Burlingtonians opposed to the redesign of City Hall Park spoke out Wednesday night in defense of the trees.
About 50 members of the Keep the Park Green group turned out to a Development Review Board hearing at Burlington City Hall to argue in favor of keeping trees slated for removal as part of renovation plans for the park.
“The trees are the vibrancy of the park as we, the people, are the vibrancy of the city,” said Charlie Messing, a member of the group.
The city is slated to install a new fountain and walkways as part of the redesign. Under the current plans, the city would remove 34 of the park’s 56 trees. Sixteen new trees would be planted for a net total of 38 trees.
Wednesday marked the second DRB public hearing on the issue. After dozens of project opponents testified against the project at a February 20 meeting, the board scheduled another hearing to give the applicants an opportunity to respond and to allow more time for public input.
In the days following the meeting, some members of Keep the Park Green tied colorful ribbons around the trees and erected signs that read: “Epic Fail” and “I needed care, but didn’t get any.”
City arborist V.J. Comai offered a public tour of the park last week and found two trees that could be saved, and space for two more to be planted. “We did listen to the community on that one,” noted Cindi Wight, director of Burlington Parks, Recreation & Waterfront.
Comai on Wednesday noted that the trees slated for removal are in poor health, pose a safety risk, or don’t fit with the new design.
Approval from the DRB would be yet another step in a multiyear process to renovate the park. The board will likely give the final OK in the next week, said Scott Gustin, head of the city’s planning and zoning department. Construction is scheduled to start in 2019.
Opponents argued that taking down the trees exacerbates climate change.
“We’re in the midst of a global climate catastrophe, and if what’s being done will be making that more of a problem, that should be reconsidered,” said Jack Daggitt. He urged the city to create more park space using vacant lots.
Donna Walters, of Keep the Park Green, asked whether some of the trees could be relocated. “We don’t think healthy trees should be cut down,” she said.*
Gustin noted that the future of the trees doesn’t fall under the purview of the DRB, which decides whether the project meets the city’s zoning ordinance and whether the park provides a public benefit. So far, Gustin said, “it sure seems like it complies with the zoning code.”
Correction, March 8, 2018: A previous version of this story misquoted Donna Walters.




Looks like this design looks better for one of those corporate parks where employees can take lunch breaks and be monitored by their masters thanks to cameras and security everywhere.
Keep The Park Green needs YOU to ensure that our beautiful City Hall Park isn’t turned into a large concrete pad with almost no trees, almost no shade, & less grass!
Our organization revealed that the City didn’t disclose how many trees would be cut under this plan until the 11th hour, right before it was to go for final approval by the City’s Development Review Board (DRB).
Withholding key elements of this plan was wrong & people have spoken out, sending almost 200 emails to the DRB, saying that they didn’t want a plan leaving our park almost completely devoid of mature trees.
On March 7, we showed that the City’s plans presented inaccurate information that misled the public about the true numbers of trees to be cut. Thus, other City documents were also incorrect, including the plan’s tree cover diagrams & shade studies requested by the DRB.
Of the park’s current 56 mature trees, only 17 (or less) would remain under this plan. Only 14 saplings that won’t produce shade for decades will be installed.
The DRB hasn’t made its decision yet, but will hold a final deliberation on Monday, March 12, at City Hall. The public can’t comment, so we must speak with our presence & show the City that we want a better plan.
Most people don’t want a hot, exposed plaza that’s 1/3 paved surface, with less grass, a fraction of the existing trees, & 14 saplings that won’t provide shade for decades.
Lack of transparency is a big problem, but this Administration must respond to public scrutiny. Stand with us: March 12, at City Hall, lower level at 5 pm. Together we can get a plan that provides needed shade, & incorporates & protects our trees!
Facebook: KEEP THE PARK GREEN
If we want to be completely true to the history of the park, we could go back to a time when there were signs posted that said to keep off the grass, when benches were “For Ladies Only”. Or, further back, to when a nearby merchant was letting his sheep graze on it.
Or maybe even further, to when there was a hanging tree. (Kidding. Kidding.)
I love trees, and history, and while I understand the initial shock that comes with hearing there are a fairly decent number of City Hall Park trees that will be removed, I also understand we can no longer manage our downtown amenities with band-aids and half measures. There are trees that are unhealthy, density that worsens the problem and contributes to safety and security issues, and the fact that the park, as it stands, gets a poor rating from people who know about public engagement through amenities, because all you can do in our park is sit. Since an urban park is not exactly a break from the hustle and bustle of downtown life, we should do better than that.
I was once a proponent of keeping the park the same. Not anymore. Research, travel, and experience have changed my mind, and shown me the park could be so much more than it is.
Burlington deserves nothing less.
@stickinthemud
“Excuse me Brad”
Sometimes it’s just too easy.