The mood among F-35 opponents gathered in an Old North End conference room Tuesday evening contrasted starkly with the triumphalist atmosphere inside a Vermont Air Guard hangar earlier in the day.

About a dozen members of the Stop the F-35 Coalition sat glumly around a table a few hours after the state’s political leaders and hundreds of uniformed Air Guard members cheered the decision to base 18 of the stealth fighter-bombers in Vermont beginning in 2020.

The activists who have fought the local basing option for more than four years were reluctant to discuss their next steps with a reporter. However, they agreed to offer responses to Tuesday’s announcement prior to conducting a private strategy discussion.

Kevin J. Kelley is a contributing writer for Seven Days, Vermont Business Magazine and the daily Nation of Kenya.

15 replies on “‘It’s Not Over,’ F-35 Foes Insist as They Carry Fight to the Courts”

  1. No – I’m saying neither the Guard spokesperson nor the EIS have the authority to give a proper indication or guarantee on actual afterburner use. That order would be contained in the mission directives (combat or training) which would be handed down from an Air Force Commander(s).
    However, based on a statement from an Air Force Commander, it was estimated to be 90-95% afterburner use. So when you factor in that external fuel tanks are planned (http://pdf.aiaa.org/preview/CD…, the minimum length runway requirement, the statement(s) and current use – the probability for afterburner use is extremely high.

  2. But just so we are clear, you believe the Air Force regarding the EIS but not when they say they won’t be using afterburners during take off…

  3. The mission and physics, not the Guard spokesman, dictates the use of afterburners. As for sound volume, according to the EIS and sound recordings on the ground, the sound recorded (not modeled as in the EIS) by the F-35 is 115 dB non afterburner/131 dB afterburner. The sound recorded (again not modeled) by an F-16 is 94 dB non-afterburner/104 dB afterburner. These recordings may be slightly different here as they were not recorded at BIA. An increase of 10 dB means a doubling of sound – therefore the F-35 is at least 2 times, but as much as 6 times louder than an F-16 in real world conditions. In current use, the F-35’s are using afterburner 90% to 95% of the time (according to Air Force reports). Interestingly, Burlington International Airport meets the 8,000 foot minimum length requirements by a short margin – 320 feet – which increases the likelihood of afterburner use. Also – similar to the F-16 – external fuel tanks are being developed for the F-35. External fuel tanks would insure afterburner use.

  4. “I don’t believe the Guard is lying to us,”
    So when they say they won’t need to use the afterburners on take off which will actually mean less noise then the F-16’s which currently need the afterburners on take off you believe them and you are just using the noise level as a hypothetical?

  5. The EIS is done because of laws that were enacted, beginning in 1978, that set standards for acceptable noise levels across the United States. The program that manages the Environmental Impact Statement program it is called the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) http://www.epa.gov/compliance/…
    I don’t believe the Guard is lying to us, I believe the F-35, through the EIS and real world testing, has proven itself a poor fit for the Burlington International Airport.
    An increase in the Cyber Security and Communications Missions that the VTANG is already engaged in (spread between Northfield and South Burlington) would be a much better fit. I would also be open to drones and other jets similar to a noise profile the F-16 makes (like the Scorpion under development) be stationed here.

Comments are closed.