Talks between Burlington Telecom and CitiCapital have officially broken down, forcing the city telecom to return equipment it bought through a $33.5 million lease agreement with the financier.
In a letter filed with the Vermont Public Service Board late Tuesday night, BT’s attorney, William Ellis, said the transfer of equipment shouldn’t interrupt existing service, but that remains a possibility.
In mid-November talks stalled between the city and CitiCapital. The impasse ocurred when the city refused to agree to terms being offered by CitiCapital to make good on its lease.
“As a result of this impasse, Burlington and CitiCapital have agreed that the equipment lease is terminated. Now that the lease is terminated, the city will obtain replacement equipment either through a partnership or other means, which will allow CitiCapital equipment to be de-installed and returned,” Mayor Bob Kiss announced via email early Wednesday.
It’s unclear how much time Burlington Telecom and the city will have to un-install the equipment it bought with the borrowed funds and hand over the goods to CitiCapital. It’s not yet clear how Burlington Telecom will find the money — or a new private partner — to re-install equipment in order to keep phone, television and internet services flowing to its thousands subscribers.
According to the letter to the PSB, CitiCapital has agreed to let the city return the equipment “as soon as practical.”
“The city is presently researching several options,” wrote Ellis to the PSB. “Those options include the purchase of replacement equipment, which would allow the CitiCapital equipment to be de-installed and returned, as well as potential partnership opportunities consistent with the city’s obligation to propose a cure to the board.”
The city was unable to persuade CitiCapital to restructure its lease to more closely match its revenues. Burlington Telecom missed several lease payments this year; CitiCapital dipped into a $1 million reserve fund to cover most of those costs.
“The cornerstone of these negotiations has been a plan to utilize the positive cash flow Burlington Telecom is producing from regular operations to support a lease amendment. However, CitiCapital has been unwilling to make an accommodation the city could support,” Kiss said.
The two sides most recently met in Boston on November 15 where CitiCapital once again refused to write off part of its lease agreement, according to Ellis’ letter.
“CitiCaptial representatives also underscored their unwillingness to set a restructuring precedent with the city of Burlington that would redound to their and the industry’s detriment, if other municipalities took actions simile to Burlingtton,” Ellis wrote the PSB. “CitiCapital’s refusal to consider the city’s proposal for restructuring the lease agreement appears also to be influenced by the belief that a ‘higher authority’ will somehow find the money to make the payments ‘at the 11th hour’ if they remain steadfast in their demand for the leased equipment to be returned.”
Earlier this year, the city was in talks with the legislature about ways in which statutory language could be changed to allow the city to float a bond to help cover BT’s debt. Such a bond would need voter approval. That idea, however, never became law or even a proposed piece of legislation.
CitiCapital wasn’t buying any of the city’s claims, or its counter-offers, according to Ellis’ letter.
“The city made an interim proposal consistent with the legal restrictions on the use of city funds that included returning to the Legislature to reconsider the existing statutory restrictions. CitiCapital remained dismissive of the legal restrictions on the use of city funds and asserted that the city had an absolute obligation to make the scheduled lease payments as set forth in the lease agreement,” Ellis wrote.
In other words — the city and its taxpayers are on the hook to repay the money regardless of any legal or license conditions.
Though CitiCapital agreed to let Burlington Telecom and the city to return equipment “as soon as practical” it also wants to be paid in the interim for use of the equipment. The city is trying to renegotiate that condition.
“CitiCapital did agree to an accommodation period to allow continued use of its equipment on the condition that the city made minimum monthly rental payments of $311,000 ,which is well above market rates and beyond BT’s cash resources. The restructuring proposal before CitiCapital provides regular and recurring monthly payments without utilizing non-BT revenue. Moreover, it provides CitiCapital a substantial upside in a format that addresses their concern about setting an industry precedent,” Ellis wrote.
In the letter, Ellis requested a status conference with the PSB to talk about the lease termination in more detail as well as potential partnership opportunities to fund the replacement equipment and to propose a “cure”, or long-term solution, to the board.
Last month, the PSB found Burlington Telecom in violation of several conditions of its certificate of public good.
Despite the setback, the ever-optimistic Kiss said BT would continue to provide services to Burlingtonians.
“Burlington Telecom is an important asset of the City. As always, Burlington Telecom is committed to providing continuing service to the residents and businesses who are its customers in the city of Burlington,” said Kiss.
Download a copy of Burlington Telecom’s letter to the Vermont Public Service Board: Download Hudson, S ltr 11-23-10-1
The complete statement of Mayor Bob Kiss:
The City of Burlington has been in negotiations with CitiCapital to restructure its lease since early this year. The cornerstone of these negotiations has been a plan to utilize the positive cash flow Burlington Telecom is producing from regular operations to support a lease amendment. However, CitiCapital has been unwilling to make an accommodation the City could support.
As a result of this impasse, Burlington and CitiCapital have agreed that the equipment lease is terminated. Now that the lease is terminated, the City will obtain replacement equipment either through a partnership or other means, which will allow CitiCapital equipment to be de-installed and returned.
The City has requested a status conference with the Vermont Public Service Board to discuss this process in more detail as well as potential partnership opportunities to fund the replacement equipment and to propose a cure to the Board. Burlington Telecom is an important asset of the City. As always, Burlington Telecom is committed to providing continuing service to the residents and businesses who are its customers in the City of Burlington.
This article appears in Nov 24-30, 2010.


Interesting – scant mention of Kiss’ recent interviews on the subject, and no mention of the criminal investigation, much less the FBI’s involvement, in the lengthy “fair game” piece this week.The reality is that Citi isn’t going to separate the debt from the cable, because of the precedent it would set. If BT is sold, the debt rides with it. No version of BT can operate without the cable. Someone is going to have to start making payments to Citi if they want to use those lines. Kiss said that they could only make $40K/mo in debt payments – which translates to hundreds of years to pay off the money owed.There, you just learned more about BT in one paragraph than in the entire Fair Game piece. It’s done.
“Only people who voted for His Cluelessness should be taxed to pay for BT.”That’s a little extreme don’t you think? Of course, if we instituted that philosophy across the board, I wouldn’t be on the hook for the 27% increase to the US’s deficit while Bush was at the helm, right? On second thought, I’ll gladly accept my percentage of repayment for the $50 million owed by BT in exchange for anyone who voted for Bush accepting repayment for the trillions of dollars owed by the US government. Sounds fair to me.
The part that pisses me off — and should piss off every single Vermonter — is that this is clearly not just Burlington’s foolish Prog problem. We all know that ultimately every single Vermonter, from Pownal to Canaan and Vernon to Alburgh, and every town in between, is going to pay this bill. Every single Vermonter. Burlington taxpayers will refuse a $50 million tax surcharge so the rest of the state will end up bailing Burlington out. Only people who voted for His Cluelessness should be taxed to pay for BT, but we know that won’t happen.
Steve-O your calculations missed a few key points. The 17 million has increased because Kiss’s wunderkind Leopold was carrying that as an offsetting asset on the citys books. Using a debt to the cash pool allowed Leopold the fraud that our credit rating was AAA but it aint he lied fabricated a liar loan with no collateral.Leopold fudged the debt, ergo we will be paying more for every short term loan the city has taken on and our bond rating has tanked and will tank further.There are offsets, Leopold admitted to this legerdemain in a City Council meeting. He said if the BT loan moves from the asset to the liability column the city is screwed. Add another ten million in extra expenses.The city has no bargaining position, Citi financial has the assets of BT not just the equipment as collateral. They will not walk away and allow Kiss to use the fiber optic cable they own. As far as a give back when they repo I don’t think we payed principal payments they were to begin in August when we began defaulting on the loan. Legal fees should eat an additional 3-4 million and we have already spent about 750k on legal fees consultants and dithering.But lets just stay positive about BT for Bob Kiss’s fantasythat he is a competent human being.
Check this out. BT’s current total debt is about $50 million: the $33 million they owe CitiLease, and the $17 million they own the Burlington taxpayers (the money Leopold stole from the cash pool). Yeah, they’ll get some credit back from CitiLease when they hand over the equipment. So, let’s say they get a credit of $6-8 million. They’ll STILL owe CitiLease at least $25 million on the note. Am I right? You don’t get out of the debt obligation just by handing the equipment back over to the creditor, right? Just like you don’t get out of your mortgage obligation by handing your house back over to the bank. You still owe what the promissory note says you owe, less the value of the returned asset. Add to that $25 million the $17 million they owe the taxpayers, and you’re at $42 million.Then add in the $6-8 million it’ll cost to REPLACE the equipment they’re giving back to CitiLease and you’re back up to a total debt load of about $50 million.Is my math wrong?That’s $50 million that BT (i.e., the Burlington taxpayers) will own if the Kiss Mal-administration wants to keep the BT fiasco going.On the other hand, if they shut down BT, they’ll STILL owe about $42 million, right?So, either $50 million to keep the thing going, or $42 million if they shut it down.For an enterprise that is worth about $14-16 million? (That’s the price that the potential suitors have offered, based on their appraisal.)So, even if His Idiocy takes the best deal he can get — selling BT to these suitors for $14 million, then BT will STILL owe around $28 million ($42M minus $14M). That money’s got to come from somewhere folks — and that means the Burlington City taxpayers.Hey, you elected him.
http://www.vpr.net/news_detail/89384/Kiss on VPR yesterday, it’s a must-listen. The guy is downright delusional. “The city’s financial position is pretty good,” but he consistently dodges the question of how they’re going to pay back the $17+m. Also, apparently it’s no big deal that Citi terminated the “lease” – they were just paying principal and interest on $32.5m to lease equipment that apparently will only cost $6-8m to replace. When asked who owns the cable, he simply ignores the question. The whole thing is unbelievable.
IRV = election of moron.
Jimmy you do not de-install all of the cable you pay rent to the owner of the fiber optic cable. This is not a new model of ownership phone companies lease lines all the time. Burlington is not as Bob Kiss likes to think a banana republic where he can seize the fiber as eminent domain.Kiss has his head up his dark hole. BT is dead the city will never be able to turn it on with out negotiating with Citi. Kiss says that BT and the equipment lease are two separate animals but this really isn’t true. BT the asset was collateralize against the loan which means the subscriber list belongs to Citi to sell off as they see fit. So anyone who wanted to keep their email name or phone number without jumping through bunch of hoops would travel tothe new company.Bob Kiss lives in a fantasy land. If your car is repossessed you do not tell all of your friends you can take them for a ride because you had just put 5 bucks in the tank. I believe if a five year old pasted a horn in the middle of Kisses head and told him he was a unicorn Bob would march up and down main street claiming he was a unicorn. The man is a moron and that is a slap in the face to morons everywhere.Leopold has booked the liar loan of 17 million as an assert on the city’s books. Kiss claims he has balanced the budget created a surplus but Leopold admitted that when the “liar loan” was moved from the asset column to the LIABILITY column, the credit rating takes a huge dump and his balance sheet bleeds red. We are bleeding vermilions Now!
@ Rich:”And I think it’s our right as citizens, to say to CITI: You’re not welcome here. There’s nothing wrong with that Jimmy, is there? It’s just good business.”Huh? Are you trying to be funny in some morbid way? Isn’t that kinda like me telling my mortgage company, after they’ve foreclosed on my house ‘cuz I didn’t pay my mortgage, “you’re not welcome here”? I’m sure they’ll be all heartbroken that I’ve banished them. Um, ok, and I guess Citi says, “Well, we don’t care whether you “want” us here or not, ‘cuz we were leaving anyway — WITH our equipment. AND the money you owe us.Guess you “citizens” win that one, eh, Rich?
@Rich, Citi DIDN’T do anything wrong here. What you call their “moralizing” is just Ellis editorializing. All they’ve said is that if you haven’t paid your debt, and you can’t even tell us how you plan to rectify the situation, you can’t keep the equipment that secures that debt. It couldn’t be simpler.If they did anything wrong, it was making the loan in the first place. It was a terrible loan. BT never had any hope of paying back that kind of debt.”And I think it’s our right as citizens, to say to CITI: You’re not welcome here. It’s just good business.”If you think boycotting a company because they fulfilled their end of a bargain and pulled out when the other side didn’t – and clearly would never be able to – is just “good business,” then I’m going to take a wild guess that you’re not in a position to throw any business Citi’s way anyway.Bye bye, BT. So long, Burlington bond rating. And everyone kiss several thousand dollars EACH in rent/property tax goodbye, because that’s what it’s going to take to make up the $17+ mil.