It’s nearly 2007, and there ain’t a damn thing we can do about it. So what have I learned in the last twelve months? That there are some arguments you just can’t win, for one.
But let’s move on. Inspired by Jay’s lovely list, I’ve decided to reveal a few of my choice picks for ’06.
I had a tough year finding new music. For one reason or another, I retreated to my safe corner, re-investigating old classics and, well, classical.
That doesn’t mean there weren’t a handful of pleasant revelations. But let’s not call it a “Best of.” I think “Records I Happen to Dig” is more appropriate. Oh, and the ranking is completely arbitrary.
#1. Kayo Dot — Dowsing Anemone With Copper Tongue
Is it metal? Is it experimental? Is it a quasi-pretentious mess? I still have no idea. But my puzzlement is no hindrance to enjoying this titanic slab of art-rock.
#2: Comets on Fire — Dogwood Rust
There are a lot of psych bands out there these days, and some of them should probably take more acid. These fellas don’t need to. On earlier outings, COF’s synapse-scrambling jams tended toward orgiastic squalls of fuzz. Here, they experiment with sun-baked ephemera, sounding like a grizzled cross between (here we go again) early Blue Oyster Cult and the Dead.
#3: Espers — II
I used to not like Espers much, but this record rules. Previously, they were a pale imitation of several acts, including Pentangle and Vashti. Now they’ve metamorphosed into an acoustic/prog chimera of remarkable strength. And how can I not include a band that sparked the “what is folk” discussion on this very blog?
#4: John Phillips — John the Wolfking of L.A.
Somehow being betrothed to the foxiest member of the Mamas & Papas wasn’t good enough for this guy. Originally released to critical antipathy back in 1970, this long out-of-print album has aged better than many envisioned. It chronicles Phillips’ post-fame dalliances with women and drugs — hardly groundbreaking in and of itself. But everything is set to a flaky, country-rock groove that goes great with whiskey ‘n’ Quaaludes. Yee-haw!
#5: Jenny Lewis with the Watson Twins — Rabbit Fur Coat
Jenny, Jenny, Jenny. Let me count the ways I love thee: First is your razor-sharp wit that cuts to the quick yet leaves no permanent scarring. Oh, you surgeon of the coyest cruelties! Second is your voice — a sweet ‘n’ sour mix of tender resentment. Third is your fetching appearance. Umm, I think I need to stop there. I’m almost a married man.
#6: Mastodon — Blood Mountain
Major label metal kicking ass in ’06? Who could’ve imagined? As an aging shredder, I have to admire the sheer intensity this band brings to the table. To my ears, Mastodon sound like the missing link between ‘90s miscreants Kyuss and the new generation of technical hardcore brats. Besides, where are you gonna hear another song about a Cyclops this year? Well, besides my second pick.
#7: Matmos — The Rose Has Teeth in the Mouth of the Beast
San Francisco duo Matmos are one of the best bands working in electronic composition, hands down. They’re not exactly “underground” (nor is this list, for that matter) but M.C. Schmidt and Drew Daniel possess a level of artistry that makes all of their releases worth investigating. And this one is no exception. Although I often forget to listen to it, when I do, I something new is revealed.
#8: Loscil — Plume
Another album I forget lives in my iPod. Scott Morgan, a.k.a Loscil, creates gracious, patient music that actually goes somewhere. He’s really hit his mark with Plume, an album that provides frosty ambient with a pulse. If you like dark drone, but find Lustmord too oppressive, this one is for you.
#9: Serena Maneesh — Serena Maneesh
Technically this was available in ’05, but I got it upon domestic release in May. I’m including it to prove that I can like Norwegian bands heavily influenced by the styles of yesteryear! This is straight-up shoegaze, no doubt about it. But I haven’t heard such a satisfying take on the sound since the genre’s heyday. And the publicists by and large left me alone.
#10: M. Ward — Post-War
I like his rough, manly voice. And the fact that he doesn’t use AutoTune.
#11: Woven Hand — Mosaic
Christianity has never sounded so bleak. Except during the crusades. And the Inquisition. And the Salem witch trials. Aww, forget it. Anyway, David Eugene Edwards’ post-16 Horsepower work is like M. Gira’s Angels of Light in Sunday School. Which is to say, brooding, ironhanded and totally devotional.
#12: Sunn 0))) & Boris — Altar
Beauty + Doom = Altar. This review will further elucidate.
#13: Brightblack Morning Light — Brightblack Morning Light
Wow — two Matador releases made my list! Maybe co-owner (and sports enthusiast) Gerard Cosloy will take back the mean things he said about me for pissing on the now-defunct Prosaics. But I doubt it. Anyway, this record was pretty hyped, and a lot of people found it dull. To that, I say: drink more Robitussin and get back to me.


I’m still writing pissy reviews, Casey. Pissy reviews of reviews, too. In any event, I try to focus my criticism or praise on the musical contents and leave the speculation about label motives to the bargain basement psychics and their sidekicks. Our reasons for being involved with the Prosaics were no different than what led us to be associated with the 2 Matador artists above that met with your approval. We liked their records and wanted to help ’em out. That you’re unlikely to dig all of ’em is neither unfair nor unexpected. But that wasn’t the point of my letter to Dusted, either. If you’re comfortable taking a shot or two at someone else’s work, it shouldn’t be so surprising if your own is held up for public examination. douchebag O-U-T!
as….well. God, it’s been a LONG day….
I’m about as die-hard a Dylan fan as they come, but the “Desire” cover is definitely a rip-off of the Phillips’ cover. Or, knowing the little smart-ass Bobby can be, it could have been a inside joke mockery of it as.Regardless, they’re both fantastic albums!
Ah, I forgive ye. ‘Tis the season, after all!
Excellent point. You even mentioned the album came out in 1970 and I missed it.
Contrary to popular opinion, I’m not actually anti-Christian. That said, I find many mainstream practitioners to be some of the most tight-hearted, closed minded weirdos around. They also typically know less about the origins of their own faith than non-believers. But there ain’t anything wrong with following Christ’s teachings, whether you believe he was the Son of God or not.Asobi Seksu would make the Top 20, for sure. But SM are moodier, and that seems to fit better with my overall mien.Re: Papa John. You got it backwards, brother. Wolfking predates Desire by several years. ‘Tis Dylan that’s the ripoff artist!
Nice list. Because Edwards is such a heavy-duty Christian, I’m surprised to find Wovenhand on your list. But since I like them, I’m glad to see it there.Serena Maneesh make the list but no sign of Asobi Seksu’s Citrus. Interesting.How badly is John Phillips trying to look like Bob Dylan in that album cover?
Wow…what a bag o’ douche….Great list Casey; I’ve only listened to a few of the albums listed, heard of (but not actually heard) a few others & the rest I’ve never even heard of before. Looking forward to listening to the new stuff; thanks again for giving into my peer pressure and posting your list! 🙂
Oh, it’s all water under the bridge now — it was two years ago. I admit it was harsh to make my review a forum through which to critique his label. I mostly wanted one of my fave imprints to not sign clones of their last big hit. I have no real animosity toward Cosloy, but I have been told he used to write quite a few pissy reviews back in his day.Anyway, here’s what he wrote to my Dusted editors:“What to make of a review that castigates a band for their supposedlack of originality…and in doing so, closely echoes several otherreviews that have appeared previously?Casey Rea — like a few other commentators thus far — seems hungup on the Prosaics’ “copping of Interpol’s patented EnigmaticUrban Mystey”;, though I think it would be worth reminding anyone whohas grown to appreciate the latter band’s merits that they too, wereat one time, pilloried for their stylstic similarities to anotherband (or two).Your reviewer is obviously entitled to his (screwy) opinions, butcomments like “over-rehearsed miserablism” (as opposed tounder-rehearsed miserablism?) and “despite (his) admitted love forgloomy English rock” say more about Rea’s biases and stereotypes he’dlike to ascribe to this band than what they actually sound like. Asone of the guys who signed them, I can categorically state that noneof the bands they reminded me of (in a good way) were English ornamed Interpol ; Pylon, The Method Actors and Native Tongue amongstthem.Which brings me to Rea’s most ridiculous statement ; “Matador shouldtake a tip from Sub Pop and start signing groups without dwelling onpast successes”. Hey, thanks a million for the constructivecriticism. Up until this point, the entire history of Matador islittered with examples of our signing one copy-cat band after anotherand until this very moment, nobody has had the guts to call us on it.Even so, we’ll continue to sign bands the same way we always have —based on our personal tastes, which clearly aren’t the same asDusted’s correspondent. But to suggest that Sub Pop’s recentsignings have paid bigger dividends, either artistically orcommercially compared to Matador’s, is just plain nuts. But eitherway, our associated with Prosaics hasn’t the slightest thing to dowith”the business of marketing”; — we’re psyched to be puttingout records by a NY band that we’d previously admired from afar, much theway we were once fortunate enough to put out records by the Unsane orRailroad Jerk or countless others who managed to make their mark inan unfriendly climate. Said climate is different now. For onething, there are more self-styled commentators eager to end a band’scareer before it starts.Let’s hear it for telepathy! Rea seems dead fucking certain of thisband’s inspirations and motivations, and equally cynical aboutMatador’s. And who is he to pass judgement? To call the recordingsflawed or downright crappy, while still incorrect, is entirely Rea’sprerogative. But he hasn’t the faintest idea what someone else’sgoals are. I humbly suggest that those equally sickened by thisreview (all 6 of you) do your best not to fall into the same trap. Ican’t figure out for the life of me why Dusted gave this cretin apublic forum (though it probably beats paying someone), much as I canonly speculate on why his parents didn’t have him put down at anearly age. It’s really none of my business and I’m gonna try veryhard not to dwell on those questions.”
What mean things did Cosloy say about you?