CIty Hall Park design Credit: Suisman Urban Design

Trees destined for removal at Burlington City Hall Park may get a second chance.

The Burlington City Council unanimously passed a resolution Monday that would reopen the design process in an effort to alter the plan to add and preserve more trees.

The measure, introduced by Councilor Jane Knodell (P-Central District), came in response to opposition by the citizen group Keep the Park Green, which has argued that too many trees are slated to be cut down under the current redesign of the downtown park.

The renovations are set to begin in 2019 — and Knodell said the project would remain on track.

“This is not about going back to the beginning and starting all over,” she said. “This is about continuing to amend a plan that has evolved over a period of years.”

Dozens of Keep the Park Green members came out in support of Knodell’s proposal.

The existing plan “is a bully and the trees are its victims,” said Charles Messing. He quoted Abraham Lincoln as he urged the city to reopen the process: “Bad promises are better broken than kept,” Messing said.

Michael Long called the current design “insensitive [and] draconian in regard to the removal of trees.” He added, “It’s just the wrong direction.”

The resolution allows city officials to come up with ways to amend the plan, which they would then bring to a new ad hoc committee. That committee will include two members of Keep the Park Green, two city councilors, Council President Kurt Wright (R-Ward 4) or someone he appoints, and two members appointed by Mayor Miro Weinberger’s administration. The Board of Finance would also select an impartial facilitator to moderate the discussion.

The group would then report back to the council in June. The resolution also requests that the city conduct a soil study in an effort to keep existing trees healthy. No more money can be spent on the project until the council receives feedback from the ad hoc committee, according to the resolution.

In exchange, Keep the Park Green will not appeal the Development Review Board approval for the current park design, which was granted in March.

Trees decorated with ribbons and signs Credit: File: Katie Jickling

Starting in 2011, the city conducted surveys and held meetings as part of its public engagement effort surrounding the planned redesign. About 950 comments went into crafting the current plans.

“We did hear from a lot of people about what they needed” in City Hall Park, said Kelly Devine, executive director of the Burlington Business Association.

At the meeting Monday, members of the public who oppose the plan noted that the city has spent nearly $700,000 during the seven-year process.

Burlington resident Kienan Christianson described the opposition as part of a larger anti-development movement. “We’re seeing a startling trend in this city of people who want to stop development,” he said. Christianson called the current plans “beautiful and stunning.”

Weinberger said the city was trying to “achieve in a very small space many public objectives.” The mayor described the challenges of receiving conflicting feedback from the public.

Residents have more recently begun to push back against the plan, arguing that they were unaware that such a large number of trees were to be removed as part of the renovation.

It was widespread opposition to the current plan that spurred some councilors to act. Max Tracy (P-Ward 2) said that councilors in wards 2 and 3 conducted a straw poll at the Old North End Neighborhood Planning Assembly last week. Not one person attending supported the current park design, he said.

The resolution “hopefully acknowledges while we’ve made significant strides, that the design is not quite there yet when it comes to removal of trees,” he said in an interview with Seven Days. “We can do better.”

Correction, April 21, 2018: A previous version of this story misidentified Kienan Christianson.

Katie Jickling is a Seven Days staff writer.

24 replies on “Burlington City Council Votes to Re-Redesign City Hall Park”

  1. There’s another side to this too and that’s money. My understanding is the Pomerleau’s gift towards park renovation ($500K?) was tied to the water splash area. Mr. Pomerleau wanted it, so in order to gain his gift the design included the splash area. I don’t see why people are so quick to criticize people who want to save some shade trees and are willing to accept one person’s influential gift.

  2. @BDE
    Does it matter that Miro didn’t personally plant over a 1,000 trees. No! You have his support and I am sure that all the people with a cause would put the blame on him if one tree is cut down.

  3. Given the ongoing attacks on democracy around the globe (and inside the White House), it is naive to think Burlington is immune to authoritarian impulses. But make no mistake: the Council’s action is not about park design; loss of shade and grass; or trampled tree roots. It’s about trampling democratic processes.

    How ironic the four Council “progressives” proposed the resolution reversing the Development Review Board (DRB) approval. And how embarrassing for the rest of Council to follow suit. A WTF moment indeed! And all because a small (<200) and vocal group of opponents did not receive the outcome it wanted.

    I do not know the design details of the plan approved by the DRB; I am not an urban designer or expert. However, I am confident the City achieved its goal of ensuring City Hall Park will meet the 21st century challenges of being a being BTV’s multi-purpose, outdoor living room to be enjoyed by all. And the process was an example of participatory democracy: an open and public forum executed over several years complete with focus groups, public hearings and vigorous dialogue by approximately 1000 interested citizens. Their efforts and input were distilled by design professionals into a plan that was reviewed and approved by the DRB. For the Council to ignore the public record in this matter is self-righteous and arrogant.

    I’ve been told there is more to this “complicated” story. But as we learned in the recent Council handling of the BT sale, the Council doesn’t do complicated. And in this instance, it has chosen to reward the bad behavior by the complaining few, and punish the good work of the many who chose to participate in a positive way, Not a good look.

  4. @BDE I did use my voice, to vocally support the redevelopment plans of the park which are fantastic and amazing and were approved by the city through a very normally and well run public process. Lets cut down these trees and get to work. #forward

Comments are closed.