Sam Rockwell and John Malkovich are CIA agents on an unusual vacay in Martin McDonagh’s dark comedy Credit: Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Rare is the character actor who has so much character that you can build a movie on the premise of people wanting to be him. That actor would be, of course, John Malkovich, as seen in Spike Jonze’s 1999 Being John Malkovich. Despite a career of indelible stage and screen roles, from Valmont in Dangerous Liaisons to Patricia Highsmith’s Tom Ripley, the 72-year-old actor has yet to win an Oscar. But that might change with his starring turn in the latest from writer-director Martin McDonagh (The Banshees of Inisherin, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri). As of press time, find Wild Horse Nine at Essex Cinemas, the Majestic 10 in Williston or the Savoy Theater in Montpelier.

The deal

We’re in 1973 Chile, shortly before a military coup will depose socialist president Salvador Allende. CIA agents Chris Carlisle (Malkovich) and Lee Chesterfield (Sam Rockwell) have been pulling the strings in that ideological conflict. But right now they have more pressing concerns, such as vacationing on Easter Island to see the “big heads” — as Chris puts it, pointedly ignoring everyone who suggests he use more culturally sensitive terminology.

A veteran of the Bay of Pigs and many other operations — including, he hints, John F. Kennedy’s assassination — Chris has been threatening to write his memoirs. He’s past the age of giving any fucks, to the despair of CIA bureau chief MJ (Steve Buscemi). At the airport, Chris spots two pretty left-wing students (Mariana di Girolamo and Ailín Salas) and, as an opening line, cheekily informs them that he and Lee are covert operatives destabilizing their government. Lee does his best to keep his loose-cannon buddy in line, but he has his own problems with a wandering wife (Parker Posey) about whom Chris taunts him mercilessly.

Then there’s the small matter of the promises Lee made to both Chris and MJ about what will happen on this trip — promises that involve a loaded gun.

Will you like it?

Do not go to Wild Horse Nine anticipating an old-person spy caper. Despite a couple of brief action scenes, this is primarily a movie for people who want to see Malkovich play one of McDonagh’s trademark witty, amoral characters. Like all the director’s work, it’s heavily dialogue-driven, but with less plot and a more relaxed vibe than McDonagh’s previous award contenders. If hanging out with Malkovich, Rockwell, Buscemi and some of the titular wild horses appeals to you, you won’t mind that the movie consists largely of seemingly aimless conversations.

Seemingly, because no conversation in a McDonagh script is truly aimless — every topic comes back around later, sometimes with stinging impact. What begins as an amiable comedy in which Chris and Lee muse on apparent randomness (the ethics of killing moths, whether dinosaurs go to heaven) soon evolves into something darker and more pointed. Allende’s is just one of many democratically elected governments that Chris has helped topple in the name of the American way. While McDonagh initially treats his protagonist’s ethical bankruptcy as a joke, even Chris’ cynicism has limits, and the film explores them.

Malkovich is the ideal choice to play a deeply unserious man realizing this could be his last chance to take a stand. As always, he beguiles the audience with his knack for couching outrageous, confrontational statements in offhand mumbles. Like di Girolamo’s student character, we lean in almost against our will, feeling privileged to be Chris’ confidant even when he’s clearly just provoking us for fun.

Lee has his own soft spot for Chris, ribbing and bickering with him but always supporting him when it counts. While Rockwell’s character is never particularly fleshed out, he brings all his oddball likability to bear on it, giving the two agents’ interactions a crackling chemistry. The screenplay doesn’t bother to tell us what good friends they are, nor does it need to: We see their rapport and loyalty on-screen.

We also see the stark splendors of Easter Island, shot on location by director of photography Ben Davis in saturated hues like an updated version of the Super 8 footage Lee takes of Chris. For all Chris’ irreverence about the spiritual meaning of the Rapa Nui people’s giant statues, the island clearly works on him in mysterious ways, nudging the story toward a deeply moving conclusion.

Wild Horse Nine could be tighter, and some of McDonagh’s humor feels tired. For some viewers, the movie will simply be too slow, while others may be reluctant to extend empathy to a protagonist who’s spent much of his life enabling fascists. But if you can get on the film’s warped wavelength, you may find yourself blinking a little too often as Chris’ jokes give way to devastating frankness about good and evil, life and death. This is an elegiac tearjerker for people who think they’re too cool for that.

If you like this, try…

The Resurrection of Victor Jara (2015; rentable at filmsforaction.org): A pivotal scene in Wild Horse Nine features Chilean folk singer Jara (Aron Hernández), who was killed during the 1973 coup. Burlington’s own John Summa wrote and produced this acclaimed documentary about his legacy.

El Conde (2023; Netflix): Chilean filmmaker Pablo Larraín, one of the executive producers of Wild Horse Nine, made this lush, surreal dark comedy that reimagines Augusto Pinochet, the military dictator who replaced Allende, as a vampire.

In Bruges (2008; rentable): In McDonagh’s filmography, Wild Horse Nine is most akin to this twisted hangout comedy in which Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson play hit men hiding out and gabbing in Belgium.

The original print version of this article was headlined “Wild Horse Nine”

Margot Harrison is a consulting editor and film critic at Seven Days. Her film reviews appear every week in the paper and online. In 2024, she won the Jim Ridley Award for arts criticism from the Association of Alternative Newsmedia. Her book reviews have also appeared in the New York Times. She is a member of the Online Film Critics Society, with reviews on the Tomatometer, and the author of five novels, including YA thrillers Only She Came Back and We Made It All Up.