Burlington City Hall Credit: Alicia Freese

Burlington Planning Commissioner Lee Buffinton resigned from her position Thursday, hours after she recused herself from a hearing on a controversial zoning change that would allow 14-story buildings to be built in a section of downtown.

The six-year commissioner told Seven Days that her job at Champlain Housing Trust made a conflict of interest inevitable. At Wednesday’s commission meeting, Sarah Muyskens, the chair of CHT’s board, read a statement in favor of the zoning change, meant to enable redevelopment of Burlington Town Center.

Her recusal came after Commissioner Emily Lee read a letter, cowritten by Buffinton, that questioned the legality of Wednesday’s public hearing at City Hall and urged a slowdown in examining the proposed mixed-used residential, retail and office complex.

CHT has an employee conflict-of-interest policy that prohibits “public opposition of any CHT mission-related activity or project.”

“When Lee first joined the planning commission, folks told her this could be an issue from time to time,” Chris Donnelly, CHT’s director of community relations, told Seven Days. When she heard the statement from CHT in support of the development, “she realized that was a trigger,” Donnelly added.

Only four of seven commissioners ultimately voted on the proposal, and each of them supported sending the proposed zoning ordinance to the city council.

The $200 million project, headed by mall owner Don Sinex, includes plans for 160-foot-tall buildings on land bounded by Cherry and Bank streets. It would also reconnect portions of Pine and St. Paul streets, which were segmented when the mall was built in the 1970s.

Buffinton said CHT’s role in this and other upcoming projects, such as the one proposed on land once owned by Burlington College, meant she would frequently have to recuse herself from meetings and discussion.

“The planning commission deserves a full slate of seven engaged members to deliberate on these important issues,” she told Seven Days.

Buffinton also cited “personal reasons” for resigning — but did not elaborate.

Sasha Goldstein is Seven Days' deputy news editor.

14 replies on “Burlington Planning Commissioner Resigns After Public Hearing”

  1. What has been lost in the discussion is the Planning Commission without discussion or consideration sent pre-dated material they did not agree, i.e., an OK on zoning changes to the City Council for Council consideration without even talking about how those changes fit with the City Master Plan/planBTV.

    The question asked really
    , is the zoning change (not the project but the project is the zoning change for Sinex and the Mayor) consistent with the City Master Plan and Plan BTV? We all have our opinion. But that is the very question which obviously needs to be discussed thoroughly and then votes yes or no by the Planning Commission itself before moving onto the the details of the zoning changes. That is the job of the Planning Commission, that is their charge as I understand it in law–and they never discussed and came to a conclusion. It two years to complete the planBRV process–it took 65 days and the Planning Commission ducked the zoning change being consistent–and needed–to fulfill the purpose of the plan. Clearly hundreds of housing units and mixed use are very possible in six to ten story buildings–look at pp 110-111 of PlanBTV, a future vision for the Mall redevelopment visualized earlier this decade!

  2. @ Philo:

    “I understand you have the type of narrow mind that would draw one to support candidates like Hillary Clinton so I’ll leave you to that.”

    I’m supporting the exact same candidate as your god Bernie Sanders. Does he have a narrow mind? Or is it you who does?

    By the way, I find it ironic that by not voting for the Democratic nominee (in defiance of Bernie’s preference), you are effectively voting for Trump, since you are against “towers” and he builds them.

  3. The only thing that is fishy is the paranoia and bitterness of a small handful of complaining, anti-development Burlingtonians. Oh, wait. That’s not fishy. That’s normal. The photo of the seven ancient “Coalition” hippies across from City Hall with their handmade sign is funny.

  4. What is fishy about the process is most clearly evidenced by the fact that Mr. White, director of planning and zoning filed a report which is required to be prepared and filed by the Planning Commission 15 days before a public hearing. This report was written in the name of the Planning Commission, but they never saw it, never knew about it, never voted on it. As the letter written by Lee Buffinton and Emily Lee evidences, it was not at all representative of their positions as planning board members. See this letter at coalitionforalivablecity.blogspot.com under the post Communication by Emily Lee and Lee Buffinton on Improprieties surrounding the public hearing (a document in the public record). While the City Attorney defended Mr. White’s act, saying that it is fine for the Director to present this report instead of the Planning Commission, Vermont Law says otherwise. In fact, the Vermont Zoning Adminsitrator’s Handbook says, “to avoid an unhealthy mixing of roles, the ZA [zoning administartor]should not write the
    board or commission’s decision”. Leaving aside the probable illegality of Mr. White’s action, it is clearly unethical to misrepresent the positions of Planning Commissioners in an official document. Not fishy?

Comments are closed.