400 Pine Street, Burlington, 863-3968
For as long as I’ve worked at Seven Days, I’ve known the nearby Cheese Outlet/Fresh Market for one thing. It’s the site of the best cookies on Earth. I’m not exaggerating.
Ideally balanced between chewy and crunchy, with nary a hint of cakiness, some bizarre alchemy ensures that the chocolate chips remain slightly melty long after the cookie has cooled. The desserts are also sizable enough that I can usually only eat a third at a time. Unless, that is, I get it right out of the oven. Then the slightly salty cookies simply prove too irresistible not to inhale all at once, my ensuing loginess be damned.
Given my over-the-top devotion, it’s strange that I’d never gotten lunch at the spot that’s just a few minute’s walk from my desk.
The prepared-food case offers a glut of options, but luckily Seven Days calendar editor Carolyn Fox was there to help me choose. We brought a veritable buffet back to the office at a cost of $25 and change.
We started with still-hot macaroni and cheese. A crunchy, light, breadcrumb-covered crust yielded to a creamy, mild cheese sauce speckled with pepper. Even though I tend to prefer sharper cheeses, it was difficult to discern this from the one I make at home. And I didn’t have to cook or clean up!
Though I ordered four maple Buffalo wings, I ended up with five, as one small wing had adhered to a drumette. No complaints. Despite the fact that I ate them cold, the meaty chicken was flavorful. It was even better with the sweet sauce, which burned with just a hint of spice as I swallowed each bite.
The peanut noodles had a similar slow fire that developed with every bite. The savory, creamy noodles were some of the best of their kind I’ve tried in the area.
On the other hand, I haven’t seen anything quite like the refreshing corn salad, brightened with a liberal sprinkling of cilantro. The tomatoes, red peppers and even the corn all tasted surprisingly juicy and fresh for vegetables that aren’t yet in season locally.
Though I’m not usually a fan of mayonnaise-slicked salads, Fresh Market’s tarragon chicken version made me crave Georgian Tarkhun, tarragon soda. Crunchy celery and grapes added a nice textural interplay to the meaty chunks of chicken. That said, I was still wiping off mayo wherever I could.
I even ventured outside my usual box and tried a different dessert. What a brilliant creation the Fresh Market s’more is! Despite a thick, crumbly graham-cracker crust and gooey, broiled, homemade marshmallow crown, the thin layer of chocolate ganache dominates the dessert’s flavor. I’m a convert. Now I know, there’s more to “Freshie” than the best cookie in the world.
Alice Eats is a weekly blog feature devoted to reviewing restaurants where diners can get a meal for two for less than $35. Got a restaurant you’d love to see featured? Send it to alice@sevendaysvt.com.
Got something to say?
Send a letter to the editor and we'll publish your feedback in print!
And, appropriately, today is National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day.
We love Fresh Market but have grown concerned about their dwindling wine and beer selections. Also, for a place that calls itself a “cheese outlet,” there is surprisingly few cheeses available. What’s going on there?
This place has gone downhill.
The Ozzie (Ozzy?) cookies are CRAAAAZY good!