
(Self-released, cassette, CD, digital)
The Discussions have been honing their brand of lush psychedelia since their 2021 debut, Live at Future Fields. This is a collective built around the compositions of multi-instrumentalist Greg Rothwell, perhaps best known to Burlingtonians as the guy who helped make Foam Brewers into a live-music hot spot. It turns out his ear for talent is quite educated, indeed.
While the band’s early work was interesting but inconsistent, its latest LP, No Shrines, No Concrete, is a knockout journey through jazzy post-rock soundscapes. The evolution is remarkable. The Discussions have always been a crew with serious chops, but that fire has never been so carefully controlled. These songs are genre-fluid, yet I would be hard-pressed to call any of this “experimental” — it’s far too refined.
Consider album opener “(Moving) Vision,” which launches from a cinematic swell into some lovely chord melodies with heavy horn support. Eli Goldman’s bass dances in perfect tandem with Derek Rice’s keys as the brass section carries that motif up into the stratosphere. On a dime, the ensemble whips a hard left to a Latin-flavored funk riff that keeps ramping up into classic ’70s prog-rock excess. Just when things start getting distinctly Mars Volta, the band reprises the original melody into a perfect, sliding stop.
Notably, these shifts all transpire in less than five minutes. That kind of time compression defines the entire album: Even the shortest songs seem far longer because there is so much shimmering detail to get immersed in. Rothwell’s compositions make the most of his collaborators’ musical and dynamic range.
Bands that can go anywhere and do anything often get lost in their own musical erudition, but crucially, everything on No Shrines, No Concrete fits. Even the sharpest contrasts sound natural, like the way that the screaming guitar solos and Gogol Bordello stomp of “Because the Battle Begun” washes out into the easygoing Tropicália of “Red Pearl.” Closing track “Meet Me at Midnight” somehow manages to encompass everything on the menu into a single parting shot.
All involved here shine, but upon repeated listens the drum work of Colin Henkel (Mal Maïz) just might make him the MVP. These are all demanding songs in very different ways, and his fluid swing carries every track. Another clutch player who must be mentioned is Dan Rome. In addition to handling saxophone duty with his usual lyrical touch, he also mixed and mastered the album at Big Lake Recording.
In small scenes, we tend to over-celebrate the human hubs who catalyze culture. It’s too easy to write about the magic that is Burlington’s incestuous tangle of creative talents. But in this case, No Shrines, No Concrete really is a stone-cold magnum opus. Fans of Jeff Parker and Makaya McCraven are particularly encouraged to check this out. The Discussions might be hard to define, but they are mighty easy to enjoy.
No Shrines, No Concrete is available at thediscussions.bandcamp.com.
This article appears in November 18 • 2026.

