Franny Max, left, and David Hubert at the Bloodstained Men & Their Friends protest against circumcision. Credit: Molly Walsh/Seven Days

“My penis is just fine,” shouted a young male motorist Monday at the busy intersection of Dorset Street and Williston Road in South Burlington before screeching off.

Was someone asking after the health of his sex organ? Sort of. The man, presumably circumcised, was responding in loud disagreement to a clutch of roadside activists protesting circumcision. They dressed to stop traffic in all-white clothing with blood-red patches over their crotches and signs showing babies and bearing slogans such as: “How Dare You Cut His Penis!”

Circumcision is performed on males, typically when they are newborns, and entails cutting the foreskin from the penis.

Concern about the practice and shifting recommendations from public health experts contributed to a drop in rates of circumcision in the U.S. between 1979 and 2010. It fell from 65 to 58 percent of male newborns over that time, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
  
Now the rate appears to be climbing back, possibly in response to research showing that circumcision can help reduce the spread of HIV and other STDs. Three years ago the American Academy of Pediatrics revised its position on circumcision to offer stronger support. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has also chimed in, saying the benefits outweigh the risks.

The anti-circ squad on the streets Monday remains dead-set against the practice.  “It’s really barbaric and harmful and babies scream like hell,” said Franny Max of Montreal, as she stood in a white outfit waving a sign at traffic.

None of her four sons has been circumcised, nor have the males in her extended family, Max said. She acknowledged the research about STD transmission, but said condoms, not circumcision, are the way to prevent the spread of sexually transmitted diseases.
 
She and other anti-circumcision protestors said the procedure causes pain, risks infection, reduces sexual pleasure and reduces penis size. “If you cut something, you make it smaller not bigger,” Max said. “If you cut a loaf of bread, you have a smaller loaf of bread.”

Max started protesting circumcision after one of her sons, then a baby, was in the hospital intensive care unit for a health problem, and she observed the procedure being done on newborns. “I saw other babies having vivisection basically, and it was horrible,” she said. 

One of the props at the protest Monday was a plastic baby doll with two surgical clamps attached to its penis and a sign a

Protesters used a plastic doll as a prop Monday. Credit: Molly Walsh/Seven Days

sking, “Was this you?”  Circumcision advocates say the pain is temporary, infection risk is low and any reduction in penis size is not noticeable. The CDC says studies around sexual sensation are mixed. 

The protest is part of a campaign by a national organization called Bloodstained Men & Their Friends. Some of the protesters were heading to Portland, Maine and other locations in the northeast after the stop in the Burlington area.

If circumcision is worthwhile, then boys can choose to have the procedure once they are adults, many of the protesters said. Harry Guiremand says he views his parents as “incompetent” for having him circumcised as a baby.

“Why didn’t anyone protect me?” he asked. Guiremand, who is from Hawaii, is on the road protesting the issue so future generations of boys are not subjected to what he sees as a brutal procedure. “It’s up to me, it’s up to us, to protect them.”

The fake-blood-stained get-ups help bring eyes to the issue, Guiremand added. “It catches peoples’ attention. They can’t look away.”  

Most of the eight or so protesters were from outside Vermont. The exceptions were Amanda Fortier of Barre Town and Erin Langevin of Monkton, who came with their uncircumcised 3-year-old sons. The tots played with toy trucks on the ground as their moms waved signs.

Circumcision is  wrong on many levels, including the baby’s lack of choice in the decision, Langevin said. “You’re forever changing their bodies, and they had no say in it.” 

An earlier version of this article in one section incorrectly stated Franny Max’s name.

Molly Walsh was a Seven Days staff writer 2015-20.

38 replies on “How Dare You! Protesters Exclaim”

  1. Mutilating. “To injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts. To deprive (a person or animal) of a limb or other essential part.”
    Crushing: (From a site explaining the different types of circumcisions, this is from the Plastibell method) “A ligature is tied firmly around the foreskin, CRUSHING the skin against the groove in the Plastibell. Then the excess skin protruding beyond the ring is trimmed off. Finally, the handle is broken off at the end of the procedure.”
    This is the site.
    http://www.circinfo.net/the_procedure_itself.html
    Flaying: to strip off the skin or outer covering of.
    Isn’t that exactly what Circumcision does?

    I realize those words elicit emotions, but they are not in fact emotive. They are factual words that correctly describe the procedure. If that bothers anyone, it is on them. Why? Does it feel wrong to use those words and infant together? If so that tells you something.

    For the comment about c-sections … a surgery to help one or both parties live is not comparable to a forced cosmetic one. The only comparable surgery is female genital mutilation, period.

  2. I was called anti-semitic for not supporting circumcision…a guy told me that european men chose uncircumcision because they wanted to spite jews or secretly support the holocaust.. i am uncircumcised becaue my family thought it was unecessary for me… i like my penis but i thought girls hated foreskins so i felt like a freak when i was 18…i hope i am not antisemitic

  3. All the issues in the world, and state for that matter and we are concerned with the foreskin? ITS A PERSONAL CHOICE….so get the hell out of everyone else’s life folks.

  4. Well I say that most people view female circumcision/female genital mutilation as barbaric. So how does male circumcision not qualify also? These body parts whether male or female serve a purpose and a function. I prefer to not lose parts of my body. I would advocate for no circumcision on either sex. Teach proper hygiene and birth/disease control and the boys will be just fine.

  5. In the tone of this article, I read an author who either chose to circumcise her son(s) or, at the very least, planned to if she ever had a son. Not hard to figure out people’s past choices based on the biases they exhibit involving this issue.

  6. Pro or Con, there is no reason you need to have signs written out with the word Penis on it and fake blood, so all our kids or grandkids see this . this is a teaching issue, go to the schools and colleges to see if you can protest or do classes on the pro and cons. but get the hell off the public street corners….. I do still think we hae laws on the books to say what you can and can’t do in public. The anti abortion group can’t protest in peace on the sidewalk but you can do this. Go figure . and I do wish you luck in your crusade if it is all the truths. but take it inside.

  7. I love all the outrage by women! Let me tell you from personal experience, I have no memory of any pain, its easy to clean, and cute. Keep your laws off my body (and my kid’s body).

  8. It was intactivosts like these who helped me see that circumcision isn’t “just something they do” and what it really is, an outdated barbaric procedure kept alive by social stigmas and tradition and people inability to even consider that they made a mistake, or that their own body could be better had it been left intact.

  9. ‘Circumcision is wrong on many levels, including the baby’s lack of choice in the decision, Langevin said. “You’re forever changing their bodies, and they had no say in it.”‘

    So, I am assuming that these protestors are also opposed to abortion, which is also done with the baby’s lack of choice and does kill them. Just saying.

Comments are closed.