Adolphe Lumumba testifying before the House Judiciary Committee on Wednesday Credit: Paul Heintz

Anako Lumumba tried to protect herself from an abusive ex, her brother told Vermont lawmakers on Wednesday. “But the system wasn’t enough to take the guns away from the guy,” Adolphe Lumumba said.

In May 2018, police have alleged, Leroy Headley shot Anako to death in the South Burlington home they once shared. She had repeatedly reported his threatening behavior to police — twice in the week before she was killed — but Headley still had legal access to firearms.

Reps. Maxine Grad (D-Moretown) and Martin LaLonde (D-South Burlington) are seeking to prevent such tragedies. The chair and ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee have introduced legislation that would require subjects of a restraining order to surrender their firearms. Their bill, H.610, would also expand the state’s new “red flag law” to allow family and household members — not just law enforcement officials — to seek extreme risk protection orders, which allow for the temporary confiscation of firearms from those deemed dangerous.

Adolphe Lumumba told their committee that the bill might have helped Anako.

“I’m not here today to save my sister, but I know there’s other people out there who can be saved by this,” he said. “This is something my sister would have wanted, too.”

The measure is one of several firearms-related bills lawmakers are considering this session.

Sen. Phil Baruth (D/P-Chittenden) has introduced legislation that would prohibit the possession of semiautomatic weapons in certain public spaces, such as government buildings, churches, hospitals, parks, restaurants, concert venues and colleges. The bill, S.259, is sponsored by 14 of the Senate’s 30 members, suggesting it may have majority support.

“We should have some commonsense limitations on where you can carry guns specifically designed to kill large numbers of people,” Baruth said. “That is, you can’t carry them into places where there are large numbers of people.”

The Democratic legislature is also trying to determine what to do about Republican Gov. Phil Scott’s veto last session of a bill requiring a 24-hour waiting period before the purchase of a handgun. Legislators could attempt to override Scott’s veto, but that would require a two-thirds majority in both chambers. While 20 senators backed the measure, S.169, last session, only 82 of 150 members of the House did.

“I’m not sure we have the votes to override,” Grad conceded.

Sen. Dick Sears (D-Bennington), who chairs the Senate Judiciary Committee, said he’s hoping to allay Scott’s concern that there is insufficient evidence to show that a 24-hour waiting period would reduce the state’s suicide and homicide rates. To that end, Senate leaders have invited two prominent Harvard Business School professors who have researched the question to testify next week.

“I think what we should do is work with the administration and find a path,” Sears said. “And I’m willing to do that.”

If that fails, Baruth plans to push for a waiting period of 48 hours, arguing that the research is even stronger that longer waiting periods are effective. “In that sense, we are taking him at his word,” Baruth said of the governor.

During a break from testimony in her committee Wednesday, Grad said she planned to focus on advancing her own bill, H.610.

“Domestic violence-related homicides are preventable,” she said. “This would give survivors of domestic violence, law enforcement, the court, family, community members the tools that they don’t have now to reduce access to firearms.”

In addition to the restraining order and extreme risk protection order provisions, Grad and LaLonde’s bill would close what’s known as the “Charleston loophole.” Under federal law, if a criminal background check is not completed within three days, a gun dealer may proceed with a sale. That allowed the perpetrator of a 2015 church shooting in Charleston, S.C., to purchase a gun even though he should not have been permitted to do so.

Last year’s vetoed waiting-period bill also sought to close the so-called loophole by prohibiting gun sales without a completed background check. Grad said she included the same provision in her new bill because she believes it would also save lives. “For me, this is a domestic violence, homicide prevention bill,” she said. “So they’re all related.”

During Wednesday’s hearing, several witnesses raised objections to the legislation.

South Burlington Police Chief Shawn Burke said his own department could handle the increased workload that would come with the mandatory seizure of guns from those served with restraining orders. “But that’s not the case around the state,” he said. “Operationally, this would be a huge lift for law enforcement in the state.”

Chief Superior Judge Brian Grearson similarly warned that requests for warrants and extreme risk protection orders could strain the courts — particularly after hours, when such requests are handled by lower-level personnel.

Ed Cutler testifies before the House Judiciary Committee on Wednesday Credit: Paul Heintz

Gun-rights advocates, meanwhile, said the legislation would restrict their rights and make them less safe. Ed Cutler, president of Gun Owners of Vermont, said that closing the Charleston loophole could make it difficult to quickly obtain a firearm in order to ward off members of the animal kingdom.

“In Vermont, the crime rate is extremely low. The murder rate is almost nonexistent,” he said. “But we have wild animals. We had a bunch of years ago a big rabies epidemic.”

Cutler argued that the state’s new composting rules might compound the threat.

“Bears in the spring are really hungry, and bears with cubs are very protective,” he said. “You go out to that compost pile with a bear problem and you don’t have a firearm, you need to get one just to defend yourself. If you can’t [pass a background check in] three days, you can’t defend yourself against that bear.”

Paul Heintz was part of the Seven Days news team from 2012 to 2020. He served as political editor and wrote the "Fair Game" political column before becoming a staff writer.

24 replies on “Legislators Set Their Sights on New Gun Restrictions”

  1. Gun laws promoted by the most ignorant lawmakers on the subject of firearms. Yes, I’m talking about Baruth and LaLonde. Will you be able to have a hunting rifle in your car to mail a letter at the PO, or to pick your kid at school, or to even drive by the school, or the church, or to park at the local eatery? Loaded rifles are illegal to carry in a car, last I knew.
    Now, the Baruth and LaLonde gang still think a semi-automatic firearm is akin to a nuclear weapon. This alone should give you a hint at their wisdom. Banning high volume magazines without serial numbers proves their ignorance.
    Well officer, I bought this before the ban. Oh, OK be on your way.

  2. I’m really tired of hearing how wonderful Vermont’s homicide rates are compared to other states. Compared to more than 50 other countries in the world, Vermont’s rates are appalling.

    Please go to //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_firearm-related_death_rate and arrange the columns from lowest to highest rate. You’ll find that Vermont’s rate (1.6) (//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States_by_state) would put us in a tie for 60th place, after, to cite just a few examples Japan, Austria, Norway, Palestine (!), Netherlands, Ireland, Spain, China, Poland, Czech Republic and Italy, all of which have murder rates that are less than 1/2 of Vermont’s.

    The real question is whether the unwanted side-effects of passing this law are worse than the hoped-for savings of life.

  3. Vermont gun control? Are the democrats crazy? Vermont is the envy of every other state. Only a nut would limit ownership in Vermont. Clearly, democrats don’t have a clue.

  4. Well, I’m sure glad there are some experts on here to tell us how it is. Why don’t they run for office?

  5. The fact that the lawmakers are taking testimony from two Harvard Law Professors who have studied this issue is all I needed to hear. Regardless of what it’s about studies are always flawed or manipulated. Look no further than the FDA one week a new drug is the cure all the next year every lawyer in the country is part of a lawsuit settlement.

    I suggest people just start using their common sense.

  6. These representatives ARE representing their constituents, just because you don’t agree with them doesn’t mean that they are misrepresenting those who voted for them. If you don’t like it then get involved and get someone elected who you think will do a better job. And before you attack me,know that I am a 3rd generation native Vermonter and gun owner.

  7. “I would much prefer they spend some time re-working the onerous property taxes, the excessive spending, the incredibly expensive school system, and finding a way other than paying people to move here to attract jobs and employers. How about spending some time on those (actual) problems?”

    Lower property taxes = give people more money to make Vermont more attractive
    Lower excessive spending = give people more money to make Vermont more attractive
    Make education cheaper = give people more money to make Vermont more attractive
    Don’t pay people to come here = don’t give people more money to make Vermont more attractive

    Super consistent.

  8. These twits that have the nerve to take tax dollars as compensation for being “representatives” of the people need to familiarize themselves with “disparity of force”. For those unfamiliar, it’s the deadly force that no amount of legislation can take away. Taking this thugs gun would not have prevented him from harming or killing this victim. But waiting periods or other restrictions WOULD prevent a would-be victim from obtaining the means to defend themselves (from someone capable of harming or killing them with their bare hands). This legislation is evil, as are it’s proponents. And counterproductive to the goal.

  9. I would much prefer they spend some time re-working the onerous property taxes, the excessive spending, the incredibly expensive school system, and finding a way other than paying people to move here to attract jobs and employers. How about spending some time on those (actual) problems?

    We just got nailed with a 12% health insurance increase (if I have my facts straight) right after giving OneCare, an “Accountable Cost Organization” over a BILLION DOLLARS ($1,000,000,000.00) with basically no accounting for how they’re going to spend the 60% increase over 2019. How about spending some time on that (actual) problem?

    We have a prison system that appears to be so poorly run that people are being released early, and top officials are being shown the door. How about spending some time on that (actual) problem?

    We have some real, terrifically difficult problems that threaten the entire state. But yes, please fritter away your time trying to subvert the Constitutions of both the United States and Vermont to get your names in the paper. Then, the gun-rights organizations will challenge the laws in court (which will cost the state money), and as often happens, your new laws are nullified. But hey, you got your names in the press. Yay you.

    And you want to vote yourselves a pay raise?

  10. Good job Seven Days on once again completely failing to represent the conservative viewpoint.

    If a gun sale cannot proceed without the successful completion of a background check, than politicians merely have to cut funding for them. This would make any and all gun sales illegal, effectively providing politicians with a back door route to commit massive violations of our civil rights without any kind of oversight.

    The compromise was that background checks would be required, but if the government failed to complete one in a timely fashion the sale would proceed as planned. This stems from the American notion of innocent until proven guilty; the burden of proof lies with the government to prove that someone is high-risk.

    But at least you threw in a pity quote at the end of this article about how we need to protect ourselves from bears. Shame on Paul Heintz for failing to demonstrate any kind of journalistic integrity, and shame on Seven Days for providing him a platform to do so.

Comments are closed.