A Thanksgiving leftover sandwich made with Vermont Farmstead Cheese’s cranberry cheddar Credit: Courtesy of Clare Barboza

The day after Thanksgiving is my favorite day of the year. Not because it’s a holiday — the Seven Days office is in full swing — but because it means I get to eat a sandwich full of leftovers.

Call it a Gobbler, a Mayflower, a Turkey Lurkey: The genre of turkey sandwich that comes stuffed with stuffing and slathered in cranberry sauce is great all year. But it’s best, of course, the day after all those ingredients were painstakingly prepared for a celebratory feast. When stored properly (please don’t leave your leftovers out all day), these ingredients combine for a sandwich that’s better than Thanksgiving dinner itself.

I’ve always eaten my leftover sandwich straight from the fridge, sometimes standing in front of it. This year, I’m changing it up: It will be hot, warmed in the oven to melt my new secret ingredient.

I hadn’t thought of putting cheese on the sandwich until I heard from Tess Mix earlier this fall. The marketing director at Vermont Farmstead Cheese and Grafton Village Cheese tipped me off to adding Vermont Farmstead’s cranberry cheddar ($9.95), a cheese that feels designed for exactly this purpose.

“Cranberry cheddar is not a new concept,” Mix said, citing the combo’s New England heritage. But it was among the first flavored cheddars that the South Woodstock biz launched.

In 2009, a group of the town’s residents purchased a struggling water buffalo dairy farm and turned it into the first community-owned dairy and artisan cheesemaker in Vermont. Under the leadership of president and co-owner Kent Underwood, Vermont Farmstead Cheese has found its niche in local cheese counters as the “quirky cousin,” Mix said, especially compared to Grafton Village Cheese, which Vermont Farmstead bought in April 2025. (Mix called that historic brand an “astute gentleman.”)

Kent Underwood of Vermont Farmstead Cheese and Grafton Village Cheese head cheesemaker Mario Gonzalez in 2025 Credit: File photo

“There are so many amazing cheeses in Vermont, and a lot of them have a little bit of status to them,” she continued. “We’ve solidified ourselves into a brand that likes to be fun, likes to be local and likes to not try to be the elite cheese.”

Vermont Farmstead Cheese’s more out-of-the-box flavors include maple Sriracha cheddar, hot honey cheddar, smoked brie and a whole line of brewery collabs that bring us gems such as Cheddy Topper, which uses the Alchemist ’s flagship brew, Heady Topper.

I’ve eaten the cranberry cheddar countless times but always on a cheese board, where its tart whole cranberries convince me to grab more slices than is polite. Its packaging calls the cheese inside a “gentle cheddar,” and I find it packs a slightly sharper punch than some larger-scale products without screaming in your face about that fact that it’s cheddar. The 7-ounce square blocks have never lasted long in my house.

Following Mix’s advice, I’ve got an extra stashed away for Friday, November 27. I’ll grab a nice loaf of local sourdough, stack all the cold leftovers on a slice, put the cranberry cheddar on top and stick the whole thing in the oven to warm it up.

The melted cheese solves the dry-sandwich issue that the sitcom “Friends” tackled with the “Moist Maker” — an extra gravy-soaked slice of bread in the middle of Ross Geller’s prized once-a-year sandwich — without needing so much cranberry sauce that it gets soggy. The cheddar helps the various flavors meld, and the cranberries give a bonus pop with every bite. I’ll never eat it cold and cheeseless again.

Thanksgiving can be a lot, Mix said. “Family politics, national politics — it’s all happening. On Friday, the drama is gone, and you still have half a turkey.”

A cranberry cheddar leftover sandwich is the postholiday relief we all need. If anybody dares try to steal mine, you’ll hear me screaming “MY SANDWICH,” just like Ross. ➆

“Small Pleasures” is an occasional column that features delicious and distinctive Vermont-made food or drinks that pack a punch. Send us your favorite little bites or sips with big payoff at food@sevendaysvt.com.

The original print version of this article was headlined “Gobble It Up | Vermont Farmstead Cheese’s cranberry cheddar improves the Thanksgiving leftover sandwich”

Jordan Barry is a food writer at Seven Days. Her stories about tipping culture, cooperatively-owned natural wineries, bar pizza and gay chicken have earned recognition from the Association of Alternative Newsmedia's AAN Awards and the New England Newspaper & Press Association. She holds a master’s degree in food studies from New York University, where her research focused on building a lexicon for the American craft cider industry. She also has an animal science degree from the University of...