On Thursday, February 18, Seven Days is teaming up with Channel 17/Town Meeting Television to host a public debate about Instant Runoff Voting. On Town Meeting Day, Burlington voters will have the opportunity to weigh in on whether the city should continue to use IRV to elect the mayor.

The debate will be between two IRV supporters, Rep. Mark Larson and Keri Toksu of the League of Women Voters, and two IRV opponents, Burlington lawyer Sandy Baird and Chuck Selene of One Person One Vote. 

A media panel, including Shay Totten of Seven Days, Bianca Slota of WCAX and John Briggs of the Burlington Free Press, will ask questions. Jess Wilson of Channel 17 will moderate. The audience will also have an opportunity to ask questions. There will be a mike for audience members, and we’ll be taking questions via a live chat on this blog.

The fun starts on Thursday, February 18, at 7 p.m. Come to Burlington City Hall Auditorium, or watch the debate live on Burlington Telecom and Comcast channel 17, or on the Seven Days website. Want to tweet about it? We’re using the hashtag #btvirv.

Seven Days’ deputy publisher and co-owner Cathy Resmer is a writer, editor and advocate for local journalism. She works in the paper’s Burlington office and lives vicariously through the reporters while raising money to pay them. Cathy started at Seven Days as a freelance writer in 2001 and still has the Rolodex to prove it. As the paper’s first online editor, she launched Seven Days email newsletters and started the paper’s first social media accounts. Cathy has overseen Kids VT, Vermont’s...

32 replies on “IRV Debate This Thursday”

  1. Thanks once again for yet another non-response response "Tommy"…you truly are a waste of everyone's time…ugh…

    "What facts can you offer to ameliorate my concerns?"
    There haven't been any instances of actual voter fraud with IRV. Also, I'm pretty darn sure that the ballots don't get transported from one place to another without an escort. This isn't Chicago where the dead vote…this is Burlington VT…wake up…fear-mongering is so 2003 Haik…

  2. You can say I’m whining or that the potential for cheating is a non-issue, but those are opinions, not facts.What facts can you offer to ameliorate my concerns?

  3. MisterGuy, you are obviously so much smarter than everyone, I abdicate my right to vote and will follow you. Thanks for shining the light into all my dark corners.

  4. "Whatever. No system is perfect, but it's still easier to swap out a memory card if the card has to travel."
    Whatever indeed Haik…your continued whining on this complete & total *non-issue* is a real bore at this point.

    "MisterDouche"…Internet Troll, period.

    "Its easier to vote for someone rather than some ones."
    Yea, because ranking one's choices is so, so very "hard"…not…

    Burlington will quite simply never have a Condorcet method way of voting implemented. Condorcet methods have not ever been used in govt. elections anywhere in the world.

  5. Alex and/or Haik, about Condorcet not being on the ballot next month: Think about it a little, one side or the other is going to lose next month. The side that loses will have their interests served far more with Condorcet than they will with whatever they’re gonna get. And the side that wins will have their *legitimate* concerns addressed with Condorcet. It’s a consensus methods that uses the same ranked-ballot that IRV uses (except Condorcet allows for ties on a single ballot).But, instead, we’re gonna have this knock-down, drag-out, go-for-broke slugfest that leaves only one side standing. Just like with the two-party system, it’s up or down with IRV.But the problem with the two-party system that we were trying to avoid with a ranked-ballot in the first place is that sometimes our choice with the two parties is between Dumb and Dumber. When Dumb and Dumber is our major party choice, we *need* viable third parties and independents to break out of that rut and keep both major parties focused on the needs of the electorate. What is so ironic in the up-or-down vote with IRV is that again, sadly, our choice is between Dumb and Dumber. So I guess I’ll have to vote for Dumb and be prepared that Dumber will win.

  6. Haik, I think the issue that you were alluding to (the necessity to count IRV ballots centrally) is called “precinct summability”. If you’re willing to have enough piles of ballots, any method is “precinct summable”, that is ballots can be counted at the precinct, the count results can be promulgated publicly (with interested parties monitoring and transmitting the same sums to their campaign headquarters) which would make it difficult for the ballots to be swapped en-route to City Hall (or wherever the central counting place is).Plurality and Condorcet are simply and elegantly precinct summable, but IRV requires a pile for every possible manner that a ballot could be marked. For 3 candidates, that would be 9 piles (and therefore 9 sums to transmit upward to the central counting location). For 4 candidates, it would be 40 piles (and 40 different sums) and the number of piles increases damn fast for more candidates than that. For Plurality it would be one pile per candidate and for Condorcet it would be one pair of sums for each pairing of candidates (3 sum pairs for 3 candidates, 6 sum pairs for 4 candidates, etc. …)It *is* a useful and legitimate concern to have precinct summability for statewide and nationwide elections. For a city as small as ours, I think the logistics of securely transmitting ballots to City Hall ain’t so bad.

Comments are closed.