With a gubernatorial veto becoming more likely — and with the current budget set to expire in 44 days — Vermont officials face a question they’ve never before had to answer: What if the state doesn’t have a new budget in place by June 30, the last day of the fiscal year?
Gov. Phil Scott, a Republican, has repeatedly said he’ll only sign a budget that includes a plan to reduce teachers’ health insurance costs. Scott, though, wants to realize the savings by bringing collective bargaining to the state level while most Democrats do not.
After several weeks of negotiations, legislative leaders announced Wednesday that they would go ahead and pass the budget on their terms, with or without the governor’s blessing. A vote could come as soon as Thursday.
If Scott follows through on his veto threat, the Democrat-controlled legislature would break and then return to hold a “special session,” likely in mid-June.
The political circumstances were different in 2009 when the last — and possibly only — budget veto took place. After then-governor Jim Douglas, a Republican, rejected the bill, Democrats, who had a super majority in the Statehouse, simply overrode it. But this time, Dems don’t have the numbers and House Republicans have pledged to sustain the veto.
That means the legislature would have to go back to the drawing board and again try to pass a budget acceptable to Scott.
If they can’t? Vermont Public Radio’s Peter Hirschfeld put that question to Gov. Phil Scott Wednesday.
“Oh, we’ve got a long time between now and July 1,” he responded.
Not that long, though. “Six weeks,” Hirschfeld said.
“I’m confident that common sense will prevail and we’ll have a budget come July 1,” Scott reiterated.
When pressed, the governor admitted, “I haven’t looked into it but I would assume essential services would continue.”
“Would there have to be cuts?” Seven Days’ Terri Hallenbeck asked.
“I’m not sure,” the governor responded.
When Hirschfeld put that question to legislative leaders, House Speaker Mitzi Johnson (D-South Hero) told him, “I think that’s a great question for the governor.”
The only person in the Statehouse Wednesday who could offer a definitive answer was Stephen Klein, the legislature’s chief fiscal officer. When asked, he pulled up the Vermont Constitution on a reporter’s phone and read a single line: “No money shall be drawn out of the Treasury, unless first appropriated by act of legislation.”
In other words, when the budget stops, the money stops. To avert a state government shutdown, the legislature could take temporary measures such as passing legislation that would fund state government for days, weeks or months until they agree on a permanent budget.
By the end of the day, Klein had been asked the question so many times he’d taken to carrying photocopies of the pertinent section of the constitution.



“You are trying to marry together issues that do not belong together with a quick fix solution. Vermont’s economy . . .”
No, it was you who introduced the state of the overall Vermont economy into the discussion. And you were right. The Vermont economy sucks. And that is not by accident. It is a direct and foreseeable result of the state’s long-term anti-business policies. Foisted upon us by the very same people who are the puppets of the teachers union in the legislature.
“Teachers are not demanding they make more than everyone else.”
That is just plain, obviously, and demonstrably false. Every time they negotiate a contract they seek wages and benefits that they absolutely, positively know that no one else in the state gets. Including the parents of all of the kids they are teaching, and the school board members sitting across the bargaining table.
“Their salaries are already in the middle of the pack.”
Middle of what “pack”? Where do you come up with this? Maybe in the “middle of the pack” nationally. But way above the average Vermont family income. One average teacher brings in more than most Vermont families.
“Reducing teacher wages and benefits does not solve the other issues …”
You keep repeating this propaganda. No one — absolutely no one — is talking about “reducing teacher wages.” The ONLY thing we are talking about is bargaining with the teachers union for healthcare benefits at the state level instead of at the local school board level. No one has made the case against this proposal. Not Tim Ashe. Not Mitzi Johnson. Not Martha Allen. No one.
If you look at the two largest State expenditures, they are education and healthcare (56%). The Governor’s proposal will not only save millions of dollars but will at the same time impact our two largest expenditures and presumably afford some relief to the property taxpayers and not alter the teacher’s benefits.
So, what’s the problem? The NEA and those legislators beholding to the NEA. It would be refreshing to see those legislators elevate the Vermont taxpayer over a special interest group in their list of priorities.
You are trying to marry together issues that do not belong together with a quick fix solution. Vermont’s economy is struggling, wages do not support the cost of living, and taxes are too high. This is not because teacher salaries are too high.
Teachers are not demanding they make more than everyone else. Their salaries are already in the middle of the pack. Middle of the pack spending on teacher wages should put Vermont’s education spending in the middle of the pack as well but this is not the case so other things are driving up this cost.
Reducing teacher wages and benefits does not solve the other issues but solving the other issues makes teacher compensation a non-factor.
The issue at hand is, at what level teacher healthcare negotiations should take place. Lade engages in diversion.
He agrees that education spending in VT is very high, but creates a diversion by saying that teacher salaries “alone” are not pushing education costs to the top. Well, at least 80% of the cost of local school budgets in VT are labor (i.e., salaries and benefits), so, yes, teacher salaries and benefits ARE primarily what’s driving VT education spending to the top of the country.
I agree that healthcare funding in VT in general is a problem and needs to be fixed nationally, but again that’s a diversion from the current issue of the teachers union wanting more and better benefits than what everyone else in VT gets.
Last, he again diverts with a comment about wages in VT being lower than average. That’s true. But the same legislators who are owned and controlled like robots by the teachers union are the very ones who have given us the tax, regulatory, and anti-business policies that make it impossible to do business here and for anyone — except the publicly-funded teachers, of course — to make a living in VT. Business is gone and the educated young have fled. There’s no one left to tax to death for publicly-funded health care and for the teachers’ exorbitant demands.
Keep throwing numbers around…$26 million, $19K, $28K. I agree that education spending in Vermont is near the top in the nation. Among the charts I’ve seen it is always in the top 8.
Teacher salaries are right around the middle in relation to the rest of the country. Teacher salaries alone are not pushing education spending to the top.
Special needs spending eats up a considerable amount of the education budget but nobody is going to be in favor of getting rid of those.
So let’s blame the teacher’s health care for this high price of education. Forget that health care in general needs reform and that for profit health care is far more disgusting than paying for education. Let’s also not look at why the burden of paying for education falls on the middle class property owner and not how this cost could be spread around. Let’s not look at why wages in Vermont are lower than average. Instead, let’s get out the pitchforks and torches and take out those greedy teachers.