Left to right: Supreme Court Justices Beth Robinson, John Dooley and Harold Eaton Jr. Credit: Matthew Thorsen

Two days before he steps down, Gov. Peter Shumlin will need to convince the Vermont Supreme Court that he has the legal right to appoint a replacement for retiring Justice John Dooley. The court has temporarily blocked Shumlin from picking a new justice in response to a legal challenge from House Minority Leader Don Turner (R-Milton).

Dooley announced in September that he would retire when his term ends on March 31. Shumlin raised some Republican hackles by promptly declaring that he would pick Dooley’s successor. Now, the outgoing governor will spend his final days in office defending his decision in court — a hearing is scheduled for January 3.

“By looking to make a consequential executive decision that should rightly be made in April 2017, at a time well past his gubernatorial tenure, Gov. Shumlin is setting a troubling precedent of overreach,” Turner said in a statement announcing his legal challenge.

Reached Friday, Turner said he’s “very pleased” with the court order and is confident he’ll prevail. “When I look up vacancy in the dictionary, it means no one is in the position,” Turner said.

Shumlin spokesperson Scott Coriell told Seven Days that “the governor has been following the law” per this state statute: “Whenever a vacancy occurs in the office of a Supreme Court Justice, a Superior Court judge, magistrate, or Chair of the Public Service Board, or when an incumbent does not declare that he or she will be a candidate to succeed himself or herself, the [Judicial Nominating] Board shall submit to the Governor the names of as many persons as it deems well qualified to be appointed to the office.”

Scott told Vermont Public Radio earlier this month that he had no plans to interfere in the process. In a statement Friday, Scott said he has “a lot faith in the Court to provide clarity on this issue and make the appropriate ruling.”

Coriell said Shumlin has interviewed the six candidates submitted to him by the Judicial Nominating Board but has not yet named a replacement for Dooley. Coriell deferred to Attorney General Bill Sorrell, who could not be reached, for further comment.

Alicia Freese was a Seven Days staff writer from 2014 through 2018.

13 replies on “Vermont Supreme Court Blocks Shumlin From Picking New Justice”

  1. Heat doesnt really concern me, especially from pseudonymous sources, but I do appreciate real thoughtful dialogue, so thanks again for the reply, Senator.

    Only two possibilities make sense to me. Either the incumbent governor can make an appointment, he does so before the terms of the existing senators expire, and the senate is able to consent before all the relevant terms expire. Or the governor does not make the appointment before his term expires, or the senators terms have expired by the time it is able to consent, then the new governor and the new senate appoint a new JNB, which then makes a new set of recommendations, and then the new governor appoints and the new senate confirms. Unlike you, in that circumstance, I assume the old recommendations would expire with the old JNB.

    Why should a new governor and/or a new senate be bound by recommendations from a JNB whose terms have expired?

    You seem to believe that the JNBs job is to make the recommendations because the statute so commands. But that doesnt make much sense to me unless this is some kind of make work program for appointees.

    The statute orders them to do so in order that the governor can make a (legally acceptable) appointment and for no other reason.

    In effect, I see this as ONE job, of which there are 3 coordinated parts: the JNB recommends so that the governor can appoint so that the Senate can confirm. Take out any one of the three parts and the job is not complete.

    It will, indeed, be interesting to see what the Supreme Court has to say. Theres a lot more here than first meets the eye.

  2. John Greenberg: Thanks for the discussion. I’m sorry to see you are taking some heat from the political end, but I guess it should be expected.

    The question you raise about which JNB should create a list is a valid one. The same can be said about the senate, which has the responsibility of providing its “advice and consent.” Should it be the senate constituted at the time the JNB makes a list, the senate constituted at the time the governor names a replacement, or the senate constituted at the time the vacancy factually occurs? If the Governor was to appoint a replacement on Tuesday of next week, should it be the senate on Tuesday or the new one sworn in on Wednesday that gives the advice and consent? I would argue that there is no problem if the JNB, governor and senate each remained in their respective silos and abided by the plain language of their authorizing documents. The JNB has done its job. No action should be taken by the governor until the office is factually vacant. The senate can then do its job and the process will have worked as intended.

    I still cling to the belief that the governor’s job is limited to the language of the constitution and nothing about the statute, explicit or implied, vests him with power. I did not mean to imply that the documents themselves are in conflict with each other. Conflict is only created through the governor’s interpretation. It will be interesting to see how the Supreme Court decides it. Thanks again for the discussion.

  3. Citizen claims that I said that a governor is not allowed to act on issues after their term is up. I didnt say anything resembling that, although if citizen means that governors may act as governors only while theyre serving as governors and not afterwards, it would certainly appear to be correct.

    In any case, none of this is at issue here. The current governor was planning to make the appointment DURING his term, not after. Representative Turner has raised the issue of whether the appointment can be made when a justice declares that he does not wish to be reappointed, or only after he actually vacates his position and the Supreme Court of Vermont will now hear and decide the case.

    In the face of Senator Bennings argument for Rep. Turners position, Ive tried to show that there is a reasonable legal argument to be made for the governors plan, and indeed, that the latter position is MORE reasonable legally because it gives full meaning and force to both the statute AND to the constitution, while Bennings interpretation puts them in conflict.

    In any case, no one is trying to change the rules. There is a legitimate question here as to what the rules really are.

    Finally, again, I would suggest that someone should take a look at the preceding two centuries of Vermont history to see if this situation has arisen previously and how it was handled. It seems improbable that no similar situation has arisen in all that time.

Comments are closed.