Burlingtonians opposed to the redesign of City Hall Park spoke out Wednesday night in defense of the trees.
About 50 members of the Keep the Park Green group turned out to a Development Review Board hearing at Burlington City Hall to argue in favor of keeping trees slated for removal as part of renovation plans for the park.
“The trees are the vibrancy of the park as we, the people, are the vibrancy of the city,” said Charlie Messing, a member of the group.
The city is slated to install a new fountain and walkways as part of the redesign. Under the current plans, the city would remove 34 of the park’s 56 trees. Sixteen new trees would be planted for a net total of 38 trees.
Wednesday marked the second DRB public hearing on the issue. After dozens of project opponents testified against the project at a February 20 meeting, the board scheduled another hearing to give the applicants an opportunity to respond and to allow more time for public input.
In the days following the meeting, some members of Keep the Park Green tied colorful ribbons around the trees and erected signs that read: “Epic Fail” and “I needed care, but didn’t get any.”
City arborist V.J. Comai offered a public tour of the park last week and found two trees that could be saved, and space for two more to be planted. “We did listen to the community on that one,” noted Cindi Wight, director of Burlington Parks, Recreation & Waterfront.
Comai on Wednesday noted that the trees slated for removal are in poor health, pose a safety risk, or don’t fit with the new design.
Approval from the DRB would be yet another step in a multiyear process to renovate the park. The board will likely give the final OK in the next week, said Scott Gustin, head of the city’s planning and zoning department. Construction is scheduled to start in 2019.
Opponents argued that taking down the trees exacerbates climate change.
“We’re in the midst of a global climate catastrophe, and if what’s being done will be making that more of a problem, that should be reconsidered,” said Jack Daggitt. He urged the city to create more park space using vacant lots.
Donna Walters, of Keep the Park Green, asked whether some of the trees could be relocated. “We don’t think healthy trees should be cut down,” she said.*
Gustin noted that the future of the trees doesn’t fall under the purview of the DRB, which decides whether the project meets the city’s zoning ordinance and whether the park provides a public benefit. So far, Gustin said, “it sure seems like it complies with the zoning code.”
Correction, March 8, 2018: A previous version of this story misquoted Donna Walters.




Everyone who has commented should go walk in the park to really understand just how many trees are slated to be cut. The homeless are my friends. Ive been homeless. They need Love, food, shelter, job training. Ask them about whats going on in the park. Theyll tell you. They are our friends. They sit on two benches and will move out of the way if you ask. Theyve been collecting the trash people dump in the park every day. Why dont we find more places to open their doors to them and help them. Then they can sit Inside. Right now there is no place for them to go. May all of you experience homeless. Maybe you will be better citizens then.
Only one million has been donated for fixing up the park. Lets spend this wisely. Upgrade as needed. Use our aeration system and nutrition system to help the trees. Cutting them down is expensive. Keeping them is not. Our new arborist only said 7 trees need to be cut down and maybe 3 more. The designers are not listening to him. Or to the historical park design. Obviously there are trees that can be removed from this list they have made to cut down. 15 trees are merely IN The Way of the design. They are not sick. The designers have done several designs already. They are talented can can do another design that follows the arborist suggestion of what needs to be removed and leave the rest of the trees.
This new plan also covers ONE THIRD of the park with hard sharp surfaces. Simply reduce this to 25% or less and move it around and you can save all the trees on the arborist list to not cut down.
After seeing how much of the lovely, live buffer areas next to the bike path out in the NNE have been clearcut–trees, shrubs, tall grasses for example–what’s a few more trees? It seems this administration is hell-bent on destroying Burlington. It would not suprise me at all to hear soon about the urgent necessity for another “investment” in Burlington to reduce the carbon footprint to stave off the dire consequences of climate change. The hypocrisy of this administration is mind-boggling.
“City Hall Park is currently a nasty, unattractive place that is oftentimes little more than an outdoor homeless shelter, populated by people who won’t even make room for pedestrians to pass on the walkways. Fix the park.”
The writer of this comment is making the assumption that the new plan will fix the behaviors he deplores.. The city has, among other tweaks, taken out a goodly number of the benches, put metal dividers on the benches that remain, and taken out the chess tables to discourage drug abusers and the homeless. Now they want to put unprofessional commercial eyes in the Park to monitor behaviors, and keep Farmer’s Market in the Park with some modest adjustments. What could possibly go wrong? Keep the Park Green wants to upgrade the Park in keeping with the historic neighborhood in which it is located, AND put professionals in the Park to monitor those who would be disruptive.
City Hall Park is currently a nasty, unattractive place that is oftentimes little more than an outdoor homeless shelter, populated by people who won’t even make room for pedestrians to pass on the walkways. Fix the park. To the people who go apoplectic any time anyone wants to change anything, anywhere: get lost.
Excuse me Brad, but
“From the picture it looks like there are lots of people enjoying the new park”
is not a great punchline cause it’s an architect’s rendering, not a photo. Please stop. Get back to the subject.
Frankly, the climate change argument is weak because the loss can easily be mitigated and we’re talking about drops in the bucket. There is, however, no compelling reason not to work around the healthy trees. They are all that will remain of the park’s antiquity and are the most attractive aspect of the park. Little rain gardens and what looks like artificial deck just doesn’t have the same feel and gravity.
A coffee stand and splash pad are terrible ideas. The thought that there will be water shooting up from the ground not only sounds expensive to maintain and ugly but also a reason not to bring my toddler there. The notion that a coffee-slinging spy will be an effective safety mechanism just hard to believe. Come on.
To me a great park would be open space with sporadic tree placement. No need to over think it and overspend.
Was there any thought to making the park 14 stories high?
Jokes aside, the park does need some renovations. I just hope that lady in the lower left has her frisbee playing dog on a leash. Bad dog owners will kill a park just as fast as anything else.
In response to BTVong above:
“The worst enemy of the trees and grass in that park is not climate change – it’s the lazy, homeless-by-choice thugs and addicts who spread their tarps and tents on the ground.
The tree huggers ought to switch their focus and go after the real problem: the bums in the park who come to Burlington, the socialist capital of the northeast – to collect welfare.”
The lions share of the damage is done by Farmer’s Market, which we would like to see taken entirely out of CHP, either to the surrounding streets, or more preferably, relocated to Battery Park. Additionally, Keep the Park Green is very aware there are behavioral problems in the park. To this end, we have suggested using some of the $3 million dollars the City wants to invest in the park “upgrade” (which will kill the historic park so many of us love), and pay for a full time ranger during the busy months (off-season availability would need to be considered as well).. This would be far superior to having eyes on the Park from those staffing the coffee cart, etc… Also, we would like the the City to provide more more appropriate housing for the homeless. Many have issues with mental illness, and we do a miserable job providing adequate services for them.
@stickinthemud
I think you are barking up the wrong tree.
Sometimes less is more when it comes to trees.
Weed out the deadwood.
From the picture it looks like there are lots of people enjoying the new park
Brad D wishes to spar:
“You do realize that the park right now looks nothing like the original City Hall Park. Maybe we should go back to the time when it was round.
As a matter of fact let’s go back to the time when the world was flat!”
Well, Brad, I can see that you do not get my point. I hope you do not fall off the world.