On Thursday, February 18, Seven Days is teaming up with Channel 17/Town Meeting Television to host a public debate about Instant Runoff Voting. On Town Meeting Day, Burlington voters will have the opportunity to weigh in on whether the city should continue to use IRV to elect the mayor.
The debate will be between two IRV supporters, Rep. Mark Larson and Keri Toksu of the League of Women Voters, and two IRV opponents, Burlington lawyer Sandy Baird and Chuck Selene of One Person One Vote.
A media panel, including Shay Totten of Seven Days, Bianca Slota of WCAX and John Briggs of the Burlington Free Press, will ask questions. Jess Wilson of Channel 17 will moderate. The audience will also have an opportunity to ask questions. There will be a mike for audience members, and we’ll be taking questions via a live chat on this blog.
The fun starts on Thursday, February 18, at 7 p.m. Come to Burlington City Hall Auditorium, or watch the debate live on Burlington Telecom and Comcast channel 17, or on the Seven Days website. Want to tweet about it? We’re using the hashtag #btvirv.
This article appears in Feb 10-16, 2010.


Repeal IRV.Its easier to vote for someone rather than some ones.If we don’t get to a majority vote,lets have a real runoff where the voters focus on the top two choices. IRV is for theorists. When we reach utopia, I will vote for IRV – I promise.
MisterGuy: Prog troll.
Whatever. No system is perfect, but it’s still easier to swap out a memory card if the card has to travel. When the ballots are counted on the spot at each of the polling places, all eyes are on them and there’s less time between the polls closing and the counting. IRV adds more opportunities for cheating, there isn’t a doubt in my mind.
Quote Haik: That’s wrong of course, because the same effort cheat would have to be made seven times over to occur at each of the polling places, and there would be many more eyes on the process at a polling place than there would be in a car between the polling place and city hall. You’re wrong.Why would you need to affect results in all wards? One ward could be enough to swing it if you’re talking about going back to a simple 40% majority. Yes, the more wards you compromise the easier it would be to hide the tampering, but seriously.. as MisterGuy said, the election fraud arguement is specious at best. No real advantage in either system.If you want to go back to a winner takes all, make it a >50%. At least then you know half of the citizens like the results. Of course, requiring a >50% tally would mean virtually every mayoral election moving forward would end in a runoff which would get pretty darn expensive… which is why IRV makes so much sense in the first place.
If you think IRV is "complex" (it really isn't BTW…it's just ranking candidates yanno), then you'll just *love* "the condorcet tabulation method"…it's waaaay more complex than IRV.
Talk about a solution without a problem:
"IRV necessitates the transportation of ballots to city hall for tabulation. This adds opportunities for fraud as computer chips and or ballots might, theoretically, be switched during transport."
When has there ever been voter fraud with IRV?? Hint: Your "theoretical" concerns are based on blind fear-mongering, period. But, of course, you'll keep repeating them like they are "real" concerns anyways…ugh… BTW, aren't all the ballots transported to City Hall under guard?
"the mayoral election in Burlington in 2009 *did* suffer several anomalies or pathologies"
No, it really didn't.
"the screw up was that the pairwise majority-preferred candidate (the candidate who beats any other candidate when paired against them), Andy Montroll, was not elected"
…because the actual election in question was a five-person race, not a series of imaginary two-person races that might have existed in some alternative universe.
"the screwup was that the presence of a candidate who finally did not win himself actually changed who the winner was (a spoiler-lite)."
It's kind of hard to call the guy that came in *second* a "spoiler". Again, alternate universes where down is up & Bizaro Superman is Superman don't count.
Any sort of attack that could be acomplished by sending the results to city hall could be just as easily done by corrupt elections workers at a polling location under the old system.That’s wrong of course, because the same effort cheat would have to be made seven times over to occur at each of the polling places, and there would be many more eyes on the process at a polling place than there would be in a car between the polling place and city hall. You’re wrong.
Any sort of attack that could be acomplished by sending the results to city hall could be just as easily done by corrupt elections workers at a polling location under the old system. If you’re going to attack a sysstem for its requirement that the data needs to make it back to a centrail point, don’t ignore the fact that no system is 100% secure. Heck, if you have access to the hardware and time to study it, you could probably develop a phsical hack that ignores every second or third scan and replaces it with results that you want on those scantron machines. Election fraud happens in a lot of places that don’t have IRV.The real issue is that the public needs to be educated about the system, the candidates, and the issues before voting. If you’re just a straight partyline voter, IRV definitely is not for you. Those people who educate themselves on the issues and the candidates have more power under IRV through second and third choices. I hope one thing everyone can agree on is that strong civics education is essential for a strong democracy.
It doesn’t take Blackwater or Dr. Evil to swap out a computer chip, neil. And even though I’d like to see IRV repealed, Bob Kiss was my first choice vote in the last two elections, so your stereotype fails just like all stereotypes. You will bring Captain Solo and the Wookie to me and you will vote yes on question 5.
So lets see if we can summarize:Against IRV – People are stupid and confused by ranking a first, second, third, etc choice. They’re obviously stupid because they didn’t vote for my candidate. – Blackwater (aka Xe), Mossad, Dr. Evil, or possibly the A-Team might interrupt the vehicles carrying the ballots to City Hall for Tabulation and rig an election. – Encourages Multi-party Democracy (who wants to be like Europe or Canada anyway?!?!)For IRV – Could save money under some circumstances – Would require a charter change to undo. Who wants to spend energy doing that? – Encourages Multi-party democracyI’m not trying to make fun of anyone in particular here, just pointing out that the arguments for are negligible and the arguments against seem to involve a lack of willingness to educate the public on civics and a rather unhealthy fear of black helicopters.
“Haik, the point about the City Councilor election is that IRV would have saved the cost of a special runoff.”There are far greater concerns in a democracy than the cost of an election.Funny, Progs are only concerned about public expenditures when it comes to Burlington elections. On every other issue, they can’t spend enough of other people’s money. Funny.