This week in movies you missed: Want to see how America might look after a full economic collapse? Look at Detroit.
What You Missed
In this documentary, directors Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady (Jesus Camp) present present-day Detroit with little commentary. It starts with images: a young woman exploring abandoned buildings. Opera singers on stage. Grass encroaching on bricks and pavement.
Then we meet the people: a video blogger who loves the city too much to leave, just chronicles its decay. A union man who remembers when a string of vacant lots were thriving factories. A nightclub owner who quotes radical sociologists.
And we get the stats: In 1930, Detroit was the fastest-growing city in America. Now its the fastest shrinking. In the past 50 years, it lost half its population. Unemployment, the mayor says, stands at 50 percent. City government wants to move residents out of dying neighborhoods where its too costly to provide services, then turn them into urban gardens. Residents arent having it.
And the final irony: Now that prosperity has moved out of Detroit, the hipsters and starving artists are moving in.
Why You Missed It
You may have caught Detropia at last falls Vermont International Film Festival.
Should You Keep Missing It?
First the critique: By not providing expert commentary via talking heads, Ewing and Grady limit what they can do. Detropia doesnt feel like a comprehensive portrait of Detroit; it doesnt weigh the urban planners opinions against residents interests or suggest a solution to the citys woes.
Perhaps too much weight is given to the speechifying of the owner of the Raven Lounge a fascinating, passionate guy, but not necessarily informed in his views. Hes the one who voices the documentarys dark, underlying implication: As Detroit goes, so goes America. Then, in the DVD extras, he rants about Arabs, which suddenly makes him seem less like a credible armchair philosopher and more like an angry caller on AM radio.
But, as a fan of experiential documentaries, I loved Detropia as a moody, oddly beautiful experience that also provided some information. Some have criticized it for turning urban decay into found art (see the photo above). The film touches on the issue of exploitation in a scene where two young men from Switzerland admit they came to Detroit as tourists, because the ruins are more interesting than anything their home has to offer.
Crystal Starr, the video blogger, also finds the postapocalyptic landscape interesting. But for her, its something more: home.
Verdict: Do you take a strange pleasure in watching the mighty fall? Read Shelleys Ozymandias, then sit down and watch Detropia. And ask yourself whether it's really the empire builders who suffer most from an empire's collapse.
More New Off-the-Beaten Track DVDs
The Kid With a Bike (Dardenne brothers latest)
The Perks of Being a Wallflower (Awkward kid loves Hermione Granger, or whatever her name is here.)
Robot & Frank (Grouchy old guy plus near-future robot)
Each week in "Movies You Missed," I review a brand-new DVD release picked for me by Seth Jarvis, buyer for Burlington's Waterfront Video, where you can obtain these fine films. (In central Vermont, try Downstairs Video.)
Douglas Buchholz: Yes, let's all get a really good evaluating "education" on the so-called "Abenaki" groups in Vermont. Let's actually…
Chris in S. Burlington: I used to enjoy the occasional Bliss cartoon in the New Yorker and in Seven Days but his…
Isabella Fiske McFarlin: Our present plan is to expand the return to an artist's colony/ retreat in the next few years…