn’t really know what rape was,” he said.
Back at Middlebury, Dunn is waiting to see how the college disciplinary process treats her. Her friends are petitioning against punitive action, and Dunn is applying to law schools.
She said she isn’t concerned that her activism could adversely affect her chances of getting in. Her plan B: landing a job in the Bronx public defender’s office.
Dunn has heard nothing from the man she personally accused and has never directly told him how she felt about the evening. Does she think he would view the incident as sexual assault? “Probably not,” she said. “And that’s another thing that is really typical here.”
Men are sometimes raised to ignore social cues and feel a sense of entitlement, while women may be socialized not to say no or to accept things so men feel more comfortable, suggested Dunn.
Reactions from men on the list haven’t all been negative. Some of the accused have “glared” at Dunn in the dining hall or said “not very nice” things, she allowed. But others have approached her to discuss the allegations and even said they wanted to create a forum for broader conversation.
Tyler McDowell, a junior from Pennsylvania, was accused on the list of making “fetishistic, racist, sexual comments about black women.” He doesn’t remember making such comments and does not know who claims he made them, McDowell told Seven Days.
Still, he doesn’t feel he was treated unfairly. “I do not feel wronged by this. I also would stipulate that other men probably shouldn’t, either,” said McDowell.
The list was a “wake-up call” that should trigger discussion about the need for an end to the behaviors that were described on the list, he added. It’s “one way of broadcasting kind of a general call for culture change.”
Correction, January 25, 2018: Felicia Kornbluh called posting names a “weapon of the weak.” And earlier version of this story contained an error.
This article appears in Jan 24-30, 2018.
Got something to say?
Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!
Wow. I am stunned. What has political correctness on campus come to? First its ok to use violence to deny a controversial Ph.D the right to speak to students who want to hear. Then its ok to try to criminally prosecute a student for what he supposedly said in a private telephone conversation with his mother. Now its ok to make unsubstantiated public accusations of rape against specific individuals because all women are victims?
You.
Cannot.
Make.
Public.
Accusations.
Of.
Rape.
Specifically.
Naming.
People.
Unless.
Youre.
Prepared.
To.
File.
Criminal.
Or.
Civil.
Charges.
Against.
Them.
Which.
You.
Cant.
Because.
You.
Have.
No.
Knowledge.
Of.
Whether.
The.
Accusations.
Are.
Even.
True.
IMO what she did is outrageous and unacceptable.
I sympathize that she feels bad about a drunken sexual encounter that happened to her 3 years ago as a college freshman. But was it rape? Why didnt she do anything about it and why isnt she doing anything about it now?
IMO no amount not of feelings of personal victimization justifies accusing specific people you dont even know, of rape.
IMO she should never, ever, ever be employed in the law in any capacity. Ever.
And she faces multiple defamation lawsuits. Because she has no idea whether the people she outed actually did the things she accused them of. She doesnt know the accuseds and she doesnt even know the accusers!
She has just seriously damaged, possibly destroyed, the lives of people who may be completely innocent.
Suppose one of the 36 males she outed with no evidence is denied a job because the employer becomes aware of her accusations on Facebook?
This is a side note, but I think the phrase Prof. Kornbluh used was “weapon of the weak,” not “weapon of the week.” Weapons of the Weak is the title of a deeply insightful academic book. It shows how people with little power resort to informal, sometimes oblique tactics to resist abuse.
While no one should condone sexual assault or protect those who perpetrate it, is it not possible that the male who assaulted Ms Dunn was every bit as drunk as she? In which case would she not be equally as liable?
Also I suspect that her list could and most likely does include some wrongfully.
I had a nasty breakup during my college years and could envision landing on a similar ‘list’ as a means of revenge by the person with whom I broke up.
Some of those listed may now be wondering where they go to get their reputations back.
Who Elected You the place women that have experienced sexual assault can turn is the police or an emergency room, both places are capable of preforming a rape kit that will provide the evidence needed to file charges against the person responsible for violating them. Thats how you get justice not posting names with no evidence. Just ask the scumbag Harvey Weinstein he assaulted many women but because none appear to have followed the proper legal paths he will never spend a day in jail and will return to his posh life in no time. Who knows in a few years the libs in Hollywood will forget it ever happened and award him a lifetime achievement award.
I think this should be a wake up call to Middlebury College that it’s students do not understand consent. It’s time to go beyond teaching students how to avoid being raped. It’s time to go beyond teaching students how not to rape (though that would be a nice start). It’s time for Middlebury College to set a standard of enthusiastic consent for both parties, and teach their students how to recognize enthusiastic consent. Why set such a high standard for consent? That’s easy – sex should be enjoyed and wanted by both parties. Are you not sure if your partner wants to have sex with you? Are you getting mixed signals? You do not have enthusiastic consent. Do not pass Go. Do not have sex with your partner.
Ms. Dunn wants to attend law school but seems to have little respect or understanding of how the system works. Im in no way defending the men she has outed but in America we have a system in which victims report crimes to officials and bring charges against the perpetrators of crimes. We do not just plaster accusations up online and expect the general public to judge the perpetrators with no evidence. As the parent of a young daughter I have no use for men that dont respect women but I will also teach my daughter that if she is ever violated by anyone man or woman the path to follow is go to the authorities and file charges. Justice will never be served by just posting names on a Facebook page. Ms. Dunn may want to ask Middlebury for some of her money back because the education she has paid for does not seem to be good enough to get her into law school if she does not understand how the law works by now. And without evidence she might be liabil of slander if any of the men decided to challenge her statements.
“It’s pretty ubiquitous, and I hear no stories in which people used the university or other judicial procedures and got relief. That basically never happens.”
Is Prof Kornbluh saying that UVM doesn’t do anything for students who get harassed and assaulted?
the monster the left has created is consuming itself
Sexual assualt is obviously NOT okay, but it is also not taking place in “epidemic” proportions, as claims Professor Felicia Kornbluh, who is supposedly a historian. As horrific as it is, it is neither rampant nor ubiquitous. Thankfully, it is the exception rather than the rule, and Ms. Kornbluh’s histrionic, overwrought comment isn’t helpful. Historians should at least try for a dispassionate, unexcitable response to events. And yes, Ms. Dunn should face sanctions at Middlebury and serious legal action from anyone on her list, unless they have been convicted on evidence in a court of law. It looks like that young woman has caused a great deal of trouble for herself. You don’t accuse people of crimes without cause or evidence. I wonder if she has either of those things and also if she has the stomach or the money for the inevitable legal trouble that is about to come her way.
Shame on Middlebury College for it’s poor response. the #metoo campaign doesn’t just protect celebrities from sexual harassment. Young girls on college campuses have long had nowhere to turn. That someone would turn to publishing their abusers online is no surprise. If you want them not to, step up and provide an alternative solution.
Elizabeth Dunn, stay strong. It’s hard to speak truth to power.
Tyler McDowell, to takes a lot of courage to be publicly called out and to use it as a moment for growth. I hope more follow your example.