โ€˜America at Its Bestโ€™

I enjoyed the well-written and balanced article about the NIMBY struggles of Sarah Beal and David Kenyon [โ€œLove Thy Neighbor?: Charlotteโ€™s Cherished Old Brick Store Is Thriving. Thatโ€™s Created Problems for the Homeowners Next Door,โ€ November 4]. In the last line, Ms. Beal expresses her desire to get a muffin and โ€œfeel good about it.โ€

I can empathize with Ms. Beal. She bought a lovely house with easy access to good muffins. The muffins are so good, in fact, that now everyone wants to come enjoy them. This is what has made Ms. Beal angry โ€” too many muffin lovers! So, Ms. Beal has, of course, lawyered up.

America at its best.

Mayorโ€™s โ€˜Misstepโ€™?

[Re โ€œBurlington City Council Confirms Anthony Geraci as Police Chief,โ€ November 9, online]: While I also hope the new police chief will be successful, Mayor Emma Mulvaney-Stanak missed the mark when she apologized to the new chief and his family for the comments of Councilors Becca Brown McKnight and Evan Litwin as though their criticism was aimed at him. I think the criticism belongs to her.

Why, when she had two yearsโ€™ notice to hire a new chief, did she wait until just months before interim chief Shawn Burkeโ€™s departure to select a candidate? I doubt many of the city councilors had much time to even meet him. There certainly isnโ€™t time to look for other candidates, even if they wanted to.

Who was on the hiring committee? Why werenโ€™t the members announced publicly? I wrote to the mayorโ€™s office two years ago, expressing interest in being on the hiring committee, and heard nothing. How were the hiring committee members selected? How many officers were included? Was chief Burke asked to vet the candidates?

The mayorโ€™s poor management of the two-year timeline, her lack of transparency in the process, and her unwillingness to include the city councilors in a timely and meaningful way are baffling. The police chief is an important post and will have a critical impact on whether the good work chief Burke started will continue.

Public safety is a huge issue that Burlington must improve upon, and we canโ€™t afford another misstep.

Welcome to SoBu

As reported by Colin Flanders in โ€œNot in My Suburbโ€ [September 9], the Champlain Valley Office of Economic Opportunity has been looking for a place to put a 100-bed, low-barrier homeless shelter and identified a suitable location on Williston Road, adjacent to โ€œBetaville.โ€ However, even before the idea was proposed, South Burlington city staff raised objections, arguing that โ€œa large homeless shelter could prompt other communities โ€” potentially even outside of Vermont โ€” to send people there.โ€

In stark contrast, city manager Jessie Baker is quoted by Aaron Calvin in โ€œSpreading Its Wingsโ€ [October 21]: โ€œSouth Burlington aspires to be a very welcoming community, and that means being welcome to anyone who wants to come and join us. I hope our neighbors are willing to welcome new neighbors to their neighborhoods as well.โ€

Welcoming newcomers, as Baker says, cannot mean welcoming only those who arrive with jobs and investment behind them. Betaโ€™s growth may bring real benefits to South Burlington, but the people seeking shelter are our neighbors, too. When officials celebrate a companyโ€™s expansion while opposing a place for people in crisis โ€” citing the possibility that other communities might send them here โ€” the cityโ€™s welcome sounds conditional; economic newcomers are invited in while unhoused people are treated as someone elseโ€™s responsibility.

If South Burlington truly wants to be welcoming, it should apply that principle to its most vulnerable neighbors and work with CVOEO on a viable shelter plan, rather than helping send them elsewhere.

Ed Funding Redo

In Alison Novakโ€™s [โ€œRough Cuts: Vermontโ€™s School Districts Face Difficult Decisions as They Begin Crafting Next Yearโ€™s Budgets,โ€ October 28], Meghan Metzler, board chair of Champlain Valley School District, says โ€œthe district isnโ€™t contemplating any school closures. But getting the target budget number will undoubtedly mean cutting more staff.โ€ I am surprised that the metric primarily used by school boards and superintendents equates cost savings directly to the number of full-time educator reductions.

With Vermont having one of the highest per-pupil costs in the nation, combined with our declining test scores, we need to modify our thinking and our system of education funding.

As a retired educator, I have seen the number of school and district administrators balloon to an untenable level. I support looking at consolidating the school districts and cutting the number of administrators and staff who are not involved in direct student contact. Do we need all these superintendents, additional highly paid administrators, school buildings and all the related maintenance costs, along with all the administrative staff to support these entities for the approximately 80,000 students in Vermont?

No.

Maybe a change is needed in the dreaded annual school budget cycle. The work needs to include politicians in Montpelier and the Vermont Agency of Education working in unison with local school officials. Doing the same thing year in and year out and expecting a different result is frequently called insanity. I propose sanity in education funding and fiscal considerations.

Love Tom Tomorrow

Imagine if Tom Tomorrow, creator of the cartoon โ€œThis Modern World,โ€ were to place an ad in the Seven Days personals: โ€œLooking for someone to share with me a world of unequivocal and palpable sarcasm โ€” and willing to communicate in snide and cynical in-your-face honesty. Must use words as if they were blunt-force instruments. Willing to show you just how vapid and irrelevant this current presidency is as it actually falls off the cliff of intelligence, like lemmings running blindly into the abyssโ€ฆโ€ 

Tom would have to fight back troves of responses from his readers, thirsting for his weekly reminders that โ€œThis Modern Worldโ€ is indeed hysterical and obvious. And dumber than a doorknob.

Please, Tom, keep reminding us!


Lake Effect

The November 4 cover package headlined โ€œTroubled Watersโ€ prompted a steady stream of thoughtful letters to the editor. Hereโ€™s a sampling of reactions to the first part of our yearlong investigation with ProPublica into the cleanup of Lake Champlain. The published stories were โ€œBillion-Dollar Question: The Spending on Lake Champlain Cleanup Has Surpassed $900 Million. So Why Isnโ€™t the Project on Track?โ€ and โ€œNixed Results: Vermont Legislators Ordered an Outside Audit to Ensure the Costly Lake Champlain Cleanup Was Working. It Was Never Done.โ€


Your cover story on Lake Champlain cleanup neglected two important reasons progress is so difficult.

First, phosphorus input comes from hundreds of thousands of sources, because it comes from you and me and every property, business and farm. Think of driveways, roads, sidewalks and parking lots as streams โ€” because, when it rains, thatโ€™s what they are! Any loose soil or plant matter on pavement (or packed dirt roads) is phosphorus headed for Lake Champlain.

Can millions in state spending make you sweep all grass clippings off your sidewalk? Ensure your neighbors never spill soil on their driveway when planting annuals? Compel everyone to rake leaves out of the gutter or rural ditch daily? No one wants heavy-handed ordinances dictating citizensโ€™ personal behavior. Yet how else can we stop stormwater phosphorus?

Also, the article leaves out the role zebra mussels play in encouraging cyanobacteria blooms. Zebra mussels are filter feeders; they suck in lake water, digest the microscopic life and release filtered water. But zebra mussels donโ€™t like cyanobacteria โ€” in fact, they spit them out! This means zebra mussels eat the plankton that prey on cyanobacteria, and they eat the beneficial algae that compete with cyanobacteria, but they donโ€™t eat cyanobacteria. What a bonus for those toxic blooms! Their enemies get eaten, and their competitors get eaten, but they get a free pass. Itโ€™s no coincidence that zebra mussels arrived in Lake Champlain in 1993, reached the northeast arm in 1995 and toxic blooms began in 1999.


Good news! Iโ€™m bringing a new business to your town. Let me tell you about it. I produce a product that is already in oversupply, so Iโ€™ll need a subsidy from you to make a profit. My small margin means I canโ€™t pay enough to hire local folks, so Iโ€™ll have to import low-cost foreign workers, work them ungodly hours and house them in substandard conditions. My product, while wholesome, produces a large amount of toxic waste that absolutely reeks. And since I canโ€™t afford to manage it correctly, Iโ€™ll be dumping it in the river. Youโ€™ll have to pay hundreds of millions of dollars to clean it up. Does this all sound OK with you?

This is Vermont industrial dairy, all day, every day. Asking why Lake Champlain is a sewer is like smashing your thumb with a hammer and asking why it hurts. The current situation gives the lie to the idea that Vermont politicians work for our stateโ€™s citizens and not the chosen few, who, as always, are privatizing their profits and socializing their losses. Free-market capitalism, my dairy air!


That weโ€™ve spent nearly a billion dollars on lake cleanup efforts to achieve โ€ฆ not nearly enough โ€ฆ is unfortunately not a surprise to anyone following this issue closely. That average phosphorus levels have increased over the past decade in the southern and northeastern parts of the state points to our failures in addressing runoff from the single largest source of lake pollution: agriculture, especially dairy. 

So-called โ€œcap-and-tradeโ€ solutions have been the hallmark of cost-effective environmental cleanup efforts for decades, whereby a regulatory body sets a cap on total emissions โ€” in this case, phosphorus โ€” and allocates discharge permits to polluters, then gradually reduces the cap over time to a targeted level. Permittees are then able to trade pollution credits so that those for whom compliance is costlier can buy the right to maintain their emissions, while those for whom cleanup is cheaper can do so and reap the benefits of selling excess credits. 

This approach has proven far more effective across a broad range of cleanup efforts than the path Vermont has taken to date: doling out millions in grant monies and requiring those unfortunate entities liable for cleanup under the misguided โ€œthree-acre ruleโ€ to spend a lot to achieve little in the way of phosphorus reduction. 

Our state has an extremely long list of investment needs, from more affordable housing and health care to aging infrastructure repairs. Not pursuing the most cost-effective solution to our mandated lake cleanup is costing us hundreds of millions in money better spent elsewhere.


Dairy farms have been made obsolete by concentrated animal feeding operations, which operate essentially unregulated, and they do what they do because raising cows on pasturelands is more expensive than the cruel method of containing them in a warehouse. As a real farmer, you canโ€™t compete with that; youโ€™d have to join them. The businessmen who own CAFOs, as we now know, make the environment suffer, as well as the people who would like to enjoy it. A few bad apples spoil the bunch. Another few bad apples do nothing about what they are doing, though we elect them time and time again.

There was a Seven Days article about the condition of the Vermont dairy industry three and a half years ago, which apparently hasnโ€™t caused anyone to end the abuse of waterways and animals [โ€œโ€˜Get Big or Get Out,โ€™โ€ The Dairy Issue, May 31, 2023]. Algae bloom trouble in Lake Champlain began when the CAFOs arrived. So, who is more important, the new dairymen or the rest of us? Ben & Jerryโ€™s should update its packaging to show wall-to-wall cows with no way to move around. When politicians and big businesses work together like they do in this country, bad things happen.

Corrections

The November 4 news story about the Old Brick Store in Charlotte, headlined โ€œLove Thy Neighbor?,โ€ used an inaccurate word to describe the waste resulting from the storeโ€™s septic system. The proper term is effluent. Along similar lines, store owner Jolene Kao didnโ€™t โ€œdelayโ€ a meeting with her neighbors in late July. She said the meeting would need to wait because of travel plans.