On Thursday, February 18, Seven Days is teaming up with Channel 17/Town Meeting Television to host a public debate about Instant Runoff Voting. On Town Meeting Day, Burlington voters will have the opportunity to weigh in on whether the city should continue to use IRV to elect the mayor.
The debate will be between two IRV supporters, Rep. Mark Larson and Keri Toksu of the League of Women Voters, and two IRV opponents, Burlington lawyer Sandy Baird and Chuck Selene of One Person One Vote.
A media panel, including Shay Totten of Seven Days, Bianca Slota of WCAX and John Briggs of the Burlington Free Press, will ask questions. Jess Wilson of Channel 17 will moderate. The audience will also have an opportunity to ask questions. There will be a mike for audience members, and we’ll be taking questions via a live chat on this blog.
The fun starts on Thursday, February 18, at 7 p.m. Come to Burlington City Hall Auditorium, or watch the debate live on Burlington Telecom and Comcast channel 17, or on the Seven Days website. Want to tweet about it? We’re using the hashtag #btvirv.
This article appears in Feb 10-16, 2010.


Alex, there are no safe assumptions and one never knows what might have been; Well played in pointing out condorcet’s absence from the ballot. I certainly asked for that; and we’ll see if somone else has an answer to the transport security question. Cheers.
Haik, the point about the City Councilor election is that IRV would have saved the cost of a special runoff. Assuming that the last two mayoral elections would have gone to special runoffs based on the IRV results seems fairly safe, and hiding behind “that’s speculation, not fact” is blowing smoke. I would personally prefer condorcet tabulation, but that’s not on the ballot. :pI really don’t know enough about the security issues for transporting the ballots to comment, but that’s a good question.
The question of using IRV for city council races is not on the ballot this election. The question of whether to repeal the use of IRV in mayoral elections is.We do not know if there would have been a runoff in either the 2006 or 2009 races had we not employed IRV. All we know is that there had never been one previously. I guess one might say IRV saved us from runoffs in the last two, but that is speculation, not fact, and one ought to know the difference.I will say I find it ticklishly ironic- both that in 2006 Bob would have missed the old 40% cut-off by a scant 1%, but nobody made much of it since he was the plurality and condorcet winner anyway, and that in 2009 he was neither but still won.The truth is that in a frictionless universe that worked the way it should in theory- that guy Robert Bristow is right. The IRV supporters shouldn’t really be supporting IRV- they should be supporting the idea of using the condorcet tabulation method instead because that is even more small-d-democratic than IRV. I imagine their arguments against that, if any would face the question squarely, would look and sound somewhat similar to the agruments being made in favor of the old plurality system now. Namely, it’s simpler, easier to understand for more people and thus increases participation, and the overall perception that the winner is legitimate.But regardless I haven’t heard anyone address my main concern with IRV, and I’ll repeat it- IRV necessitates the transportation of ballots to city hall for tabulation. This adds opportunities for fraud as computer chips and or ballots might, theoretically, be switched during transport.Anyone want to try knocking that down, and explain why that shouldn’t be a concern?
Haik, we had a special runoff for Ward 7 city councilor. If we elected councilors via IRV, the costs of that special election would have been avoided.Also, while opponents of IRV have claimed that there has never been a runoff election for Mayor, this is disingenous at best and disinformation at worst — we have had runoffs in the past two mayoral elections, but were spared the expense of a separate city-wide mayoral runoff date because we had IRV.
Alex, how is something that’s never happened before a “very real problem?”
re: the idea that IRV gives a person more than “one vote”Last March, Ward 7 voters did not elect a winner between Vincent Dober, Ellie Blais, and Eli Lesser-Goldsmith on March 3 and a runoff was held at a later date between Dober and Lesser-Goldsmith. Believing that IRV gives a person more than one vote is equivalent to believing that people who voted for Blais on March 3 should not have been allowed to participate in the runoff election on the later date.IRV fixes the very real problem that an extra election date costs money; not just the direct costs of holding the extra election, but the wasted time of the approximately 1000 voters who voted on the morning of the runoff date.
Robert just made the greatest argument against IRV ever. KISS — Keep It Simple, Smarty. One person, one vote. The person with the most votes, wins. It’s worked for a long time. Our voting laws weren’t broken before IRV came along. There was no reason to try to ‘fix’ them.
IRV necessitates the transportation of ballots to city hall for tabulation. This adds opportunities for fraud as computer chips and or ballots might, theoretically, be switched during transport.
If the old law was in effect, the 2009 election would have gone to runoff with Kurt Wright vs. Bob Kiss. if the turnout on Runoff Day was comparable to that of Election Day, then the result would be no different than it was with IRV. but if, because of reduced voter turnout, Kurt Wright squeeked out a “victory” against the explicit wishes of the majority of Burlington voters, that would be a problem.the mayoral election in Burlington in 2009 *did* suffer several anomalies or pathologies due to the way that IRV tabulates the vote and decides the winner. it *did* screw up, but the screwup was not that Kurt Wright wasn’t elected. the screw up was that the pairwise majority-preferred candidate (the candidate who beats any other candidate when paired against them), Andy Montroll, was not elected. the screwup was that the presence of a candidate who finally did not win himself actually changed who the winner was (a spoiler-lite). the screwup is that the GOP Prog-haters had actually caused the election of the candidate they liked least, simply for voting for the candidate they liked the most.those are screwups, but it would be worse with the old plurality-rule method.and, the historical fact is that at the time, people *did* question the legitimacy of Lincoln’s election and his right to govern. same with Clinton, same with W, and even with Obama with his 53% mandate.
IRV just feels like a solution without a problem. Abe Lincoln won the presidency with 40% of the vote. Bill Clinton with 43%. Woodrow Wilson with 42%. Nobody questioned their legitimacy, their power or their right to govern. Heck, Bernie Sanders himself didn’t get 50% of the vote when he won his first election for mayor of Burlap. Today, few supporters of IRV would find fault with the outcome of that election. If we had IRV in 1981, it’s quite possible that Sander’s political career would never have gotten off of the ground. Our democracy is functioning well without IRV. Let’s reject it now so that we can focus on more pressing issues.