Fletcher Free Library Credit: File: Oliver Parini

An organization called Gender Critical Vermont has canceled a public discussion about “the unforeseen consequences of the transgender agenda,” saying planned protests would make for an unsafe environment.

The event had been set for 6:30 p.m. Tuesday at the Fletcher Free Library in Burlington. 

Critics caught wind of the event and vowed to protest the discussion they considered to be an attack on transgender people and their rights.

“The response of the transgender activist community in Burlington follows a familiar pattern of eroding the principles of free speech and rational discussion,” Gender Critical Vermont wrote in an email Monday afternoon announcing the cancelation.

Peggy Luhrs, a Burlington resident and lesbian activist since the 1970s, is one of the founders of the group and was scheduled to speak at the event. She told Seven Days the decision to cancel is only temporary.

“We will reschedule,” Luhrs said. “We’re going to look for a bigger venue, we’re going to look for a place where we can have security. There’s just no point in having a screaming match.”

According to a statement from Fletcher Free Library director Mary Danko, Gender Critical Vermont reserved a library meeting room for the purposes of hosting a “discussion group for Vermonters who oppose the subversion of Women’s Rights by the transgender agenda.”

The library consulted with the Burlington City Attorney’s Office and concluded the event fell within library guidelines for reserving space and should be allowed, Danko wrote in the statement, which was posted Monday to the library’s website.

“Public libraries have always been organizations that vigorously try to uphold the tenets of free speech on which our country was built. We have fought censorship on many levels, including efforts to ban books that occur still to this day,” Danko wrote.

Critics of  the event equated the planned discussion to hate speech and questioned why the city’s public library would allow it to take place.

Is the institution “truly abiding by their standards and directives of not promoting hate speech and violence?” asked Taylor Small, a trans woman who serves as director of health and wellness at the Pride Center of Vermont.

Dana Kaplan, the executive director at Outright Vermont, said he got calls from parents all over Vermont who were concerned that the library was hosting the event.

“I think that there are a lot of folks in our community who feel extreme relief that the event is canceled,” said Kaplan, who is trans.

There’s no trans agenda trying to subvert women’s rights, Kaplan added. The trans agenda, he said, is “of gender liberty where everybody gets to be themselves, and I feel that that is also a feminist agenda.

“I don’t understand the pitting against each other,” Kaplan said. “We’ve got a lot of bigger issues to focus on.”

Luhrs said the group is not a hate group nor was it going to use hate speech. The discussion was titled, “What are the unforeseen consequences of the Transgender agenda?” The description read: “If you are a Woman, Gay Man, Lesbian, Child or Parent, or cherish Free Thought/Speech, you have a stake in this conversation!”

“I’m not a transphobe. I don’t hate trans people,” Luhrs said. “This is about protecting women’s rights and lesbian rights. “

For example, she said, lesbians are often told “they are transphobic if they won’t consider trans women as partners,” even when the trans women have male genitalia.

Luhrs said she also planned to talk about how the trans movement could be hurtful to women’s sports and could undermine laws such as Title IX.

She wanted to discuss her opposition to puberty blocking hormones and gender reassignment surgery for people under the age of 18. Adults should be free to make those choices, but a “wait-and-see” approach is better for minors, Luhrs said.

Ultimately, the medical interventions don’t change her opinion that gender is fixed at birth. “I believe you can’t really change sex,” Luhrs said. “You can pretend you can, but you can’t.”

Trans activists immediately shut down any challenge by labeling opposing views as hate speech, she added. 

“This is totally Orwellian as far as I’m concerned,” Luhrs said, adding: “I have never seen so much authoritarianism from the left, except maybe Stalin.”

“I’m a longtime, very out lesbian, and I have no problem with gender nonconforming people,” she continued, “but I have a problem with a certain group that is trying to make all the rules their way.”

The discussion has yet to be rescheduled, Luhrs said.

The debate made its way to the Burlington City Council on Monday night, when Councilor Perri Freeman (P-Central District) introduced a resolution affirming the rights of trans people and condemning discrimination.

“The City of Burlington acknowledges and supports the existence of transgender and nonbinary individuals in our community and supports their rights and freedom to live openly, without fear of retribution,” reads the resolution, which passed unanimously. The city also “condemns any bigotry, hate speech, and exclusionary spaces that are hostile toward the very existence of transgender people.”

Despite the cancelation, two counter-events are still scheduled for Tuesday. From 6:30 to 8 p.m., Burlington resident Laura Hale has reserved the Fletcher Room at the library — next to the room that Gender Critical Vermont had reserved.

Hale’s event will include conversation, art and reading.

‘The intent is to celebrate the queer and trans community in Burlington,” said Hale, who is married to a trans woman.

Outright will host a letter-writing “heck yeah” event. Supporters are invited to visit the nonprofit’s office at 241 North Winooski Avenue in Burlington from 1 to 4 p.m. and write letters of affirmation to Vermont’s trans youth. Kaplan will then ask Fletcher Free Library to display them. Supporters can also email notes to info@outrightvt.org.

Reporter Courtney Lamdin contributed to this story.

Molly Walsh was a Seven Days staff writer 2015-20.

38 replies on “Amid Backlash, Group Cancels Burlington Talk on Transgender ‘Agenda’”

  1. I see that sevendays violated its own Letters to the Editor policy by publishing a second LTE from Christian Herrick slandering Gender Critical VT two months after this article appeared.
    ….and in the midst of an unprecedented global crisis.
    I guess it’s true that narcissism has no pause button.

  2. I see that Sevendays decided to violate its own letters to the editor policy by publishing a second LTE about this event from Christian Herrick, two months after the fact.
    ….and in the midst of an unprecedented global crisis.
    I guess it’s true that narcissism has no pause button.

  3. Outreach to Outright VT has not brought any willingness to discuss these issues. You cannot change sex. Every bit of DNA will remain as the sex one is born (not assigned) and hormones or surgery do not change that. There are growing numbers of de-transitioners, many of whom feel they were too easily “affirmed”. There is a push to trans now and Doctors have spoken out about the lack of support for a wait and see approach that often ends with a child realizing their homosexuality.

    But when the police in the UK go to people’s houses to “check their thinking” and hold a young mother in a cell for over 7 hours, separating her from her nursing child over a tweet, I think it’s time to ask why, in the name of a very tiny population, this is being done. No one to this day is checking anyone’s social media for misogynist or anti lesbian tweets. This is the new misogyny and like the old misogyny it is foremost about silencing women. The definition of bigot is; “a person who is intolerant of any creed, belief or opinion that differs from their own”. The bigotry here is those suppressing questions and differing opinions about the current transgender ideology. Adults and children should be free to dress as they wish and engage in whatever activities appeal to them.

    Adults will decide what course they take in life and all deserve full human rights and protection from discrimination. But transactivism cannot force people to believe what they know isn’t true or compel or forbid speech in the Orwellian manner now going on in the UK and in the USA with the firing of people who dared to resist the propaganda and relied on science and their own empirical knowledge.

  4. outsider looking in, trying to be an Ally in this and curious whether, in advance of this event, did Peggy Luhrs/Gender Critical Vermont ever reach out to Outright Vermont to internally discuss concerns and seek collaboration on possible resolutions? If so, pls advise if/how those discussions broke down? If not, why not why wouldn’t Gender Critical Vermont seek that internal dialogue first? …It seems that this event as advertised may not technically qualify as “hate speech” but advertising a public event about “the subversion of Women’s Rights” by transgender people- and “the unforeseen consequences of the transgender agenda” seem intentionally (unnecessarily) provocative. Indeed, it could stoke prejudice -even violence- against transgender people, including local trans youth. And that would be a sad, bitter irony… We all owe Peggy Luhrs much respect and gratitude for her lifelong fight against misogyny and male violence against women. But it seems she does her great legacy a disservice here, seeming divisive, even “subversive” to the greater fight against misogyny and patriarchy, and worse unintentional or not potentially stoking violence against transgender people and trans youth. As ever, Vermont has a chance to showcase its legacy of leadership on queer issues. Please- Gender Critical Vermont and Outright Vermont- meet in private first, discuss concerns and opportunities for reconciliation and also explore ways to present a united LGBT front publicly in the greater fight against patriarchy, misogyny and the EPIDEMIC of male violence against women. Remind us why you should lead that great fight. Please.

  5. Greetings to whomever.
    Please accept my appreciation of your well-thought-out and balanced article on the postponed discussion in the Fletcher Free Library by Gender Critical Vermont. The issues presented are indeed charged with emotion and are passionately felt on all sides. For over forty years, I have fiercely defended marginalized populations, and my credentials are well-established and widely known among fellow progressives.

    I do not think I am alone in my disbelief that saying “I disagree with you” constitutes hate speech. Democracy depends on free and open debate, and I look forward to learning what Gender Critical Vermont has to say. I hope that our community will continue to support free speech and allow individuals to form their own opinions.
    I must add that several friends have warned me against sending this comment. They suggested that doing so could jeopardize my livelihood. However, I refuse to accept that in this enlightened, well-educated community, there could be any risk in saying, “We need to hear what others think.”

  6. From Quillette https://quillette.com/2019/12/07/are-we-in…
    : …it’s also not true that most trans murders are motivated by “hate.” The first case I reviewed while researching this article, that of Claire Legato, involved a trans woman killed while attempting to break up a physical dispute over a financial debt between her own mother and a close family friend. This was not atypical. The conservative writer Chad Greene, himself a member of the LGBT community, recently reviewed a sample of 118 of the cases of anti-trans homicide compiled by the Human Rights Campaign. His conclusion: exactly four of the perpetrators were clearly motivated by “anti-trans bias,” animus, or hatred. In contrast, 37 of the murders were due to domestic violence, and 24 involved sex workers and were largely the result of the dangerous working conditions associated with illegal sex work. More than a few others were essentially random acts of violence: one of the victims in Greene’s data set was Jordan Cofer, the transgender man murdered by the Dayton Shooter. “

  7. From Quillette https://quillette.com/2019/12/07/are-we-in…
    : …it’s also not true that most trans murders are motivated by “hate.” The first case I reviewed while researching this article, that of Claire Legato, involved a trans woman killed while attempting to break up a physical dispute over a financial debt between her own mother and a close family friend. This was not atypical. The conservative writer Chad Greene, himself a member of the LGBT community, recently reviewed a sample of 118 of the cases of anti-trans homicide compiled by the Human Rights Campaign. His conclusion: exactly four of the perpetrators were clearly motivated by “anti-trans bias,” animus, or hatred. In contrast, 37 of the murders were due to domestic violence, and 24 involved sex workers and were largely the result of the dangerous working conditions associated with illegal sex work. More than a few others were essentially random acts of violence: one of the victims in Greene’s data set was Jordan Cofer, the transgender man murdered by the Dayton Shooter. “

  8. Gender Critical VT has no connection to Reddit and its gender critical thread. I have never even seen that Reddit thread or much else of Reddit.

Comments are closed.