Debate over the F-35 has been dominated in recent weeks by the plane’s opponents. But supporters of basing the fighter jets at Burlington International Airport went on the offensive Wednesday.
Their tactics did not prove as creative or as colorful as the opposition’s deafening F-35 noise simulation and the fudge-gifting event staged at Sen. Patrick Leahy’s downtown office. The organizer and two prominent backers of the Green Ribbons for the F-35 campaign held a traditional press conference at the Main Street headquarters of the Lake Champlain Regional Chamber of Commerce.
The pro-F-35 speakers nevertheless made controversial claims that were met with skepticism from some of the reporters in attendance.
Chamber president Tom Torti argued, for example, that there’s no validity to the case against the plane on the basis of the noise it makes. “We believe that’s a red herring,” he declared.


Seems like you need to get a dictionary – and spend some time in Winooski. Preferably on a Monday when the Air guard doesn’t normally schedule training flights. You might be surprised at what you find in each.
Care to prove to me that Winooski-ites all wear earplugs all day and night, stay in their homes, don’t hear car horns, car alarms, sirens, and jackhammers, don’t put iPod earbuds in their ears and crank the tunes, don’t listen to loud stereos, don’t go to the movies, don’t go to concerts, don’t play video games, don’t do any air travel, don’t watch fireworks, and don’t go to carnivals and fairs and fun parks?
Care to cite any examples of this ‘hypocrisy’ in Winooski?
Yes, you’re absolutely correct: I do try to avoid exposing myself to loud noises.
Unlike the people who are hypocritically complaining about the F35s.
Earplugs, since you aren’t aware, can be purchased that allow normal speech to pass right through and block out damaging levels (under about 120 dB). I can go to a concert, still have normal conversations and not have any ringing or discomfort and – as a result – minimize or eliminate the sounds I’m exposing myself to. I usually go because it’s a great time – why else would anyone go to a concert?
You probably don’t though since you want to avoid all that loud racket from the jackhammers and sirens every ten feet here in the big city.
” I wear earplugs when I’m operating machinery or attending concerts”
You go to concerts? Oh, my! You’re harming yourself!
And you allegedly wear earplugs? So why go at all?
First – it’s not OK to expose people to damaging noise simply because they have neighbors. I don’t voluntarily harm myself – pity you seem to believe all should be forced into submission from damaging sound levels just because you choose to ‘watch TV loud’. Personal choice goes both ways – while you choose to turn your TV up I can make other choices. I wear earplugs when I’m operating machinery or attending concerts – and shouldn’t have to wear them inside my house or in my backyard.
Second – you display a fundamental misunderstanding of how sound works. Sound drops by a measurable amount (about 6 dB or 2-3 X quieter) with a doubling of distance. For an F-35 measured at 131 dB 500 feet away, you need to be 1,000 feet away for the sound to drop to 124 dB. An F-35 at even 5,000 feet is still substantially louder at 103 dB than a lawnmower would be at just six feet away (88 dB). Things like Lawnmowers, sirens and traffic are also on the ground. The ground itself, any object on the ground, and any organic material (grass or trees) will block and diffuse the sound. However, when something is overhead in the air – that is not the case.
“I don’t willfully place my head near fireworks, jackhammers, loud music, sirens, etc.”
Not true. If you choose to live in an urban environment, you do exactly that. You choose to expose yourself to a constant barrage of very loud noise.
And even if you live in a suburban and rural environment and you put in earbuds and listen to music or watch loud TV or do a thousand other things we do everyday — or allow your kids to do so — you’re voluntarily harming yourself.
Now that’s a huge leap to an assumption! I don’t willfully place my head near fireworks, jackhammers, loud music, sirens, etc. I can’t think of any neighbors that do either – but here’s one huge difference. Willfully placing yourself near something that’s mildly loud is very different than a government organization forcing 8,915 locals exposure to sound that is known to be damaging – in contrast to known government health standards & Air Force protocols – removing the choice and having a significant impact on the health and financial well being of the area.
My point. All the people who are complaining about the jet sound are willingly exposing themselves to harmful noise on a daily basis.